You can get mad at ‘higher-ups’ who help a problem to continue and continue but it is the people ‘down-unders’ who hold up the base that have made this prpblem to even be started. These people are more worthy of our hate. The people down under make this problem start by supporting companies like rockstar and then continuing and continuing to support companies like rockstar when they bust unions or when they fail t o deliver what customers asked for.
Kind of a chicken and the egg kinda issue tho. Rockstar wouldnt be able to get away with this if there wasnt a subsection of mouth breathing customers who willingly spread their cheeks to get fucked over. Theyll literally drop $60 for the same 2K with a roster that couldve been an updated
Yeah I also have seen the very same people who are Disney, marvel, Nintendo, Steam/Valve fans hand wave these same shitty practices away because they like the art the company distributes.
Some people think being anti-capitalist means you can’t enjoy stuff made by huge companies that have shitty practices. Some of yall are gonna have to stop playing video games and watching TV/Movies altogether.
I don’t get the hype for this game, even GTA 5 felt boring to me and I’ve never finished it. Is it that normies only know 1 or 2 games like GTA and FIFA so these things are a big deal for them?
I guess I get that, I enjoyed traveling around the map listening to the radio in San Andreas, but I liked the whacky and goofy nature of those early GTA games, but in GTA 5 it felt like they turned the game into a reality simulator and I don’t care for that, I game to escape my reality not to roam around in a photo real simulation of it.
Some people do only RP servers and basically only play GTA. Not for me, but i have played about 4000 hours of factory based games so I shouldn’t be talking shit about this sort of thing.
Ive never played GTA RP but my understanding is that it’s like a separate client or mod or something. The big one (only one? Biggest one?) is called FiveM.
V also has its quirks. For example if you’re in some sort of game lobby with others (not the main hub, but the missions, races, etc.) and then get into the loading screen, then tab out of the game, it will not continue to load until you get back. Everybody else will also have to wait.
5 online was getting shot by angry dicks who wanted to always play the hiest. I was in my early 20’s excited to play it and all it was, was the same as all the other games.
5 disks to load it, only to be disappointed. Fuck man it felt like call of duty multi-player was a better choice at the time. At least cod made sense but gta 5 online was just senseless useless bullshit with almost no time between respawning and getting shot.
I mean gta is a ghetto-gweedo-mobster lifestyle simulation game so what can I expect but to just be killed the moment I repawn and it felt like I should’ve been playing COD.
I stopped playing it after I realized I am not going to be able to reach any part of the map online without being auto killed after respawning. There was no chance to level anything up or get any new weapons.
My fault for waiting until I could get the game half off and my fault for thinking online would be playable.
In general, AAA games weren’t able to fit on a physical disc for decades already, that’s why this recent backlash about it was stupid from the beginning. We needed to talk about getting rid of DRM, but conversation shifted to disks as if that will fix anything.
If you mean the physical disks of the 70s-90s, I’m with you, but things like Blu-ray gave us so much more storage. A single sided quad layer blu-ray disc holds 128GB, dual sided triple layer disc’s come in at around 200GB.
As someone that had to shuffle discs all the time growing up, the game could definitely come on disc’s if they wanted to.
They just want to have the ability to rip it from your library. They just want you to never have access to the games that you purchased and will never call it renting because they want to keep customers.
We all know we’re renting by now. You don’t purchase a game, you purchase a renting term and when they make 7, they’ll remove your data from the cloud and make it impossible to play the game you paid for only for you to find out you agreed to allow them to do such.
But here’s the kicker, having the game being sold to you on a disk does absolulely nothing to prevent that. However, while we’re talking about how amazing disks are and how much we want our games to come on 20 bucks worth of additional plastic and how much we want to pay for readers to read said plastic, we’re not talking about how much it’s legal and normal for a publisher to require you to login in their system and periodically be connected to the internet so your game can exchange whatever the fuck info with their server, or else it can’t even run (legally). Because when you buy a disk, you own a piece of expensive plastic, and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.
Disks are dumb and it’s amazing that they’re gone, and we absolutely don’t need them to return. What we do need is the customer protection akin to stop killing games initiative, which will make digital purchase have the same legal protection as any other purchases.
Hell, if I was a conspiratorial sort, I would say the whole disk backlash started because sony wants to misdirect the public attention
Well thankfully the supreme court already ruled that I can keep backups… Once I buy a game I like to think I can keep it, that’s why I’ve given up on consoles though, too many people want to control the thing I bought.
There were already articles a few days ago about how you could read the product code through the box in certain countries by simply shining a flashlight through it, because the regional distributor cheaped out on the paper inset that would have prevented it.
I’m sure making that knowledge public helped the situation. /s
So, it does kinda make sense. It means R* doesn’t have to make a bunch of different collectors sets, instead they make one and you buy your choice of game in your region. I also don’t doubt R* would’ve charged $100 more for including the game anyways.
It’s sadly not the first time this is a thing. There have been several “collectors editions” that didn’t include the game throughout the years. It’s so fucked.
A good compromise would be allowing the code to work multiple times but only be installed on one system at a time. This would introduce other issues though as people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work and ‘steal’ those games.
Oh I definitely get why they do it, but claiming it’s a cost issue to print all these disks doesn’t make sense when they could implement a similar mechanism with digital-only games. They of course don’t want to because they want to wipe out the second-hand market but pointing stuff out like this leaves them nothing to hide behind.
i still have the pc edition of gta 5 on seven discs. it sounds like gta 6 would have fit comfortably on five blu-rays, but then there goes their excuse to stop you from reselling something you “bought”
That would require an online connection to verify whether that license is still “valid” every time you open the game to ensure it hasn’t been installed another system since it was last used, or at least a periodic check-in with an allowed overlap period.
