Amazon’s Decoy Deals: Investigation Reveals Nearly 1 in 3 Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Advertised by Amazon Offered No Savings to Shoppers, Nearly 1 in 10 Were Actually More Expensive
The Keepa browser extension has saved me a great deal of money. Like noticing that a wood chipper goes on sale for half off for 2 hours roughly every 6 months and then sending me an alert when it happened. You can get things new for less than you’d pay on the used market with those alerts. I got a lot of woodworking tools at lowest-ever prices that way as well.
This is very easy problem to solve from a legal point of view (the EU solved it in 2019 in two sentences). It’s also a easy win for politicians, so if you want to stop the scam in the US, it’s probably just one email to your representative away.
Any announcement of a price reduction shall indicate the prior price applied by the trader for a determined period of time prior to the application of the price reduction.
The prior price means the lowest price applied by the trader during a period of time not shorter than 30 days prior to the application of the price reduction.
While we have no such legal protection in the us, I do see articles claiming that Amazon does similar. If a seller defines a sale, Amazon adjusts the reference price to 30 day price.
Of course I didn’t see a country referenced so perhaps it only for eu or something
It’s still a problem with the 30 day limit though, so many companies raises their prices 31 days before the sale is about to begin… It should really be at least 90 days, but preferably 6-12 months for it to have some real effect.
That requires the seller to keep a price above what they think it’s the optimal sale price for a very long time. It’s a gamble that would only pay off if most of their direct competitors did the same.
That behaviour would be specifically illegal in the UK and I should imagine UK authorities would love a juice fine payment from Amazon if they were caught; you cannot advertise something is an offer without having a majority period where the price was higher.
I read a few years ago about a trick a lot of manufacturers were up to where a TV with a model number like 47VTP-84780T would have exactly the same internals as 47VTS-84799P and some superficial difference on the casing.
The reason for the existence of 47VTP-84780T was to be offered at an arbitrarily high price in one store for a three month period, in order to be “70% OFF!!!” nationwide for Black Friday.
Why should governments profit off theft? That money should go back to the people that it was stolen from. They steal from us then they get “fined” which is paying off politicians then everyone has an incentive to rip the people off for money.
i mean this is obvious to anyone thats paid attention. their black friday, prime day, cyber monday, all their big sales… they jack up the prices leading up to the sale, slapp’m back down to normal and then say 50% off.
I watched a program years ago that was about scammers…
One of the main points was that when people got e.g. a letter from the Prince in Nigeria or wherever, the email usually had loads of spelling mistakes on purpose.
They weren’t after the people who spotted those, they were after the people that didn’t.
I think Amazon works in a similar way, and maybe some sellers on it.
They’re not after the people who monitor the prices during the sales, they’re after the people who don’t.
For myself, I do very little business with Amazon, but when I have to, it’s usually at least days in advance of when I am going to buy, I use a different browser behind a VPN where I am not signed in, and of course being logged out I cannot put anything in the cart or in Save for Later. Instead, I keep a text file with the listing name, the stripped link (nothing after /db/itemnumber), and the price at the time.
If I still want it when I’m ready to buy, I plug in the stripped link that I saved earlier, see if it’s still at that price, and buy it then. Or not. But either way, there is zero history involved that ties me to that item on the Amazon side and I will get the best price available for that specific item at that moment in time.
Is it a pain in the ass? Yes. But as much as is possible I don’t let Amazon gamify me. I never, ever shop Amazon signed in. Keeping items in the cart or Save for Later just tells them how better to manipulate your spending.
And you might be surprised at just how much NOT letting them know what you are interested in buying saves you in the end. I have even seen “sale” or “introductory price” offers that disappeared for me as soon as I logged in.
For me it’s worth the trouble. Fuck Amazon and fuck Bezos.
This was interesting to read. As a noob at this stuff, how do I know where to cut off links to strip them without deleting too much? Is it different for every website?
If you’re on an Android device, you can try an app such as URLCheck. A lot of times, it’s anything after the question mark, but that’s not always true. You can try deleting part of the url then see if the stripped down part still works, and you’ll start to see the patterns.
Again, that’s only for Amazon. Arguments can contain all kinds of information, not just trackers, and some pages won’t open without them. The only way to know on any site is to guess: strip out all the arguments (the bits after the question mark) and simply try the new, stripped link. If it works, it works.
This isn’t new from online, this is is standard instore brick and mortar for decades for Black Friday and Boxing Day, and other type of sales. Inflate the price leading up, and drop it, so it appears on sale at the regular price.
