373
Microsoft-pilled sysadmin blocked Thunderbird "for safety"
“Only Microsoft® Outlook for Windows™ is secure, use that application for read the email on your computer”
Ok, I’m on linux, that means I won’t be reachable on the work email.
“Only Microsoft® Outlook for Windows™ is secure, use that application for read the email on your computer”
Ok, I’m on linux, that means I won’t be reachable on the work email.
Comments
I’ve moved to https://mailcraft.dev/ until they figure out that one.
As the only Linux guy in my shop, I just wait for their apps/updates to completely brick things and until the place is practically on fire, and when the moment is right, I just start complaining.
“My operating system is SO BORING. TWO MONTHS UPTIME AND IT JUST FUCKING WORKS. 650 updates and I don’t even need a restart. NOTHING I DO BREAKS IT. ARRRRGH IT IS SOOOO BOOOORINNNNG.”
Every now and then it’s fun to throw a symlink back to C: in your documents file. Cyber loves it when you backup everything to your OneDrive.
Having always been the only Linux guy at many places early in my career, I’ve finally pivoted to running the show with my last job change.
Boy, are we currently developing a long term concept with open source all over it. Supporting hosting on open source platforms is a requirement for new products and has cost two vendors their contracts so far.
I am raining fire on that passive, whiny attitude of can’t-do-anything-about-it slavery to locked down platforms in medium sized companies and the numbers, robustness to costs say I’m right.
BROTHER
We keep the lable maker next to the coffee maker.
I haven’t had a Windows update break anything in over a decade. Not at home, not in two sysadmin roles.
What are you running, Windows XP devoid of updates?
Then you’ve not been paying a lot of attention, or accidentally held back an awful lot of updates.
I don’t hold back at home, just allow middle-of-the-night updates and the occasional reboot. At work I used WSUS to hold off on updates until I could read the news, let them stew a week unless it was a critical security update.
I did doge that monster CRM breaking update at work, but again, that was over 10 years ago.
Look, I can’t fight the hivemind. Lemmy is convinced that Windows is in a constant state of broken. I’ve had my home Windows install since Win10, same SSD, across 4 PCs, haven’t had an OS issue for years. Lemmy will say this is not possible. And then go on to post questions about busted Linux drivers.
I think part of the disconnect is people seeing manufacturer Windows installs as the Windows experience. At home and work, I only install from a clean ISO, so I dodge almost all the crap people bitch about.
I’ve had every Linux desktop I installed in the last decade, except Mint, commit suicide after a few weeks to months due to borked updates. Every single one.
YMMV.
(Sure, they where salvagable, but that’s not the point: Linux too has its upgrade and dependency bullshit. That is my point. Linux is not immune to bad updates.)
True, all things ARE fallible, BUT Linux (I mean real Linux, example- Fedora/Debian) I’m NOT including things like Arch/etc- does not threaten to self destruct for millions of people every other Tuesday due to untested vibe-coded updates. Last Tuesday they pushed KB5132061 and broke printing for several tens of thousands of people.
Yeah, a few weeks ago even Copy Paste got nuked by an update, so either he’s not updating or doesn’t really use his computer.
It is the same with me. If an update breaks stuff for 0.01 % that still means 10’000 will be affected.
Yeah, that one update hit everyone on my office at the same time so I think it was pretty severe
Broken in Excel, which is not an operating system last I checked.
Nope, system-wide.
There’s been two WINDOWS updates that have broken copy paste in excel:
(KB5002914) And (KB5002934)
And there’s been two WINDOWS updates that have broken clipboard history, which isn’t all of the system but if you did have it activated it broke the clipboard entirely:
KB5058411 and KB5061526
Apparently also build 26200 of win 11 also had clipboard issues system-wide (deleting clipboard after a second until a restart).
All of these were this year, and all of these were Windows updates.
No, he/she is correct. You are just exaggerating and being obtuse.
We use Microsoft Outlook at work too and we block other email clients because you can’t set sensitivity labels in other applications which means that we can’t implement data loss prevention features to do things like prevent the accidental sending of internal emails to external recipients.
We also can’t perform a targeted deletion of company data from non Outlook email clients or non OneDrive cloud storage systems.
It might be infuriating but it is totally reasonable.
Leave it to Microsoft to make open standards incompatible.