This is exactly what Xbox was eviscerated for back when they first announced the Xbox One.
They may have been eviscerated for it back then but that was over a decade ago and I can’t imagine it would affect that many people now especially in the context of a 200+GB game that’s digital-only to begin with. Back then you could play from disks offline still but that isn’t possible now. I think most people would prefer this to having a game that’s completely worthless and non-transferable the second you play it one time.
Steam and Ninfendo (?) prove it doesn’t need to be every time. Low bar sure, but for lending my friend a game I bought on the eShop it’s still pretty nice.
The problem with that idea is, if you resell the game there’s nothing stopping you from writing down the code and continuing to use it. They’d need to instead use something like a hardware key used to activate the game that cannot be easily spoofed.
people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work
That doesn’t seem like a significant issue, in the sense that big platforms can already be presumed to have a lot of active codes at any given time, so if it’s realistically possible to bruteforce even a single one, that’s a problem either way.
Aha why would you think that at all? The game companies have already been burned multiple times trying to speed up the death of physical media so they should kill the secondary market.
I guess so. Its not the first game having a code in a box. Its similar to a Steam code, that tie to your account and then can never be used again - its consumed, you become a consumer.
This is actually one of the things where Nintendo is ahead, with the game key carts. While its still a code basically, you still own the cartridge and can sell it to others. Microsoft has a new strategy too. You can pop in your disc on the console, then it ties a digital license it to your account. If anyone else pops the disc in, then you loose the digital license. This makes it possible to sell those games, regardless of if is something on the disc or not.
Uh story time! So like 15 years ago, I bought Napoleon Total War. We didn’t have a games shop in town, so I ordered it online. It was supposed to arrive the next day, but delivery got fucked so it took a week to arrive. I was super excited to finally play the game, only to discover the case didn’t have a CD. It turned out it was just a box, with the plastic stuff to hold a CD, but only with a Steam key i instead. I waited a week to get a physical copy of a game, just to get a key I could’ve bought for the same price directly from Steam…
That’s basically what happens with GTA 6 too. As long as they are upfront about it and you know about it, its fine. Because that is the “contract”. But if you didn’t know, then it sucks and is not okay. Either you didn’t read the fine print (it shouldn’t be a fine print anyway, but a big disclaimer) or they didn’t mention it (which would be illegal, but how to proof that?). I wonder how many don’t know they purchasing a code only, with GTA 6. I also wonder how many even care.
Back then I didn’t even consider the option. I always bought physical copies, and didn’t use Steam at all. It was probably written somewhere, but even if I’d read it, I probably wouldn’t have connected the dots, because why would you ever just want a useless empty plastic case?
Ultimately, PC is worse for actual ownership of games, but it trades it for the fact all my games follow me to every future machine. That trade off is worth it for me, but I’m mad everyone is being forced to make it and not even getting the benefit usually anymore
I think its important that we make this public, because its also to help those in such a situation. I don’t like hiding issues, because that also means anyone having the issue would not know why and can’t even prevent it. Off course, I completely understand the paradoxical situation here, because if you don’t tell it to the mass, then most people won’t abuse it.
I don’t understand why they’re even having physical boxers made up when the game will be download only. You might as well just buy from the PlayStation store or whatever the Xbox equivalent is. At least that way your guaranteed to get the game.
lol “physical copies?” You mean your empty plastic box with a download code?
I did hear you could literally hold the box up to the light and read the code inside yesterday. I am guessing that’s actually true. Which is hilarious. Think I might go down to Walmart and see if I can get a free game code.
Wha? When did that happen? The original release of the game with The Orange Box did actually have the games on a disk so I would assume it was in some stabdalone retail release?
Weird… Cuz the only stand alone release for Portal that I can even find info about is Portal: Still Alive which was exclusive to the Xbox Arcade. It was only ever sold through Steam or in The Orange Box for PC.
As I understand it, there was a poster in the way of doing that, but some person on tiktok or some other variant did it after removing the poster to freak people out.
Why wouldn’t the code require purchase? Ah, this is a gift card scam. They nabbed the code, waited for it to be purchased, then activated it? Wouldn’t the thief need to know when it was purchased and before the purchasee got home?
I think the idea was that the code wouldn’t be activated from Rockstars side until sold in a retail store. Don’t think that is supported by retailer infrastructure, a per box phone home to Rockstar, but I’m no expert.
Gift card activation is way more sophisticated than whatever system they are using for this. There’s no retailer handshake for activation, you just input the code and it works if it hasn’t already been activated.
I bring a “just wait and pirate it” vibe “nuh duh but its the biggest release ever” and “nuh duh i wanna support the billion dolar corporation for their work” folks don’t like…
And remember, shoplifting still earns Rockstar money (the market has already paid for that box) and steals games from people who paid for it.
🏴☠️ sail the high seas, and if you can’t (eg. denuvo), the game’s probably not worth it anyway…
Oh, no, that’s definitely true, there are photos in this thread. I’ve also seen footage of cases that just didn’t have the code, period, and apparently Rockstar is still refusing to do anything about them.
Exactly. Digital game distribution has its issues, but the main upside is not needing to utilize physical resources like paper, plastic, and the gas in the trucks driving them out to stores. They managed to take away the only upside because they don’t care about the environment or wasting resources. They only think about money.
