Skip to content

Comment on Tree TERF rule

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Truth and lies require an arbiter, and you can’t really define whose truth is more correct than anyone else’s without creating a system where some ideas and beliefs are oppressed. Consensus reality is oppressive to ideas, but not all oppression of ideas is harmful (or even the same degree of harmful). If antivaxxers are using flawed or false science, by whose standards are they flawed or false? How can we know for certain they are using flawed or false science without a comparison?

    As for science… The scientific method is based specifically on the concept that there is an objective truth to the world that can be found, or else peer reviews and reconstructing experiments would essentially be pointless. You can argue our subjective realities make finding what is objective truth difficult, but that still makes for an objective reality.

    0
    • you can’t really define whose truth is more correct than anyone else’s without creating a system where some ideas and beliefs are oppressed

      “Oppressed” is a strong word to describe catching someone out on a lie. I believe in having systems like public opinion, universities, scientific communities. I just think axiology should precede epistemology in their methods of defining truth, to paraphrase Tyson Yunkaporta’s work on Indigenous Standpoint; the point is not to find the one objective truth, it’s to find the many truths with the potential to make our lives better. And of course, different subjective worlds would have different systems for using truth, so a harmful idea in one world might be welcomed in another. Hence, the value of the subjective multiverse.

      The scientific method is based specifically on the concept that there is an objective truth to the world that can be found, or else peer reviews and reconstructing experiments would essentially be pointless

      What makes you think the work of review, validation, and replication depends on objectivity? I would think it depends merely on commonality of experience. Certainly commonality is valuable, but why do you think it depends on objectivity?

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in