I think customers should decide what they want to play based on the merits of a project. People have been putting out slop (truly shit games, gacha games, asset swaps, shit ports, and now slop-generated games) for a long time. The tools didn’t make the slop, the shit designers/developers did.
Cool story bro. One of the major project merits I’m looking for is “did not contribute to corporate theft of art, the dumbing down of society, and the hastening destruction of the planet by using slop machines”.
Is it still slop when an experienced developer uses AI to assist them with development and thoroughly reviews it and is ultimately responsible for the code?
LLM’s require expertise to supervise. Expertise requires practice to built and maintain. If you have the LLM do things, you’re getting less practice in, which slowly degrades your expertise, which in turn degrades your ability to supervise the LLM.
No, but then, a developer who is responsibly using LLMs as a tool in their IDE to do boilerplate generation kind of stuff, is fundamentally not vibe coding and thus it isn’t the case that the project is AI generated, just like AI assisted.
I don’t really consider them the same use case. The former is low or no effort while the latter is a skilled person effectively doing the same types of offloading they used do with e.g. Jetbrains tools, just levelled up.
Personally I think there is a huge difference between “generate the backing implementation of this interface/protocol I wrote” and “hey Claude make me a game”
Comments
I think customers should decide what they want to play based on the merits of a project. People have been putting out slop (truly shit games, gacha games, asset swaps, shit ports, and now slop-generated games) for a long time. The tools didn’t make the slop, the shit designers/developers did.
Cool story bro. One of the major project merits I’m looking for is “did not contribute to corporate theft of art, the dumbing down of society, and the hastening destruction of the planet by using slop machines”.
Not all slop is “AI” generated, but everything “AI” generated is slop
Is it still slop when an experienced developer uses AI to assist them with development and thoroughly reviews it and is ultimately responsible for the code?
Eventually, yes.
LLM’s require expertise to supervise. Expertise requires practice to built and maintain. If you have the LLM do things, you’re getting less practice in, which slowly degrades your expertise, which in turn degrades your ability to supervise the LLM.
It degrades your experience writing code, but it doesn’t degrade your experience reviewing code. Those are two different skillsets.
No, they’re not. You need to able to write code to review it. It’s all too easy to miss bugs if you don’t know the details
No, but then, a developer who is responsibly using LLMs as a tool in their IDE to do boilerplate generation kind of stuff, is fundamentally not vibe coding and thus it isn’t the case that the project is AI generated, just like AI assisted.
I don’t really consider them the same use case. The former is low or no effort while the latter is a skilled person effectively doing the same types of offloading they used do with e.g. Jetbrains tools, just levelled up.
Personally I think there is a huge difference between “generate the backing implementation of this interface/protocol I wrote” and “hey Claude make me a game”
Sign in to comment. Sign in