If sex was like cash, it would be ubiquitous, anonymous, everyone would covet getting it from anybody and everybody, and you could use it to do cocaine.
What a pointlessly condescending comment. People buy physical because they don’t want a code, they want a physical copy. You’re just victim blaming. Criticize the company doing this, not the people falling for intentionally deceptive business practices.
You’re ignoring nuance. The customer is not at fault for the company using deceptive practices, that should be solved with regulation. The customer is at fault for not exercising common sense and due diligence. I’m not expecting customers to do background checks on companies they purchase from. But I do expect them to either use common sense and not buy things at release or accept the risk that comes with it.
How can you simultaneously say that this is a big enough problem that it requires regulation, but still have the anti consumer perspective that they are stupid for falling for it and should be able to avoid it with common sense? That’s contradictory.
Some people have crap internet connections, some people want to be able to play the game right away on christmas without a long down load. Some people expect to be able to install and play the game 20 years from now when the online servers are gone.
But the people are also really fucking stupid for accepting it.
Both are true. At some point if a victim doesn’t defend themselves you gotta blame the victim just as well as the abuser. And let’s not pretend that people that buy GTA 6 on release for the full price are really victims in society.
What do you mean by “people are accepting it”? Where do you see people who got a copy with a used or missing code who are just oh so excited they didn’t get what they paid for??
Supposedly they’re also doing a PC release slightly quicker than they usually have for the last few major releases. Because otherwise they run the risk of people vibe coding their own PC port which AI has gotten pretty good at
I think games should switch to USB thumb drives for physical copies. Publishers should get creative and put the drive in a figurine like an amiibo to sell multiples of the same game with different character figurines and players can collect them.
Since they are writable this could lock to device all the same or use a cryptographic key that does the same for you and you only on this exact device you installed to. If that’s why you wanted physical to avoid.
To be honest, that’s probably close enough to the best compromise they can come with physical ownership.
A USB drive that functions as a physical license for the game and that can be traded in/shared/etc as people want. Licensing dongles aren’t a new creation by any stretch.
But that would almost certainly cost more than the functionally similar Blu-Ray disc from before. A license key only wouldn’t take up much space however, no need more more than a few MB of memory if that’s all you’re putting on it and making the game itself still a digital download just authorized by the USB key.
Yeah but also consider that is this day an age someone can make a reproduction of the usb case and put another cheap one with malware inside it. Is a long length to fuck up someone but is possible.
This is on purpose so they can gatekeep computing and keep it being hyper capitalistic instead of letting it get more left wing like open source was threatening
You are both right. There currently is no good way out of this mess other than trying to keep together what we already own somehow. And only installing DRM free software on those drives. Or, you know, software that was made DRM free by Good Samaritans.
Not if you don’t care about putting the game on the drive. It’s already obsolete by the time the user gets the game box, and they always require Day 1 patches to be functional anyway. Just ignore needing to include the game on the stick entirely. Enough space for a license key would only need a few MB, and it doesn’t need to be particularly robust stuff either, it could be permanently read-only.
Use the USB stick as a physical license key/token. Because nothing is actually run from the discs anyway once installed, the system already checks for a corresponding disc, then it looks for a stored license on the console, and if one is missing it checks the user’s account for a license. So you just adjust that first physical check to look for either the corresponding disc or USB key.
Doesn’t really matter when it started, that was 20 years ago. It’s here and it’s never going away. Complaining about it is a waste of time and energy that’s much more useful handling new issues you can still effect.
Yes yes yes, typical gamer response. everythings horrible but we just have to accept it and keep shoveling money to game companies, because how dare I be expected to speak with my wallet and not have my precious shiny.
Problems just need to be fixed without me lifting a finger or suffering the indignity of not having everything i want when i want it.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones. It could be a micro usb dongle encased in a figurine or something, which could add to the release collectible, and it could “snap off” if clipped by kids running around being stupid.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones.
You could say the same about controller wires or even memory cards on previous consoles. That’s not a very good excuse.
It’s as big or small as you want to make it. There are a ton of tiny USB dongles that are a fraction of an inch long. Basically every wireless keyboard, mouse, and controller that use a 2,4GHz signal (not bluetooth) come with a tiny dongle like this now.
Even smaller potentially if they want to use USB-C instead of USB-A ports. If they choose to make them bigger or more complicated for sales or collectibles, that’s a possibility. But strictly as a replacement for disc licenses, nothing bigger than that is needed, maybe just a bit more to show the box art or something. Heck, they could even allow it plug into the controller charging port.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo.
How so? The info on the disc now doesn’t let you play the game anyway. At most, it makes the initial download and install take a little less time.
Take a brand new PS5, pop the disc in with no internet connection, and you still can’t play the game because it needs at least a day 1 patch to enable it to work anyway. Why even pretend a playable game is actually there? The disc is just a license already.
No. Not unless you want to buy a new copy every time you go to reinstall it.
flash memory is not an archival storage medium.
There is a strong chance it will self erase, if not the drive become completely non-functional, by the time you come back to reinstall it (or possibly when you first install it after getting home, if its been out a while and sitting on a shelf).
meanwhile, even haphazardly stored pressed optical media can last muiltiple decades. Even burned optical media, which has a much shorter life than pressed manufactured disks, has a longer expected functional life.
