Comment on Green Party Candidate Appears to Win Hawaii House Seat in Historic Legislative Victory
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
I have no strong opinions on Jill Stein, but maybe she thinks running as a third party is the better idea for whatever reason? Being a third party is clearly the point here.
Well in a way you’re not wrong — running third party is definitely the point, but it’s to enable Republicans via Spoiler Effect.. There is no other rational explanation. If she legitimately cared about the issues, she’d join from within.
Though then again we saw how much damage Sinema did with that strategy as a turncoat.
Again you’re assuming that without evidence. There are third parties in first past the post countries that actually get things done, like the UK Greens or Canada’s NDP, so it’s clearly not impossible.
Totally different ballgame! FPTP aside, those are parliamentary systems – and not a national winner-take-all race for President as Stein runs for.
As far as this House Seat the party won? Hey that’s cool, good for them. But Stein splitting the votes every 4 years? She can fuck right off.
Again, the Spoiler Effect. is a mathematical inevitability that only ever enables fascist righties when Greens run nationally here in the USA.
Put another way: logically, it is easier to reform one of the two parties than it is to dethrone them. Just as DSA is doing right now with Democrats; just as Tea Party – astroturfed or not – did to Republicans as the predecessor to MAGA. Ergo, that either leaves one of two options: (1) She’s dumb, or (2) She has ulterior motives.
I doubt Stein is gunning for a victory; apparently getting 5% of the popular vote entitles parties to federal funding. It’s not a bad idea if they can pull it off. The spoiler effect also applies in any FPTP system so I’m not sure on what basis you’re excluding parliamentary systems.
Again, she could simply tap the existing Democratic infrastructure — Just as AOC did. Just as Bernie did when he ran under the Democratic ticket. Just as AES. Just as Talarico did.
I think it’s bad when it can lead to a fascist getting in office for a full 4 years from the Spoiler Effect.
Let’s… Not support this crap. For two decades on the scene, her activism scorecard in between elections is also sorely lacking.
That’s all I have left to say on this.
Sign in to comment. Sign in