I do, otherwise it’s just wanton punishment for the sake of punishment. I believe in harm reduction, not harm multiplication, so if there is no benefit to the people involved or society and we’re still choosing punishment I generally disagree with punishment simply for the sake of punishment.
so for you it’s enough if a criminal “cured” from his desire to do crime, no punishment needed?
And as I said for myself: certainly not /just/ punishment, but also…
If we had a psycho pass system that could, with 100% certainty, confirm that a criminal will never commit any crimes again (ethical crimes, not necessarily legal crimes), I would say yes. The problem is that such a system doesn’t exist and it’s highly likely that criminals will be repeat offenders, so we have to “guess” that they are rehabilitated after the punishment.
I don’t think revenge punishment should exist in a just society, only harm minimisation. The punishment needs to be either a deterrent, rehabilitation tool, or harm containment tool, not revenge.
if someone kills one I love, I fear I’d have the need to see them suffer. Surely, I’d personally punish harder in this case, but the law should find a balance here.
Anyway, as you say: we don’t have that system, so we are just discussing the reasons for jail time, not the the if.
Comments
I see it as both, rehabilitation and punishment. I don’t think there are many who only the rehabilitation…
I do, otherwise it’s just wanton punishment for the sake of punishment. I believe in harm reduction, not harm multiplication, so if there is no benefit to the people involved or society and we’re still choosing punishment I generally disagree with punishment simply for the sake of punishment.
so for you it’s enough if a criminal “cured” from his desire to do crime, no punishment needed? And as I said for myself: certainly not /just/ punishment, but also…
Actually yes, I do feel this way. You stated it exactly.
If we had a psycho pass system that could, with 100% certainty, confirm that a criminal will never commit any crimes again (ethical crimes, not necessarily legal crimes), I would say yes. The problem is that such a system doesn’t exist and it’s highly likely that criminals will be repeat offenders, so we have to “guess” that they are rehabilitated after the punishment.
I don’t think revenge punishment should exist in a just society, only harm minimisation. The punishment needs to be either a deterrent, rehabilitation tool, or harm containment tool, not revenge.
if someone kills one I love, I fear I’d have the need to see them suffer. Surely, I’d personally punish harder in this case, but the law should find a balance here.
Anyway, as you say: we don’t have that system, so we are just discussing the reasons for jail time, not the the if.
Sign in to comment. Sign in