It’s because the cutoff date for the game awards is Nov 20 and the reviewers that nominated it have been playing it for at least a week. They intentionally chose the release date so they can fit in this year.
Why just make this up? You don’t want GTA to be good, so it could only get these nominations if they bought them? As though this series hasn’t been a critical darling for decades. Did big moneyed publishers forget to pay their bribes last year so that Expedition 33 could win everything? Why didn’t Sony simply pay enough money for Wolverine to be nominated?
People here pointing out that reviewers likely have been playing the game. I’d still argue it’s pretty whack because the pre-release review experience - for a huge game that’s already suffered multiple leaks, that’s already made a billion dollars and doesn’t really need reviews - is going to be more locked down than the other nominees current status. We don’t know that every voter has had access, or the kind of access needed to make a fair judgment. Also, the game could have a 40+ hour main story… was every voter able to complete the majority of it?
Doesn’t really matter, it’s a marketing event, but Geoff wants to have it both ways and that is annoying.
I doubt they were even allowed to openly discuss the game among themselves unless the NDA had a specific exception clause for award shows which would really rub me the wrong way too.
Maybe it’s just me but TGA feel really out of touch this year. At least more than usual and I think their lack of transparency has a lot to do with it.
I know a lot of people will just shrug it off as shallow popularity contest or trailer show which I agree with to some extend. Culturally however, I like the idea of honoring exceptional work and I think their way of doing that just undermines it, sadly.
Maybe it’s just me but TGA feel really out of touch this year.
Tbf, they were out of touch last year. It was already really clear everyone was tired of the over-funded live service crap, but that didn’t stop TGA from having Highguard as their big reveal at the end.
They are not allowed to disclose their verdicts yet so they couldn‘t even argue why they think this is GOTY. Obviously there was no discussion happening during the selection phase. GTA6 being nominated 8 times really exposed how shallow the whole thing is.
I copy part of my other reply: GTA 6 on the other hand is already in reviewers hand since 3 weeks, and they tested, reviewed and gave ratings. The articles are mostly done. They just wait until the review embargo is lifted, but they already know how good or bad the game is and can vote already.
Comments
How does a game that hasn’t been released yet get nominated for everything?
Because game awards are nothing more than fancy marketing campaigns.
Community votes only weigh at 10% of the final decision. The other 90% is from a “jury panel of media and influencer outlets”, i.e. paid off schmucks.
Nominations are paid for.
Money.
It’s because the cutoff date for the game awards is Nov 20 and the reviewers that nominated it have been playing it for at least a week. They intentionally chose the release date so they can fit in this year.
Why just make this up? You don’t want GTA to be good, so it could only get these nominations if they bought them? As though this series hasn’t been a critical darling for decades. Did big moneyed publishers forget to pay their bribes last year so that Expedition 33 could win everything? Why didn’t Sony simply pay enough money for Wolverine to be nominated?
People here pointing out that reviewers likely have been playing the game. I’d still argue it’s pretty whack because the pre-release review experience - for a huge game that’s already suffered multiple leaks, that’s already made a billion dollars and doesn’t really need reviews - is going to be more locked down than the other nominees current status. We don’t know that every voter has had access, or the kind of access needed to make a fair judgment. Also, the game could have a 40+ hour main story… was every voter able to complete the majority of it?
Doesn’t really matter, it’s a marketing event, but Geoff wants to have it both ways and that is annoying.
I doubt they were even allowed to openly discuss the game among themselves unless the NDA had a specific exception clause for award shows which would really rub me the wrong way too.
Maybe it’s just me but TGA feel really out of touch this year. At least more than usual and I think their lack of transparency has a lot to do with it.
I know a lot of people will just shrug it off as shallow popularity contest or trailer show which I agree with to some extend. Culturally however, I like the idea of honoring exceptional work and I think their way of doing that just undermines it, sadly.
Tbf, they were out of touch last year. It was already really clear everyone was tired of the over-funded live service crap, but that didn’t stop TGA from having Highguard as their big reveal at the end.
Because the panel that nominates and votes on the awards are the same review outlets that got advance copies.
They are not allowed to disclose their verdicts yet so they couldn‘t even argue why they think this is GOTY. Obviously there was no discussion happening during the selection phase. GTA6 being nominated 8 times really exposed how shallow the whole thing is.
I don’t think there is discussion. The panel is like 100+ outlets that fill out questionnaires.
As far as I know, these awards are organized by media outlets or some such. They get versions of games before they are officially released.
I copy part of my other reply: GTA 6 on the other hand is already in reviewers hand since 3 weeks, and they tested, reviewed and gave ratings. The articles are mostly done. They just wait until the review embargo is lifted, but they already know how good or bad the game is and can vote already.
Is this your first industry awards event? ;)
Sign in to comment. Sign in