Also, only have a few of the door crashers, so you get in the store and buy something else if you don’t get it.
the brick n.mortar stores usually mark up their prices in the lead up to black friday so that on the day they can appear to be dropping them but in actuality, they just dropped them back to where they started
That’s why I am trying to avoid Amazon. I’ve been looking for other European alternatives. Though unfortunately, there are little better alternatives since many don’t deliver to Ireland.
There are a few that do, but also try the manufacturers, or the Amazon sellers website.
CDiscount.com (France) have sellers that will ship to Ireland, usually for €10ish. but in the last year or so they removed the filter that allowed you to select country to ship to, which makes it harder to find them, and cdiscount are impossible to contact.
Germany have many mail forwarding options - I use mailboxde which ship to Ireland based on weight and whether or not there’s a battery (and shipping time).
Can still save quite a bit using them.
but in the last year or so they removed the filter that allowed you to select country to ship to, which makes it harder to find them, and cdiscount are impossible to contact.
I signed up on CDiscount to order an eBook reader until it said they don’t deliver to Ireland.
Yeah, 3rd party sellers will ship to Ireland, but harder to filter which ones now. I bought a pixel recently, and bought a 5-in-1 garden tool at the start of summer.
This isn’t even for the holidays. I see stuff go for, say, 40% off constantly as a “limited time deal” and then notice that the seller upped the original price to make 40% off just a few dollars under the normal price.
The Camel is Amazon only. Tweakers is about every electronic item, and tracking everything attach to it (so also specs, and price history). They also have in depy performance reviews of like home batteries. I doubt that Camel has such things, but I only looked quickly around
This has been the case for years, and not to defend Amazon, but the solution is right in the middle of the listing.
There is a link for Price History directly beside the price of the item. It goes back 30 days, 3 months, and 1 year. You can literally check the price for the item right there.
I know that we need consumer protections, but at what point does reading comprehension and a little due diligence come into play?
The reason Amazon, and other retailers, get away with this year after year is that they’ve already made their price histories available, and they depend on marketing and gullibility to press sales, as has been the case since humanity began trading.
One of the tricks they do is move items between sellers and release identical versions with new price history so you cannot see what its actually sold for in the past.
I always put stuff in the “save for later” list for awhile before I purchase things to see if I really needed it (i often don’t) and when you do this you can see how often things are just “no longer available from this seller” and magically appear from another seller for a higher price. That seems to be how they do price changes normally now.
Install Keepa, a browser extension that shows you a nice little price grid right in the product page.
Or you can ask their built-in AI for the price history, but that feels gross. I wouldn’t trust it.
Honey colluded with the sites to provide a discount, not the best discount. The sellers had control over the price. It also stripped the affiliate data from the transaction, meaning the influencers pedaling Honey didn’t even get paid.
Iirc honey would automatically apply coupons to your cart, but would also silently inject affiliate info so they got a cut or something like that. I don’t think honey ever offered a price history chart.
Comments
Reposting myself:
or keepa
The Keepa browser extension has saved me a great deal of money. Like noticing that a wood chipper goes on sale for half off for 2 hours roughly every 6 months and then sending me an alert when it happened. You can get things new for less than you’d pay on the used market with those alerts. I got a lot of woodworking tools at lowest-ever prices that way as well.
Keepa is way better imo, I tried both a while back and settled on it.
Keep a what
eye on prices
deez
nuts?
Yay, we did it, Lemmy?
I don’t even look at the deals. I just wait for ccc alerts for things I actually want on my ccc watchlist.
Upvoted for utility, yet I i prefer to not Amazon, personally.
I know it’s like shouting into a storm, but stop using Amazon. All of your excuses are bogus.
Better yet, stop buying crap you don’t need.
This is very easy problem to solve from a legal point of view (the EU solved it in 2019 in two sentences). It’s also a easy win for politicians, so if you want to stop the scam in the US, it’s probably just one email to your representative away.
There’s a lot of sentences there, which two are you referring to?
Its probably Article 2, Amendments to Directive 98/6/EC, the first two sentences.
Excerpt here
While we have no such legal protection in the us, I do see articles claiming that Amazon does similar. If a seller defines a sale, Amazon adjusts the reference price to 30 day price.
Of course I didn’t see a country referenced so perhaps it only for eu or something
Hahahaha you said Americans are represented by their leaders. That’s funny.
We have to wait for Europe to sue the fuck out of companies for anything to happen.
It’s still a problem with the 30 day limit though, so many companies raises their prices 31 days before the sale is about to begin… It should really be at least 90 days, but preferably 6-12 months for it to have some real effect.