Sometimes I get frustrated that this game doesn’t release on PC at the same time as consoles and then I remember that literally every time they have a big title release there’s dumb shit like this going on. Console players are just the glorified beta testers for this, as far as I’m concerned. PC version will drop with a year’s worth of bug fixes and balance patches, run better, look better, and will be modable day 1.
I am not frustrated about it personally, there are dar to many incredible games and I do not have close to enough time(or money) to play them all. Missing GTA is a drop in the ocean.
I think for me I think the issue is just that I’m missing out on the cultural event itself more than the game and that’s what is making me frustrated more than anything else. It’s like your coworkers talking about Breaking Bad or Game of Thrones at the watercolor on break - it’s not like you can’t do that any time you want, but you miss out on all the cool discussions that happen when the event in question is fresh in the memories of everyone who gets to experience it firsthand.
PC players get robbed of that, but are rewarded with a generally better end product so I guess it balances out.
I haven’t played a single PS5/Xbox SX game yet and my to do list is long while my time to play is short… So, I guess, I will have enough to play for the next few years until I get bored.
Comments
LMAO! That’s what you get for supporting a union-busting corporation!
Not the main point here, but this image caption is really odd:
“A video game weightlifting scene illustrates the story, though the reported GTA 6 download-code problems concern boxed copies rather than gameplay”
This seems like something AI would say if you asked it to fill in the blanks.
Yeah that’s because it is.
I re-read it three times thinking I must just be tired.
Surely checks site tweaktown.com would have the most substantial gaming journalism there is… They would never use AI as such an award winning website.
I have no idea what this caption means.
Why are so many people shitting on the fans of the game and not the company proving why we need physical games??
Shit on both. Buying this game is perpetuating major problems in the industry as shown by this company’s horrible choices
THANK YOU. THIS!
You can get mad at ‘higher-ups’ who help a problem to continue and continue but it is the people ‘down-unders’ who hold up the base that have made this prpblem to even be started. These people are more worthy of our hate. The people down under make this problem start by supporting companies like rockstar and then continuing and continuing to support companies like rockstar when they bust unions or when they fail t o deliver what customers asked for.
Kind of a chicken and the egg kinda issue tho. Rockstar wouldnt be able to get away with this if there wasnt a subsection of mouth breathing customers who willingly spread their cheeks to get fucked over. Theyll literally drop $60 for the same 2K with a roster that couldve been an updated
How dare people buy games they want?
Isn’t the point here that they don’t want this but have paid for (and rewarded) it anyway?
What they really didn’t want is for the code to already be used.
But the choice is a digital code, or a digital code in a box with a poster/map for £5 less than retail.
I didn’t notice Baldur’s Gate 3 getting anywhere near this level of shit for skipping physical.
Yeah I also have seen the very same people who are Disney, marvel, Nintendo, Steam/Valve fans hand wave these same shitty practices away because they like the art the company distributes.
Some people think being anti-capitalist means you can’t enjoy stuff made by huge companies that have shitty practices. Some of yall are gonna have to stop playing video games and watching TV/Movies altogether.
I don’t get the hype for this game, even GTA 5 felt boring to me and I’ve never finished it. Is it that normies only know 1 or 2 games like GTA and FIFA so these things are a big deal for them?
I want to get high and drive around listening to the radio looking for birds, I’ll probably spend 40 hours on just that alone
I guess I get that, I enjoyed traveling around the map listening to the radio in San Andreas, but I liked the whacky and goofy nature of those early GTA games, but in GTA 5 it felt like they turned the game into a reality simulator and I don’t care for that, I game to escape my reality not to roam around in a photo real simulation of it.
For what it’s worth Jason Schreier shares your opinion on GTA V and he’s saying VI is a masterpiece
The biggest games get the audience that doesn’t play many games yeah.
Ya its like those people who only get into the nfl’s football… and just stick with that football only…
Like these people do know tha tthere are other football leagues out there , ones that dont try their best to ignore the damage that CTE does righht?
Some people do only RP servers and basically only play GTA. Not for me, but i have played about 4000 hours of factory based games so I shouldn’t be talking shit about this sort of thing.
What’s RP server, is it the multiplayer thing, never played it
Role Playing server. If you follow arma 3 its like altis life.
Ive never played GTA RP but my understanding is that it’s like a separate client or mod or something. The big one (only one? Biggest one?) is called FiveM.
[deleted]
Not all of us live in Florida and California so the experience is new to us
I love creating havok and chaos, ill get GTA 6 in a year or so when I’m looking for that sort of thing
Loved doing that in just cause 3, doesn’t get better than that. Still sad that there is no official DRM free version though.
Let the “diehards” beta test it for you and get the GOTY edition in a year or so with all the bugs fixed and it’s $40.
Needing a download code defeats the purpose of a physical copy.
Thanks to all the console players for beta testing this game. Looking forward to the proper release for PC whenever.
Well. Look at how GTA IV works out on PC. Tons of stuff is buggy and removed and so on because it is a skimpy port
Not so for V, though.
I’m still mad at the IV port that I couldn’t play it on my my new dual-core CPU at the time.
V also has its quirks. For example if you’re in some sort of game lobby with others (not the main hub, but the missions, races, etc.) and then get into the loading screen, then tab out of the game, it will not continue to load until you get back. Everybody else will also have to wait.
5 online was getting shot by angry dicks who wanted to always play the hiest. I was in my early 20’s excited to play it and all it was, was the same as all the other games.
5 disks to load it, only to be disappointed. Fuck man it felt like call of duty multi-player was a better choice at the time. At least cod made sense but gta 5 online was just senseless useless bullshit with almost no time between respawning and getting shot.
