Skip to content

Comment on Software is breaking down at a systemic level, by Jimmy Breck-McKye

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Poor article. Way too much doom and gloom.

    “AI is both a cause and a symptom of the problem here”

    Author starts but citing php2shell (caused by a bug written 10 years ago by a human), Emudhra (caused by human laziness and incompetence), FAA outage (broken physical wiring and poor human written contingencies)

    None of those were caused by AI.

    Vast majority of this years’ CVE floods have been /discovered/ by AI, not caused by it. These reports are already starting to level out, according to Linus. AI is finding them quickly, for good and bad, because we’re asking it to - but it’s not the cause. It will be a cause for future bugs caused by software being written /now/, because it’s writing more software now.

    The actual reason we’re seeing more breakages than before is that we’re using technology more than ever in critical services without good contingency planning.

    1
    • None of those were caused by AI.

      The author does not claim that.

      He says that AI comes on top of these trends and that using AI in a way that creates more bugs is caused by common forces.

      The actual reason we’re seeing more breakages than before is that we’re using technology more than ever in critical services without good contingency planning.

      And why is that?

      12
    • @communism@lemmy.ml· · edited

      The author explicitly states that it’s not (solely or primarily) because of AI. Did you read it, or did you get an AI to summarise it for you?

      2
    • imo the article wasn’t really about AI, but rather obfuscation through endless, undecipherable chains of dependencies reliant on unpaid volunteers for both creation and maintenance.

      2
    • @Ledivin@lemmy.world· · edited

      I’m sorry, but we absolutely don’t know what caused the FAA outage. The fact that you believe the first official stories is WILD and I can’t trust anything else you push

      -1

Sign in to comment. Sign in