Skip to content

Comment on I'm on Lemmy to commiepost and chew bubblegum. And I'm all out of gum.

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • IDK, maybe killing shitloads of people by shipping them off to gulags?

    0
    • @Cowbee@lemmy.ml· · edited

      That didn’t happen, though. The overwhelming majority of deaths in the GULAG system were from starvation in the 1940s, due to the Nazis invading Ukraine to starve out the Soviet people. Further, the GULAG administration began after Lenin, and was disbanded in 1956. Below is the mortality rate data from Wikipedia:

      Year Deaths Mortality rate %

      https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/b3ad32ae-017a-4102-96f3-18fad476b5df.jpeg

      A correct analysis of the Soviet Union is necessary, because it was the first socialist state. We need to be critical, but base our critique on fact, not fiction. There’s plenty that went wrong, but there’s also plenty that went very, very well. We can learn from both.

      0
      • Ah, so people didn’t die in gulags except those that died in the gulags?

        Got it.

        Wikip says that over a million died in gulags before ‘53.

        Guess you’ve just moved the goalposts to “they aren’t enough to matter, and we’re not gonna really count that because cherrypicking.”

        1
        • @Cowbee@lemmy.ml· · edited

          You claimed Lenin killed a shitload of people in GULAGs, which didn’t even exist when Lenin was in power, and the overwhelming majority of those that died in GULAGs died because of Nazi-inflicted weaponized starvation. What’s your actual point? Over 700,000 of total deaths were during World War II. Of the people the Soviets were directly responsible for, these numbers were far more in line with contemporary prison systems.

          0
          • What specifically was bad about the Soviet system,

            Don’t play word games with me. You said Soviet system, and now you play games and say oh, I only meant Lenin…

            -1
            • Fair enough, I did ask two questions:

              What specifically was bad about the Soviet system, and what was bad about Lenin as a leader?

              I assumed you were answering both, so my mistake on not realizing you were only answering the Soviet question. In any case, incarceration rates weren’t terribly high, and mortality rates weren’t either. Many soviet prisons were actually fairly progressive even by today’s standards. Prisoners were paid wages equal to those outside the prison, handcuffs were seen as barbaric and largely unnecessary, and prisoners could even go on vacation. Some prisons even had people going home for the weekends.

              The reason for the Soviet prison system acting in the way it did, was because they believed in rehabilitation over punishment for most crimes. They believed that the best way to do so is to train people on how to be productive, pro-social workers. Not all prisons had the same progressive conditions, though, and this varied largely by severity of crime and region.

              As I said, we can learn from what they did well, while also recognizing where they faltered. Both are necessary if we are to carry their torch, and repeating nonsense Red Scare framing only serves to divorce us from the common historical task of the working class globally.

              0
              Continue this thread 2 more replies
        • [deleted]·

          [deleted]

      • Tankie

        -2
        • Sure? I thought it was fairly obvious that I’m a Marxist-Leninist, I’ve never hidden that. I believe the hundreds of millions of workers that worked, fought, and died to build and protect socialism weren’t fools.

          1

Sign in to comment. Sign in