There was an idea of tying minimum wage to the median rent in a given area, so if rent goes up, then so does the local minimum wage. This has the additional benefit of pitting low-wage employers against landlords.
What would it need to be to at least be above poverty? Some way to guarantee 5-10% left over that can be put into savings would be great , but that might have too many factors
How do you define poverty for that? The federal poverty line? Or a living wage?
The Federal poverty line is (PDF):
$15,960 for an individual and $21,640 for a 2 person household. That’s $7.67/hr and $10.40/hr respectively. And those are both EXTREMELY far from any sort of livable wage.
Where did you pull “$40” from? That’s 2.7x the highest purchasing power it ever reached (1968), a delusional amount. “Rise each year with inflation”, of course, is reasonable.
Call me crazy, but I think that minimum wage being 2.7x its relative value from 1968 is actually quite reasonable, considering how much overall productivity per worker has risen since then.
You know the cost of living in Dallas/ Fort Worth? My sister lives in Bedford Texas. 40 would make that area become livable. Can’t imagine how people survive in places like Austin Texas or Houston.
Different jurisdictions are allowed to have different minimum wages for a reason.
There’s a federal minimum, states can have minima, and even municipalities can set their own.* If you want to speak in idealism that’s never going to happen anyway, $40 federally (a figure someone on the Internet just pulled out of thin air) is the dumbest solution to localized high cost of living.
Also, a 40-hour work week at $40/hour is $83,200 annually. The median household income in Bedford is $78,785, while 66% of people own homes. I don’t think you know what you’re talking about even regarding this specific town.
* Republican states largely bar municipal minimum wages. That doesn’t make the solution to blanket the entire country in a $40 minimum. I mean obviously, but that’s a controversial take inside an echo chamber that doesn’t actually care.
Edit: I got so caught up in the specifics of the minimum wage that I completely forgot to mention the main reason this would be stupid: by the time you’re enacting $40 federal minimum wage, you’re far past the point where you can address cost-of-living directly – things like universal healtcare, free and accessible public transit/micromobility, nationalized energy based mostly on renewables and battery storage, subsidized housing, stopping union-busting and monopolies, and I could go on. Like you’re sidestepping (comically dodging, really) actual solutions in favor of the dumbest, most capitalist way to go about solving cost of living while not addressing the underlying issues.
More money? I would be getting zero money per hour, because nobody in their right mind is hiring me for $40/hour.* There’s a point beyond which the minimum wage is a reasonable metric for addressing cost of living, and $40/hour is so comically beyond that point that you may as well be asking “well why not $80/hour? Don’t you like more money??”. “Sky’s the limit when you don’t give a shit.”
What I’m complaining about is people taking a chance to advocate for beneficial if idealistic change – a solid, living minimum wage combined with systemic change like robust, de-privatized services, including healthcare, energy, transport, food, etc. (or fuck it: just actual, outright socialism at this level of political willpower) – and instead derailing it to circlejerk over obviously infeasible bullshit that actively makes the problem much worse. $40 minimum wage is the second-grader’s solution to cost of living.
* I say this, but what actually happens if federal minimum wage is magically made $40/hour and then magically made to stay there (i.e. there’s no takesies-backsies) is that the economy goes into a freefall and the Treasury prints money until US dollar is devalued enough for the riots to stop.
It’s not the change that hurts, it’s the rate of change. Most states that raised their minimum wages to > $15/hour phased it in over multiple years for exactly this reason
No, at $40/hour, it’s definitely also the change itself. You can’t just phase that in over “multiple years”, unless “multiple” is “decades’ worth”.
I get what you’re saying, that’s part of it, but not nearly a large enough part that such a batshit number is even worth discussing outside of a completely unserious thought experiment – about the same level of thought experiment seriousness as “what would happen if we built a poopcano?”
Comments
Good, but way too little. Minimum wage should be $40/hour now, and rise each year with inflation. By law.
I think minimum wage should be tied to cost of living somehow.
There was an idea of tying minimum wage to the median rent in a given area, so if rent goes up, then so does the local minimum wage. This has the additional benefit of pitting low-wage employers against landlords.