I mean gta is a ghetto-gweedo-mobster lifestyle simulation game so what can I expect but to just be killed the moment I repawn and it felt like I should’ve been playing COD.
I stopped playing it after I realized I am not going to be able to reach any part of the map online without being auto killed after respawning. There was no chance to level anything up or get any new weapons.
My fault for waiting until I could get the game half off and my fault for thinking online would be playable.
Those aren’t physical copies. They’re plastic advertising material for influencers.
In general, AAA games weren’t able to fit on a physical disc for decades already, that’s why this recent backlash about it was stupid from the beginning. We needed to talk about getting rid of DRM, but conversation shifted to disks as if that will fix anything.
If you mean the physical disks of the 70s-90s, I’m with you, but things like Blu-ray gave us so much more storage. A single sided quad layer blu-ray disc holds 128GB, dual sided triple layer disc’s come in at around 200GB.
As someone that had to shuffle discs all the time growing up, the game could definitely come on disc’s if they wanted to.
if a game cant fit on a blu-ray disk, then thats a lazy developer problem, not a media problem.
It’s a leadership and budgeting problem, not a developer problem, the devs have no say in what the physical packaging is.
“Its not a problem with the developer, Its just a management and money problem inside the developer”
They just want to have the ability to rip it from your library. They just want you to never have access to the games that you purchased and will never call it renting because they want to keep customers.
We all know we’re renting by now. You don’t purchase a game, you purchase a renting term and when they make 7, they’ll remove your data from the cloud and make it impossible to play the game you paid for only for you to find out you agreed to allow them to do such.
But here’s the kicker, having the game being sold to you on a disk does absolulely nothing to prevent that. However, while we’re talking about how amazing disks are and how much we want our games to come on 20 bucks worth of additional plastic and how much we want to pay for readers to read said plastic, we’re not talking about how much it’s legal and normal for a publisher to require you to login in their system and periodically be connected to the internet so your game can exchange whatever the fuck info with their server, or else it can’t even run (legally). Because when you buy a disk, you own a piece of expensive plastic, and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.
Disks are dumb and it’s amazing that they’re gone, and we absolutely don’t need them to return. What we do need is the customer protection akin to stop killing games initiative, which will make digital purchase have the same legal protection as any other purchases.
Hell, if I was a conspiratorial sort, I would say the whole disk backlash started because sony wants to misdirect the public attention
No shit but with the disks you have indefinite access. They can’t wipe it from your system like cloud games.
I just wish split screen and human interaction came back and owning one disk, meant 4 of your friends were coming over to beat the game.
I wish that it wasn’t all online and that human interaction didn’t mean two people owning two systems on two tvs in the same room on gamer chairs.
Then again… Lan parties were a thing and bringing your own computer was a thing.
I guess with instant access and the ability to play with anyone in the world, why would you want to interact with anyone else around you.
Well thankfully the supreme court already ruled that I can keep backups… Once I buy a game I like to think I can keep it, that’s why I’ve given up on consoles though, too many people want to control the thing I bought.
There have been many games that have used multiple discs, noone really complains about it
Title is misleading. These people are not “GTA 6 players” - they never even played the game!
There were already articles a few days ago about how you could read the product code through the box in certain countries by simply shining a flashlight through it, because the regional distributor cheaped out on the paper inset that would have prevented it.
I’m sure making that knowledge public helped the situation. /s
Does that mean that the code can only be used once?
So for instance buying the « physical » version of the game doesn’t allow you to resell it?
Correct.
The physical version is just a glorified collector’s set, even the physical box only gives you the digital version.
Correction: the actual collector’s set doesn’t actually come with the game, digital or physical.
Hahahaha
Sorry for the useless comment but a regular upvote didn’t feel like enough
So, it does kinda make sense. It means R* doesn’t have to make a bunch of different collectors sets, instead they make one and you buy your choice of game in your region. I also don’t doubt R* would’ve charged $100 more for including the game anyways.
It’s sadly not the first time this is a thing. There have been several “collectors editions” that didn’t include the game throughout the years. It’s so fucked.
Once again advocating for one of the few ways we can exercise power here: Stop buying their bullshit.
Apparently some guys with flashlights are way ahead of you.
Exactly what I’d expect, as someone who occasionally plays a video game 😅
lol, wtf is even going on anymore
A good compromise would be allowing the code to work multiple times but only be installed on one system at a time. This would introduce other issues though as people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work and ‘steal’ those games.
You’re missing the point.
You’re assuming these gaming companies care about their users…
It’s like my copy of wow I purchased 20 years ago. I have the box and game, but seems my account has disappeared and I’d need to repurchase
Oh I definitely get why they do it, but claiming it’s a cost issue to print all these disks doesn’t make sense when they could implement a similar mechanism with digital-only games. They of course don’t want to because they want to wipe out the second-hand market but pointing stuff out like this leaves them nothing to hide behind.
Even better would be just having a disc.
i still have the pc edition of gta 5 on seven discs. it sounds like gta 6 would have fit comfortably on five blu-rays, but then there goes their excuse to stop you from reselling something you “bought”
That would require an online connection to verify whether that license is still “valid” every time you open the game to ensure it hasn’t been installed another system since it was last used, or at least a periodic check-in with an allowed overlap period.
This is exactly what Xbox was eviscerated for back when they first announced the Xbox One.
