No indie game made it to the Game of the Year nomination is a bit baffling, such as Mina the Hollower. Also Big Walk and Sektori got higher scores than Phantom Blade 0, Control Resonant, 007 First Light and Resident Evil Requiem.
Big walk didn’t make it vecause of the whole AI thing i believe. But agree. At least tgere is a game nominated thag isn’t even out yet. Idk, the whole game of the year thing just seems dumb. Not oscar level dumb, but we are getting there.
GOTY isn’t Best Game, it’s most impactful, most discussed, most influential… It’s the game that defined the year (Astrobot stole the award from Balatro and I will die on this hill)
I mean their criteria is that GOTY is the best game, according their description. Usually any GOTY award is by definition their opinion of best game. That’s why I’m confused that worse rated games are nominated for GOTY over games with better ratings.
One explanation is, that the award show does not ask all critics from Metacritic. And that makes a different recommendation.
Comments
No indie game made it to the Game of the Year nomination is a bit baffling, such as Mina the Hollower. Also Big Walk and Sektori got higher scores than Phantom Blade 0, Control Resonant, 007 First Light and Resident Evil Requiem.
I had a discussion round about GOTY nominations a few days before: https://lemmy.ml/post/55307499
Big walk didn’t make it vecause of the whole AI thing i believe. But agree. At least tgere is a game nominated thag isn’t even out yet. Idk, the whole game of the year thing just seems dumb. Not oscar level dumb, but we are getting there.
But the game is nominated for other category. And nowhere they state that using Ai disqualifies for GOTY, but is allowed for other categories.
GOTY isn’t Best Game, it’s most impactful, most discussed, most influential… It’s the game that defined the year (Astrobot stole the award from Balatro and I will die on this hill)
I think GOTY means best game. It makes no sense to vote for a game that is worse. According their description:
Yea that’s just marketing fluff.
GOTY is a bs title that is entirely meaningless when it comes to how good a game actually is.
I mean their criteria is that GOTY is the best game, according their description. Usually any GOTY award is by definition their opinion of best game. That’s why I’m confused that worse rated games are nominated for GOTY over games with better ratings.
One explanation is, that the award show does not ask all critics from Metacritic. And that makes a different recommendation.
Sign in to comment. Sign in