Skip to content

Comment on Tree TERF rule

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Ok, I knew trees were not a monophyletic group. But didn’t know the wood thing.

    Someone please elaborate on that part. Why are palms not wood? I’m assuming bamboo isn’t either?

    5
    • I’m not sure about palms but isn’t bamboo just like, grass on roids or something?

      7
      • It seems you’re spot on

        Palm trees, despite their tree-like appearance, have a unique structure that sets them apart from traditional woody trees. Their trunks are actually made of a dense, fibrous material that is more akin to a thick, woody grass than to the solid wood found in trees like oaks or pines. This material, often referred to as palm wood, is composed of the tightly packed leaf sheaths that form the trunk. While it provides support and stability, it lacks the lignin and cellulose that characterize true wood.

        https://woodrio.com/article/are-palm-trees-made-of-wood

        14
        • Hmm, so according to this page:

          The major components of bamboo are cellulose, hemi-cellulose, and lignin, taking up above 90% of the whole weight

          Which would mean that based on the implied definition you quoted, bamboo is wood. Which I admit, does rather go against my intuition.

          3
          • bamboo is absolutely wild and i love it: it grows so fucking ludicrously fast that you can see it under the right circumstances, the shoots are edible, and the mature plant is so fucking robust that you can use it to make industrial scaffolding.

            It’s kind of bizarre it’s not a more popular material, like i’ve got some cutting boards made of bamboo and unless you look at the grain structure you wouldn’t notice it’s not normal wood! Fucking give me cheap bamboo furniture!

            5
            • I know part of the problem is that in North America it has the capacity to be invasive. We absolutely should be using it more often as a cheap wood alternative and an eco friendly plastic alternative, but at least here in North America we do need to show some care with it to ensure we don’t wind up even further damaging our struggling forests

              2
          • That’s why bamboo is so popular for rayon production. Fun fact: rayon and cellophane are both just cellulose and therefore can decompose

            0

Sign in to comment. Sign in