Skip to content

Comment on human rules activism

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • see that’s why i think of it as a straw man.in my experience, people advocating for the death penalty tend to think of criminal punishment primarily as… punishment, rather than the attempt att rehabilitation we’ve come to largely agree that it is.

    most people, i think, recognise that a majority of criminal activity is born, directly or indirectly, from circumstance. therefore, most criminals act out of a perceived necessity. the criminal justice system exists to make sure that these people are rehabilitated (with varying effectiveness…), and that they are kept from society until they are. the punishment is the separation, the penance is rehabilitation.

    the punishment view seems to me more like an “eye for an eye” mindset. they did an illegal thing, so they should suffer. i’ve seen the view that the death penalty is “too good” for certain criminals, but i’ve never seen someone be anti-death penalty, pro-torture. i guess if you count the people ambiguous to prison reform into the pro-torture camp you’ll bump the headcount somewhat.

    0
    • I see what you’re getting at, but, again, I think that’s mainly because I didn’t express myself very clearly. I specifically didn’t mention ‘opponents of the death penalty’; instead, I asked: ‘How can anyone be against the death penalty […]’. I agree with you that it’s worded rather vaguely, but I would argue that both your interpretation and my intended meaning are reasonable, and think it’s a bit unfair to dismiss this as a straw man argument.

      1
      • intent is hard in text form, yeah. i feel like the way you’ve contrasted those two sentences there highlights the problem: “how can anyone…” implies that some people do. without demonstrating that this is in fact a real opinion that people hold, it is a textbook strawman. if the intent was instead to raise the discussion of whether the sort of person alluded to does exist, the wording is not only vague but wrong.

        so, for my confused mind: what was the intent here?

        1
        • I feel that I can no longer give you a straight answer to that without undermining the abstract art that has emerged from this silly post. Interpret the intention in whatever way suits you best and gives you the most. :)

          2

Sign in to comment. Sign in