That requires the seller to keep a price above what they think it’s the optimal sale price for a very long time. It’s a gamble that would only pay off if most of their direct competitors did the same.
That behaviour would be specifically illegal in the UK and I should imagine UK authorities would love a juice fine payment from Amazon if they were caught; you cannot advertise something is an offer without having a majority period where the price was higher.
I read a few years ago about a trick a lot of manufacturers were up to where a TV with a model number like 47VTP-84780T would have exactly the same internals as 47VTS-84799P and some superficial difference on the casing.
The reason for the existence of 47VTP-84780T was to be offered at an arbitrarily high price in one store for a three month period, in order to be “70% OFF!!!” nationwide for Black Friday.
Why should governments profit off theft? That money should go back to the people that it was stolen from. They steal from us then they get “fined” which is paying off politicians then everyone has an incentive to rip the people off for money.
I happen to live in a country where “the government” collecting money means “we collect money”.
i mean this is obvious to anyone thats paid attention. their black friday, prime day, cyber monday, all their big sales… they jack up the prices leading up to the sale, slapp’m back down to normal and then say 50% off.
That’s been standard retail practice for decades.
But tons of people still fall for the hype without thinking, so the sellers keep doing it.
Having used Amazon for some years now, I suspect it’s far more than 33%
I watched a program years ago that was about scammers… One of the main points was that when people got e.g. a letter from the Prince in Nigeria or wherever, the email usually had loads of spelling mistakes on purpose. They weren’t after the people who spotted those, they were after the people that didn’t.
I think Amazon works in a similar way, and maybe some sellers on it.
They’re not after the people who monitor the prices during the sales, they’re after the people who don’t.
[deleted]
Finally, I shouldn’t have had to scroll down this far to find someone showing an appropriate and justifiable level of contempt.
Only 1 in 3? TBH i assumed that literally none of the deals offer any savings.
I am pretty sure this has been known for years, at least I have.
Prices going up weeks before Black Friday, so they could “discount” it to the normal price on Black Friday.
For myself, I do very little business with Amazon, but when I have to, it’s usually at least days in advance of when I am going to buy, I use a different browser behind a VPN where I am not signed in, and of course being logged out I cannot put anything in the cart or in Save for Later. Instead, I keep a text file with the listing name, the stripped link (nothing after /db/itemnumber), and the price at the time.
If I still want it when I’m ready to buy, I plug in the stripped link that I saved earlier, see if it’s still at that price, and buy it then. Or not. But either way, there is zero history involved that ties me to that item on the Amazon side and I will get the best price available for that specific item at that moment in time.
Is it a pain in the ass? Yes. But as much as is possible I don’t let Amazon gamify me. I never, ever shop Amazon signed in. Keeping items in the cart or Save for Later just tells them how better to manipulate your spending.
And you might be surprised at just how much NOT letting them know what you are interested in buying saves you in the end. I have even seen “sale” or “introductory price” offers that disappeared for me as soon as I logged in.
For me it’s worth the trouble. Fuck Amazon and fuck Bezos.
This was interesting to read. As a noob at this stuff, how do I know where to cut off links to strip them without deleting too much? Is it different for every website?
If you’re on an Android device, you can try an app such as URLCheck. A lot of times, it’s anything after the question mark, but that’s not always true. You can try deleting part of the url then see if the stripped down part still works, and you’ll start to see the patterns.
The arguments (the various codes and characters that appear after the page address) in a given URL are different for every website.
But on Amazon, every link looks something like this (I made this up, these are not valid links):
https://www.amazon.com/item-listing-or-name/dp/ABCDE12345?blahblahblahblahEverything including and after that first question mark can go. All you really need is this part, the basic page address:
https://www.amazon.com/item-listing-or-name/dp/ABCDE12345Again, that’s only for Amazon. Arguments can contain all kinds of information, not just trackers, and some pages won’t open without them. The only way to know on any site is to guess: strip out all the arguments (the bits after the question mark) and simply try the new, stripped link. If it works, it works.
you don’t even need the ‘item-listing-or-name’ after the domain name, just /dp/asin
amazon.com/dp/B07THZYFB4
the asin doesn’t need to be in CAPS either,
This isn’t new from online, this is is standard instore brick and mortar for decades for Black Friday and Boxing Day, and other type of sales. Inflate the price leading up, and drop it, so it appears on sale at the regular price.
