Skip to content

Comment on Re-insulating my attic, thermal camera shows footprints

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Are you taking the old insulation out, or just putting new on top? If you’re removing it, I’d like to know how you are managing it.

    8
    • It’s fiberglass, not vermiculite, so less likely to be asbestos contaminated. Though I didn’t specifically test it.

      I took out about 30 square feet of the stuff before deciding I didn’t want to do that anymore.

      It’s clean, no dead stuff or mouse droppings, so I don’t feel bad about leaving it in. It’s easily compressible, old crappy stuff.

      It’s an 8 inch joist, so I squished some 10 inch unfaced batting on top of it, pressing the old stuff flat.

      You can see the difference in temp on the ceiling:

      https://sh.itjust.works/pictrs/image/fa82ab04-6143-4653-bd84-69c3661a06d2.jpeg

      https://sh.itjust.works/pictrs/image/97a0f997-69f3-44fe-b52e-e504bc417b4e.jpeg

      16
      • In case you didn’t know, compressing insulation can make it a lot less insulating. Not sure if the impact of 30% compression but figured I’d say something

        12
        • I’d imagine that compressing 10 inch insulation into 8 inches will of course reduce efficiency compared to the full 10 inches. But I doubt it’s much worse than if they just used 8 inch insulation in the first place.

          It will be more expensive using 10 inch instead of 8 inch, but I doubt the difference between the two in the same 8 inches is significant.

          2
          • Fun fact! Compressing 10 inches into 8 does reduce the R value that it could’ve been, but, compared to just buying 8 inch insulation, the R value is slightly higher.

            So the only thing you’re really losing is the extra money it costs for those two inches you aren’t using.

            In my case, the only way to get 8 x 15 unfaced is to special order it. I didn’t want to, and it’s good because I overestimated by 4 rolls, which would’ve been hard to return.

            Additionally, in the sections where I had to remove the old insulation, I found it a little tricky to get the 10 inch stuff to even loft up to 8, I can’t imagine buying 8 and trying to get it to loft properly.

            4
            • Fair enough, I wasnt sure on the full impact of the R value reduction but figured out was worth commenting. Glad you know what you are doing, at least more than I do lol

              1
        • Thanks for looking out for me! I was aware of this, here’s the detailed comment:

          https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28629103

          1

Sign in to comment. Sign in