They may have been eviscerated for it back then but that was over a decade ago and I can’t imagine it would affect that many people now especially in the context of a 200+GB game that’s digital-only to begin with. Back then you could play from disks offline still but that isn’t possible now. I think most people would prefer this to having a game that’s completely worthless and non-transferable the second you play it one time.
Understood loud and clear. NFTs for games coming right up.
Steam and Ninfendo (?) prove it doesn’t need to be every time. Low bar sure, but for lending my friend a game I bought on the eShop it’s still pretty nice.
That’s kind of what Nintendo did with their new Virtual game cards.
The problem with that idea is, if you resell the game there’s nothing stopping you from writing down the code and continuing to use it. They’d need to instead use something like a hardware key used to activate the game that cannot be easily spoofed.
That doesn’t seem like a significant issue, in the sense that big platforms can already be presumed to have a lot of active codes at any given time, so if it’s realistically possible to bruteforce even a single one, that’s a problem either way.
I had thought that you would be at least able to resell the code and transfer the licence to someone else…
That’s crazy…
The game looks and sounds great, but so many things are pushing me away from it…
Aha why would you think that at all? The game companies have already been burned multiple times trying to speed up the death of physical media so they should kill the secondary market.
I guess so. Its not the first game having a code in a box. Its similar to a Steam code, that tie to your account and then can never be used again - its consumed, you become a consumer.
This is actually one of the things where Nintendo is ahead, with the game key carts. While its still a code basically, you still own the cartridge and can sell it to others. Microsoft has a new strategy too. You can pop in your disc on the console, then it ties a digital license it to your account. If anyone else pops the disc in, then you loose the digital license. This makes it possible to sell those games, regardless of if is something on the disc or not.
Uh story time! So like 15 years ago, I bought Napoleon Total War. We didn’t have a games shop in town, so I ordered it online. It was supposed to arrive the next day, but delivery got fucked so it took a week to arrive. I was super excited to finally play the game, only to discover the case didn’t have a CD. It turned out it was just a box, with the plastic stuff to hold a CD, but only with a Steam key i instead. I waited a week to get a physical copy of a game, just to get a key I could’ve bought for the same price directly from Steam…
Ugh that sucks! It was so much more fun going into a games store, browsing the shelves and physically buying a copy.
Right? Too bad I didn’t have money back then.
Hell yeah, love story times. :D
That’s basically what happens with GTA 6 too. As long as they are upfront about it and you know about it, its fine. Because that is the “contract”. But if you didn’t know, then it sucks and is not okay. Either you didn’t read the fine print (it shouldn’t be a fine print anyway, but a big disclaimer) or they didn’t mention it (which would be illegal, but how to proof that?). I wonder how many don’t know they purchasing a code only, with GTA 6. I also wonder how many even care.
Back then I didn’t even consider the option. I always bought physical copies, and didn’t use Steam at all. It was probably written somewhere, but even if I’d read it, I probably wouldn’t have connected the dots, because why would you ever just want a useless empty plastic case?
Nintendo is great if you want to buy nothing but sequels of the same game made 30+ years ago
Also, I owned a wii. Guess who basically needs to re buy all the games if I want to use them on switch
Ultimately, PC is worse for actual ownership of games, but it trades it for the fact all my games follow me to every future machine. That trade off is worth it for me, but I’m mad everyone is being forced to make it and not even getting the benefit usually anymore
My point was, that there are better ways than a code-in-a-box for digital only games.
I think its important that we make this public, because its also to help those in such a situation. I don’t like hiding issues, because that also means anyone having the issue would not know why and can’t even prevent it. Off course, I completely understand the paradoxical situation here, because if you don’t tell it to the mass, then most people won’t abuse it.
I don’t understand why they’re even having physical boxers made up when the game will be download only. You might as well just buy from the PlayStation store or whatever the Xbox equivalent is. At least that way your guaranteed to get the game.
Because of the backlash they got for wanting to get rid of physical media entirely.
This is their compromise.
lol “physical copies?” You mean your empty plastic box with a download code?
I did hear you could literally hold the box up to the light and read the code inside yesterday. I am guessing that’s actually true. Which is hilarious. Think I might go down to Walmart and see if I can get a free game code.
If it does work, other people have probably already stole these codes before you.
Not a problem. I’ll just need to have a friend watch for store employees while I relieve my town of their entire supply of GTA VI codes.
Shoplifting has never been easier.
Ugh, I hated those back when Valve was pushing Steam through the same empty boxes with codes when buying Portal.
And I hate it now so many years later.
Wha? When did that happen? The original release of the game with The Orange Box did actually have the games on a disk so I would assume it was in some stabdalone retail release?
The only thing on that disk was an installer for Steam and a code for the game.
It was standalone, yeah. Didn’t need all the other games on there. Just wanted to play Portal. But was forced to install Steam in order to do so.
Weird… Cuz the only stand alone release for Portal that I can even find info about is Portal: Still Alive which was exclusive to the Xbox Arcade. It was only ever sold through Steam or in The Orange Box for PC.
[deleted]
It had a disc but required activation on Steam.
The disk just had a Steam installer. No game at all.
As I understand it, there was a poster in the way of doing that, but some person on tiktok or some other variant did it after removing the poster to freak people out.
Why wouldn’t the code require purchase? Ah, this is a gift card scam. They nabbed the code, waited for it to be purchased, then activated it? Wouldn’t the thief need to know when it was purchased and before the purchasee got home?
I think the idea was that the code wouldn’t be activated from Rockstars side until sold in a retail store. Don’t think that is supported by retailer infrastructure, a per box phone home to Rockstar, but I’m no expert.