Also, only have a few of the door crashers, so you get in the store and buy something else if you don’t get it.
the brick n.mortar stores usually mark up their prices in the lead up to black friday so that on the day they can appear to be dropping them but in actuality, they just dropped them back to where they started
That’s why I am trying to avoid Amazon. I’ve been looking for other European alternatives. Though unfortunately, there are little better alternatives since many don’t deliver to Ireland.
There are a few that do, but also try the manufacturers, or the Amazon sellers website. CDiscount.com (France) have sellers that will ship to Ireland, usually for €10ish. but in the last year or so they removed the filter that allowed you to select country to ship to, which makes it harder to find them, and cdiscount are impossible to contact. Germany have many mail forwarding options - I use mailboxde which ship to Ireland based on weight and whether or not there’s a battery (and shipping time). Can still save quite a bit using them.
I signed up on CDiscount to order an eBook reader until it said they don’t deliver to Ireland.
Thanks for the information. That explained a lot!
Yeah, 3rd party sellers will ship to Ireland, but harder to filter which ones now. I bought a pixel recently, and bought a 5-in-1 garden tool at the start of summer.
This isn’t even for the holidays. I see stuff go for, say, 40% off constantly as a “limited time deal” and then notice that the seller upped the original price to make 40% off just a few dollars under the normal price.
i use keepa to look at thier price history, yea they do that for alot of items.
Just call it what it is, a scam.
Show of hands: who didn’t already know, or deeply suspect, this?
We have Tweaker. An independent website who actually tracks this, and then shows you actual good black Friday deals
I’ve always relied on CamelCamelCamel. What makes Tweaker different, other than the methhead-inspired name?
The Camel is Amazon only. Tweakers is about every electronic item, and tracking everything attach to it (so also specs, and price history). They also have in depy performance reviews of like home batteries. I doubt that Camel has such things, but I only looked quickly around
Keepa is way better than CamelCamelCamel, I’ve tried both.
I actively use both and have for years. Keeps works well for some things but generally I find it’s data to be less accurate and slower to update.
Do you have a link?
https://tweakers.net/deals/black-friday/echte-techdeals
[deleted]
You know without this post, I would have forgotten about Black Friday.
So what? You have to check reviews from multiple sources anyway to not get scammed. Most often, there are prices near the reviews. Compare them.
This has been the case for years, and not to defend Amazon, but the solution is right in the middle of the listing.
There is a link for Price History directly beside the price of the item. It goes back 30 days, 3 months, and 1 year. You can literally check the price for the item right there.
I know that we need consumer protections, but at what point does reading comprehension and a little due diligence come into play?
The reason Amazon, and other retailers, get away with this year after year is that they’ve already made their price histories available, and they depend on marketing and gullibility to press sales, as has been the case since humanity began trading.
One of the tricks they do is move items between sellers and release identical versions with new price history so you cannot see what its actually sold for in the past.
I always put stuff in the “save for later” list for awhile before I purchase things to see if I really needed it (i often don’t) and when you do this you can see how often things are just “no longer available from this seller” and magically appear from another seller for a higher price. That seems to be how they do price changes normally now.
TIL; I never noticed you could click on the price. However the first thing I spot checked am was tagged 90 low price and I can see that history!
I generally don’t buy something unless and until I need it so sales prices don’t usually help but I wish I’d noticed that before
It doesn’t because people, year after year, just elect themselves to be duped this way. They don’t pay attention because they don’t care.
Install Keepa, a browser extension that shows you a nice little price grid right in the product page. Or you can ask their built-in AI for the price history, but that feels gross. I wouldn’t trust it.
Camelcamelcamel works too, but from my experience using the built in price history and 3p sites give the same results
Wasn’t that the whole point if the Honey extension, and it turned out to be some sort of scam?
Honey colluded with the sites to provide a discount, not the best discount. The sellers had control over the price. It also stripped the affiliate data from the transaction, meaning the influencers pedaling Honey didn’t even get paid.
Well, I’m glad this is unique to Honey and not a problem for any other website or extension tool.
Iirc honey would automatically apply coupons to your cart, but would also silently inject affiliate info so they got a cut or something like that. I don’t think honey ever offered a price history chart.
Nah honey gave you discount codes to use, not a price history
Ah got it. What was the scam? Was it somehow inserting affiliate links or something?
I believe inserting its own affiliate links with a side of shaking down sites to stop offering discounts
Thanks. That’s wild. I personally never used it, since it seemed sorta scammy.
Oh cool. So basically Groupon
Rug pull economy.
When going to the store is cheaper than Amazon and Temu.
Sounds like a great class action.
https://fashionlawjournal.com/fake-discounts/
Sign in to comment. Sign in