Skip to content

Comment on Rule

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Pointlessly gendered.

    33
    • Nah, there’s a point in how women tend to be raised to cater to others before themselves. Plus Miisha is a woman and will naturally identify with those points. Stating something is one way doesn’t mean that there aren’t men that have similar habits.

      15
      • What you said is quite fair, and I agree. To a point. In any space that was mainly for women I would never have commented this. Or at all ;)

        I should not have dropped the simple sound bite when I didn’t have time to explain my thoughts better. That was silly of me.

        But in general ‘if someone has these feelings/traits they must be a woman’ is rather exclusive and it really did ‘hit’ me for a sec before I reined in my autonomous reactions.

        15
      • Nah, there’s a point in how women tend to be raised to cater to others before themselves.

        Trans men generally faced the same pressures.

        Plus Miisha is a woman and will naturally identify with those points.

        Didn’t she transition in adulthood? (Miisha, please feel free to correct me there) That’s actually directly in conflict with your previous point.

        Stating something is one way doesn’t mean that there aren’t men that have similar habits.

        “Behind every…” literally does mean that.

        5
        • Didn’t she transition in adulthood? (Miisha, please feel free to correct me there) That’s actually directly in conflict with your previous point.

          There’s no contradiction there unless you just assume that societal messaging about the place of women and girls just flies over closeted trans girls’ heads instead of hitting and sticking for some reason.

          9
          • Good point, I hadn’t considered that. However, I do think a lot of parents are more subtle with their enforcement of gender roles, saying “you need to do this and not that” and not “girls need to do this and not that,” which certainly seems like it would lessen the impact on closeted trans girls. My own experience isn’t terribly useful, since my parents actively avoided gendering behavior, but I’m sure some still crept in, and it wouldn’t have been labeled as such.

            See also: the number of trans people who start passing and are surprised at how they’re treated. They were always in the general proximity of people who were treated that way, but experiencing it is another level.

            0
            • Sure, but kids are a lot more observant than most adults will give them credit for, and will also learn gendered dynamics by observing and emulating tendencies in the general culture around them, often subconsciously,.

              See also: the number of trans people who start passing and are surprised at how they’re treated. They were always in the general proximity of people who were treated that way, but experiencing it is another level.

              Could you please be a bit more specific? I’m genuinely unsure what specific experiences you’re talking about here, and I don’t wanna put words in your mouth by just assuming.
              Just speaking to my own experiences here, I haven’t been particularly surprised by how people have treated me since passing.

              3
              Continue this thread 2 more replies
        • @velma@sh.itjust.works· · edited

          Transitioning in adulthood doesn’t mean one doesn’t go through their own journey or second-puberty/second-adolescence that has similar influences to cis people.

          “Behind every…” literally does mean that.

          Fair, I missed that lol. I think an addendum could easily be added to include others who have similar anxious-attachment styles in relationships :)

          3

Sign in to comment. Sign in