Technically it shouldn’t be different from gift cards e.g. for google, steam, roblox, etc.
Gift card activation is way more sophisticated than whatever system they are using for this. There’s no retailer handshake for activation, you just input the code and it works if it hasn’t already been activated.
Maybe they purchased and returned it, still wrapped?
Games I buy here state I can only return as long as the foil wrapping is intact.
Aren’t the games locked up?
Not at the one nearest me. They have a cabinet but it has no doors.
I bring a “just wait and pirate it” vibe “nuh duh but its the biggest release ever” and “nuh duh i wanna support the billion dolar corporation for their work” folks don’t like…
And remember, shoplifting still earns Rockstar money (the market has already paid for that box) and steals games from people who paid for it.
🏴☠️ sail the high seas, and if you can’t (eg. denuvo), the game’s probably not worth it anyway…
Let’s also not forget that they are union-busting cunts who don’t deserve to operate on the market. Fucking ruin this company.
Rockstar: Sends games to stores with no codes inside.
Also Rockstar: “The missing code is a retailer problem.” *Closes support ticket*
Apparently some of the ones that actually had codes had them visible through the packaging.
Oh, no, that’s definitely true, there are photos in this thread. I’ve also seen footage of cases that just didn’t have the code, period, and apparently Rockstar is still refusing to do anything about them.
I waNT tO supPorT the BiLliON DOlLAR compANy
What about the developers they fired after release so they’re now unemployed.
whaT AbOut tHEm?
I support them most. 😥
Because they aren’t “physical copies”. The industry killed that off, but they’re leaving boxes out for those trying to support it.
Such things should have also killed off the concept or preordering, and yet, it persists.
Solution: STOP FUCKING BUYING SHIT FROM COMPANIES SPITTING IN YOUR FACE. Please.
BUT I EAT PAINT
Exactly. Digital game distribution has its issues, but the main upside is not needing to utilize physical resources like paper, plastic, and the gas in the trucks driving them out to stores. They managed to take away the only upside because they don’t care about the environment or wasting resources. They only think about money.
only gta 6 idiots could buy a physical copy that is just a fucking code
I had to visit the museum of aviation history when I heard about this. Paying respect to the roflcopter seemed the appropriate course of action.
Honestly its great for a birthday or upcoming Christmas gift which is probably why they exist
It also makes it a lot easier to pay for a game in cash.
Paying cash used to be the only option
We have been robbed
…of our cash
If sex was like cash, it would be ubiquitous, anonymous, everyone would covet getting it from anybody and everybody, and you could use it to do cocaine.
All net positives.
What a pointlessly condescending comment. People buy physical because they don’t want a code, they want a physical copy. You’re just victim blaming. Criticize the company doing this, not the people falling for intentionally deceptive business practices.
The company is at fault for deceptive practices - true
The customer is at fault for preordering and/or not checking - true
A chain holds as long as all links in it hold.
You’re literally describing victim blaming.
You’re ignoring nuance. The customer is not at fault for the company using deceptive practices, that should be solved with regulation. The customer is at fault for not exercising common sense and due diligence. I’m not expecting customers to do background checks on companies they purchase from. But I do expect them to either use common sense and not buy things at release or accept the risk that comes with it.
How can you simultaneously say that this is a big enough problem that it requires regulation, but still have the anti consumer perspective that they are stupid for falling for it and should be able to avoid it with common sense? That’s contradictory.
Some people have crap internet connections, some people want to be able to play the game right away on christmas without a long down load. Some people expect to be able to install and play the game 20 years from now when the online servers are gone.
Yeah, and the companies selling bogus physical copies that are actually just download codes should be getting the flak.
Yes the company is shit for doing it.
But the people are also really fucking stupid for accepting it.
Both are true. At some point if a victim doesn’t defend themselves you gotta blame the victim just as well as the abuser. And let’s not pretend that people that buy GTA 6 on release for the full price are really victims in society.
What do you mean by “people are accepting it”? Where do you see people who got a copy with a used or missing code who are just oh so excited they didn’t get what they paid for??
They’re accepting the fact physical isn’t physical… I wasn’t expecting to need to explain that…
I feel like you’re just ignoring things I’ve said. The entire point I’m making is that they were deceived.
This is why its DRM that was always the problem, not physical/digital.
Maybe hang back a while for this one? Just sayin’.
For me, I’ll never play it. But, if you’re going to, just ignore the hype and wait a bit.
Supposedly they’re also doing a PC release slightly quicker than they usually have for the last few major releases. Because otherwise they run the risk of people vibe coding their own PC port which AI has gotten pretty good at
So now we can just wait and pirate it.
At the rate of those vibe ports I expect to see one in like two weeks
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn%3AANd9GcSYvP95nVtfQykvj4KazCyrD60lagcbgwVHxg&s=
I think games should switch to USB thumb drives for physical copies. Publishers should get creative and put the drive in a figurine like an amiibo to sell multiples of the same game with different character figurines and players can collect them.
So we’re going back to cartridges? I’m cool with that.
In this memory price economy?
Please make it PCIe though.
Best I can do is USB 2.0. On an USB-C connector.
Since they are writable this could lock to device all the same or use a cryptographic key that does the same for you and you only on this exact device you installed to. If that’s why you wanted physical to avoid.
To be honest, that’s probably close enough to the best compromise they can come with physical ownership.