I love that idea.
Yup, $40/h (about $83k salary) would be upper middle class here, but a few cities over it would be nearly poverty level.
What would it need to be to at least be above poverty? Some way to guarantee 5-10% left over that can be put into savings would be great , but that might have too many factors
How do you define poverty for that? The federal poverty line? Or a living wage?
The Federal poverty line is (PDF):
$15,960 for an individual and $21,640 for a 2 person household. That’s $7.67/hr and $10.40/hr respectively. And those are both EXTREMELY far from any sort of livable wage.
Poverty is the wrong comparison here, and I’m not sure that line ever changes either.
Minimum wage should be relative to a “livable” wage
Where did you pull “$40” from? That’s 2.7x the highest purchasing power it ever reached (1968), a delusional amount. “Rise each year with inflation”, of course, is reasonable.
Call me crazy, but I think that minimum wage being 2.7x its relative value from 1968 is actually quite reasonable, considering how much overall productivity per worker has risen since then.
You know the cost of living in Dallas/ Fort Worth? My sister lives in Bedford Texas. 40 would make that area become livable. Can’t imagine how people survive in places like Austin Texas or Houston.
Different jurisdictions are allowed to have different minimum wages for a reason.
There’s a federal minimum, states can have minima, and even municipalities can set their own.* If you want to speak in idealism that’s never going to happen anyway, $40 federally (a figure someone on the Internet just pulled out of thin air) is the dumbest solution to localized high cost of living.
Also, a 40-hour work week at $40/hour is $83,200 annually. The median household income in Bedford is $78,785, while 66% of people own homes. I don’t think you know what you’re talking about even regarding this specific town.
* Republican states largely bar municipal minimum wages. That doesn’t make the solution to blanket the entire country in a $40 minimum. I mean obviously, but that’s a controversial take inside an echo chamber that doesn’t actually care.
Edit: I got so caught up in the specifics of the minimum wage that I completely forgot to mention the main reason this would be stupid: by the time you’re enacting $40 federal minimum wage, you’re far past the point where you can address cost-of-living directly – things like universal healtcare, free and accessible public transit/micromobility, nationalized energy based mostly on renewables and battery storage, subsidized housing, stopping union-busting and monopolies, and I could go on. Like you’re sidestepping (comically dodging, really) actual solutions in favor of the dumbest, most capitalist way to go about solving cost of living while not addressing the underlying issues.
Why would you complain about getting more money per hour lmao
More money? I would be getting zero money per hour, because nobody in their right mind is hiring me for $40/hour.* There’s a point beyond which the minimum wage is a reasonable metric for addressing cost of living, and $40/hour is so comically beyond that point that you may as well be asking “well why not $80/hour? Don’t you like more money??”. “Sky’s the limit when you don’t give a shit.”
What I’m complaining about is people taking a chance to advocate for beneficial if idealistic change – a solid, living minimum wage combined with systemic change like robust, de-privatized services, including healthcare, energy, transport, food, etc. (or fuck it: just actual, outright socialism at this level of political willpower) – and instead derailing it to circlejerk over obviously infeasible bullshit that actively makes the problem much worse. $40 minimum wage is the second-grader’s solution to cost of living.
* I say this, but what actually happens if federal minimum wage is magically made $40/hour and then magically made to stay there (i.e. there’s no takesies-backsies) is that the economy goes into a freefall and the Treasury prints money until US dollar is devalued enough for the riots to stop.
It’s not the change that hurts, it’s the rate of change. Most states that raised their minimum wages to > $15/hour phased it in over multiple years for exactly this reason
No, at $40/hour, it’s definitely also the change itself. You can’t just phase that in over “multiple years”, unless “multiple” is “decades’ worth”.
I get what you’re saying, that’s part of it, but not nearly a large enough part that such a batshit number is even worth discussing outside of a completely unserious thought experiment – about the same level of thought experiment seriousness as “what would happen if we built a poopcano?”
Sign in to comment. Sign in