Skip to content

Comment on The culprit

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • “Lieu” is ‘in place of’, so to be the lieutenant is to be the ‘tenant’, the person in place, in lieu of a captain.

    If the captain is gone, the second in command is left-tenant, the tenant who is left.

    I’m sure the real answer is some dissatisfying essay about regional dialects and poor handwriting, but I’d like to Mandala Effect this better answer.

    20
    • “Leftenant” is actually the older, less adulterated form of the word.

      In traditional military units going way back, you’d have a formation of troops all in a line. On the right side of that formation would be the commander. On the left side would be the commander’s “left tenant”.

      “Lieutenant” is just a result of people saying “Leftenant” quickly, without care to pronunciation, and – after a certain point in history – forgetting what the word originally meant. “Leftenant” --> “Leatenant” --> “Lieutenant”

      6
      • No, I don’t think it works. “Lieutenant” comes from “tenir lieu”, that is “taking the place of”, “acting as”. Nothing to do with the left side. That’s why they are just below captain or colonel: they can replace them but don’t have the actual rank.

        14
        • Nah, he is totally correct. Because in the US they are called rightenents. See, the formations follow the cultural disposition for which side of the road is to be used.

          8
          • What you say is so true, that in comparison Truth itself sounds like a lie.

            3

Sign in to comment. Sign in