A USB drive that functions as a physical license for the game and that can be traded in/shared/etc as people want. Licensing dongles aren’t a new creation by any stretch.
But that would almost certainly cost more than the functionally similar Blu-Ray disc from before. A license key only wouldn’t take up much space however, no need more more than a few MB of memory if that’s all you’re putting on it and making the game itself still a digital download just authorized by the USB key.
Yeah but also consider that is this day an age someone can make a reproduction of the usb case and put another cheap one with malware inside it. Is a long length to fuck up someone but is possible.
So you can play offline??? Hahahahahaha
No.
Well with the current NAND shortage those would cost about 500$ each or something
This is on purpose so they can gatekeep computing and keep it being hyper capitalistic instead of letting it get more left wing like open source was threatening
You are both right. There currently is no good way out of this mess other than trying to keep together what we already own somehow. And only installing DRM free software on those drives. Or, you know, software that was made DRM free by Good Samaritans.
Not if you don’t care about putting the game on the drive. It’s already obsolete by the time the user gets the game box, and they always require Day 1 patches to be functional anyway. Just ignore needing to include the game on the stick entirely. Enough space for a license key would only need a few MB, and it doesn’t need to be particularly robust stuff either, it could be permanently read-only.
Use the USB stick as a physical license key/token. Because nothing is actually run from the discs anyway once installed, the system already checks for a corresponding disc, then it looks for a stored license on the console, and if one is missing it checks the user’s account for a license. So you just adjust that first physical check to look for either the corresponding disc or USB key.
the whole “ship it broken and patch it later” bullshit only started with the always online internet connected era.
Games were capable of being shipped, without being patched, for far longer than that, and rarely had any game breaking bugs.
Doesn’t really matter when it started, that was 20 years ago. It’s here and it’s never going away. Complaining about it is a waste of time and energy that’s much more useful handling new issues you can still effect.
Yes yes yes, typical gamer response. everythings horrible but we just have to accept it and keep shoveling money to game companies, because how dare I be expected to speak with my wallet and not have my precious shiny.
Problems just need to be fixed without me lifting a finger or suffering the indignity of not having everything i want when i want it.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones. It could be a micro usb dongle encased in a figurine or something, which could add to the release collectible, and it could “snap off” if clipped by kids running around being stupid.
You could say the same about controller wires or even memory cards on previous consoles. That’s not a very good excuse.
It’s as big or small as you want to make it. There are a ton of tiny USB dongles that are a fraction of an inch long. Basically every wireless keyboard, mouse, and controller that use a 2,4GHz signal (not bluetooth) come with a tiny dongle like this now.
https://media.piefed.social/posts/l7/fO/l7fOxnBa5Ud4hWO.png
Even smaller potentially if they want to use USB-C instead of USB-A ports. If they choose to make them bigger or more complicated for sales or collectibles, that’s a possibility. But strictly as a replacement for disc licenses, nothing bigger than that is needed, maybe just a bit more to show the box art or something. Heck, they could even allow it plug into the controller charging port.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo. But then I haven’t used a console since the PS3 so I’m not exactly the target audience here.
How so? The info on the disc now doesn’t let you play the game anyway. At most, it makes the initial download and install take a little less time.
Take a brand new PS5, pop the disc in with no internet connection, and you still can’t play the game because it needs at least a day 1 patch to enable it to work anyway. Why even pretend a playable game is actually there? The disc is just a license already.
That is a more recent thing. I think that also defeats the purpose of it. To me if it needs the internet to work its useless.
No. Not unless you want to buy a new copy every time you go to reinstall it.
flash memory is not an archival storage medium.
There is a strong chance it will self erase, if not the drive become completely non-functional, by the time you come back to reinstall it (or possibly when you first install it after getting home, if its been out a while and sitting on a shelf).
meanwhile, even haphazardly stored pressed optical media can last muiltiple decades. Even burned optical media, which has a much shorter life than pressed manufactured disks, has a longer expected functional life.
Good idea. Also, hush, they can hear you and my wallet is already weeping
Rockstar: Doesn’t matter, got money
Grand theft gamo
/thread
“copies”, “physical”.
Sometimes I get frustrated that this game doesn’t release on PC at the same time as consoles and then I remember that literally every time they have a big title release there’s dumb shit like this going on. Console players are just the glorified beta testers for this, as far as I’m concerned. PC version will drop with a year’s worth of bug fixes and balance patches, run better, look better, and will be modable day 1.
Yeah, I ignore the hype.
I am not frustrated about it personally, there are dar to many incredible games and I do not have close to enough time(or money) to play them all. Missing GTA is a drop in the ocean.
I think for me I think the issue is just that I’m missing out on the cultural event itself more than the game and that’s what is making me frustrated more than anything else. It’s like your coworkers talking about Breaking Bad or Game of Thrones at the watercolor on break - it’s not like you can’t do that any time you want, but you miss out on all the cool discussions that happen when the event in question is fresh in the memories of everyone who gets to experience it firsthand.
PC players get robbed of that, but are rewarded with a generally better end product so I guess it balances out.
“physical copies”
I’m sure internet drama would be much more entertaining than the game itself.
people are drama over a game that barely or hasnt released yet, they dont even care about the game itself.
I will only buy a game I can play and resell if it costs $70.
Then you are very soon to never buy a game again.
🏴☠️
I haven’t played a single PS5/Xbox SX game yet and my to do list is long while my time to play is short… So, I guess, I will have enough to play for the next few years until I get bored.
Sign in to comment. Sign in