Skip to content

Comment on Demonstration of why russia's surface naval fleet is obsolete in the Baltic Sea

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @supersquirrel@lemmy.caOP· · edited

    Yes but this is a different level entirely. The timetable a missile truck and cargo aircraft could take out a russian warship in the Baltics is almost incomprehensibly short.

    Think about it, at first this seems like an awful idea compared to landing the C-17 (which is a strategic asset that takes years to replace) a safer distance away and driving the himars truck into range of a russian ship but that will take hours and the C-17 either has to wait on the ground vulnerable to long range strike drones/missiles or it has to ditch the missile truck and crew (which is one reason why the us marines use an unmanned humvee as a platform for their nemesis antiship missiles).

    With this strategy demonstrated in this video however the time on the ground is measured in minutes and the missile crew can be airlifted immediately to somewhere safe to reload. It is an incredibly bold and intimidating tactic to face up against as a russian warship in a littoral environment like the Baltic Sea, in the span of time a C-17 can land, unload a missile truck on a runway 100km away hidden by topography, fire off the missile, load the truck and takeoff a russian warship will barely have been able to complete a tight u-turn and begin heading out of range and that is if they realize what is happening immediately… It also means that russian warships in this environment must be able to quickly target and engage large aircraft at the very limits of their range with near 100% success, even when under attack by a swarm of drones at close range, or else they are just massively expensive sitting ducks.

    The ultimate impact of this strategy is that behind every wall of overwhelming electronic warfare and jamming positioned against russia this capability could apparate seemingly out of thin air and obliterate a ship in a matter of minutes.

    1
    • Yes but this is a different level entirely. The timetable a missile truck and cargo aircraft could take out a russian warship in the Baltics is almost incomprehensibly short.

      It’s always been like that though, with air-launched anti-ship missiles, and pre-positioned ground launched weapons (though NATO definitely has a capability gap there for now).

      I can absolutely see the benefit this has for islands, but for the mainland, Russia has always had to deal with the fact that a truck could drive through the woods and launch at their ships. The woods of Finland have always been able to randomly shoot missiles, even at a strategic scale now that launchers are not limited to MLRS speeds. This just adds that capability to all the islands big enough for a runway as well.

      It also means that russian warships in this environment must be able to quickly target and engage large aircraft at the very limits of their range with near 100% success, even when under attack by a swarm of drones at close range, or else they are just massively expensive sitting ducks.

      That’s a huge benefit, especially since Russian doctrine means they probably won’t be doing it under air cover.

      1
      • The woods of Finland have always been able to randomly shoot missiles, even at a strategic scale now that launchers are not limited to MLRS speeds.

        I am picturing a bunch of Ents with oversized RPG launchers.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in