Skip to content

Comment on Sen. Dan Sullivan campaign says it won’t concede Alaska Senate race until it’s certified

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • If she falls short of 50%, Alaska will conduct ranked-choice tabulation Wednesday, redistributing votes from eliminated candidates according to voters’ subsequent preferences.

    Look, like, Iʻve been promoting ranked choice for decades. I participated in a ballot effort over it. Its actually pretty rare it even matters. But its good to see it being used, even if I might disagree with its outcome (which seems highly unlikely).

    108
    • 100%. The people complaining about the bonus Dan Sullivan should be excited by the promise of ranked choice.

      61
      • Yes, the promise of Ranked Choice…

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-negative_responsiveness

        I’m in favor of voting reform, but Ranked Choice, or IRV if you will, was invented in 1785 and used as an example of a sort of miss step in the pursuit of a responsive voting system. It cannot reliably elect the Condorcet Winner, and has, in real world use, elected the Condorcet Loser more than once.

        It still suffers from the Spoiler Effect, so it fails on the one promise that supporters always make.

        And as Burlington Vermont showed, the backlash against a failed Ranked Choice election makes it harder to adopt an actual good voting system like Approval or STAR.

        9
        • Thank you!
          I’ve been saying this for years, I think much of the hype for RCV is an attempt to placate those looking for actual voting reform.

          I also think Approval is a great choice, that or Score. I don’t know enough about STAR, but Wikipedia makes it look reasonable.

          5
    • which seems highly unlikely

      I’d go a step further and side with Peltola to say that it’s probably mathematically impossible for him at this point.

      TL;DR: Even if it goes to ranked-choice, we already know what the majority of the ranked ballots look like, and it’s not good enough to even nearly close his gap with Peltola. In fact, probably a bit under half of the ballots for Heikes and Smol Sullivan are outright going into the void once ranked-choice starts because they didn’t rank a second, third, etc. choice.

      21

Sign in to comment. Sign in