Thank you for the good explanation, have a downvote, I hate this. 😁
I use a government deployment of Outlook that also doesn’t allow multiple Outlook accounts to be activated on the same device. Since I manage 3 email accounts for the City that can’t mix their inboxes for security/Open Records reasons, I have to carry 3 separate work phones.
Alternate user profiles on the same phone doesnt work?
The apps are sandboxed in each profile, so unless its checking a hardware identifier they should be considered separate devices.
Legally though it’s the same device. So record searches, legal holds, and other restrictions apply to a device and not a software delineation. This is important when they may need to physically take a forensics image of your device for legal reasons. Having multiple phones keeps your personal privacy more intact than profiles.
Depends on the level of paranoia of whoever defines the policies. It’s not like there aren’t issues every other days shading doubts about the permeability of sandboxes and such…/
General curiosity. Are you allowed to bring your own phone? If so a pixel with grapheneos let’s you utilize multiple android profiles that are pretty much isolated instances.
My personal phone isn’t going within a mile of government data. I like not having it be Open Records searchable.
Tried this at my job, graphene doesn’t pass safetynet so MDM solutions like intune company portal fail, this making teams and outlook not login.
Truly the bane of my existence.
I now carry multiple phones too.
Kinda depends on what kind of MDM solution they are using.
If they want to manage the whole device, then no, it doesn’t work.
If they only use MDM to manage a few specific apps (MS Intune to manage Outlook/Teams), it works just fine on GOS.
Ive had that exact setup for a while and it worked just fine. Only had to install a “MS certified keyboard app”, so Gboard or the MS version. You do have to install sandboxes google play ser vices though.
You mean your company chose to use MS for those things.
Other services are more open-friendly and offer those features.
Realistically 95% of companies are either going to use Google or Microsoft - the MS solution encompasses everything from webmail/file management/meetings to security and device management for a reasonable fee. It makes it easier to train and hire IT staff - not to mention a wide range of integrations - you just don’t get that to such an extent with other providers.
While I agree in principle that companies should become less dependent on mega corporations it ultimately comes down to affordability, support, security and resilience.
Personally I’d like to see the EU invest in a unified approach to building and fostering adoption in a proper competitor that can be open sourced. From what I’ve seen so far it’s largely been small scale, disorganised, piecemeal approaches to distancing themselves from the US corporations.
Put in that way it makes sense, I guess otherwise it wouldn’t be possible to recall emails already received and something like that
Can’t remotely wipe pst files or .msg files in a folder. I’m just glad my work implemented a block on what keyboards you can use, finally gave me a good excuse to rip teams off my phone.
They expect you to use web mail, in that scenario. If you don’t use Outlook, they can’t track you as easily.
I get that this shit is all driven due to policy settings and configurations, but if companies really cared about security they wouldn’t be throwing all their documents in Azure clouds and using Microsoft software for everything. They should say it like it is.
Many companies care about checking tho boxes for the requirements from their cyber security insurance and that’s it. It’s always about money.
Not so easy as nothing can replace Excel and Active Directory.
Try another Email client, does that work or did they block all Email clients?
Outlook has administrative features. The sysadmin controls them because it’s his responsibility and the choice of the company. Also you can use the web site to read your email.
I hate Outlook but it’s not infuriating, it’s done like that in every company.
It’s done like that and it’s infuriating.
ah it’s absolutely infuriating
if you don’t need all the extra crud in “classic” outlook. web is likely the better choice.
We changed fromgmail to outlook and now I cant usea browser anymore. I have been uncontactable for a year unless atmy desk.
If it’s for work, use what work provides, the end.
Exactly. Work doesn’t provide a laptop, my laptop is with Linux, that means I will be unreachable
It’s weird they let you on their network, but don’t provide you a compliant device. My company recently stopped allowing non-company issued devices on their network.
Yup. My employer also wants us to use Slack, Teams and all sorts of shit, and allows them on your smartphone so long as you install this whole work profile thing that limits what you can do.
I decided to not install any of that shit, they can reach me on my work laptop during work hours or not at all, since they haven’t provided a work phone.
I even refuse to install the 2FA application. It’s on the work laptop itself.
Looks like you’re in Italy?
Isn’t an employer obligated by law to provide you the equipment necessary for work?
Some companies have “bring your own device” policy. It’s not too bad when it’s properly implemented. A proper implementation means
Doing BYOD but insisting in typical corporate IT level restrictions is just being a greedy asshole, that’s not BYOD, that’s just asking for free stuff from your employees.
BYOD should be 100% optional but it’s actually more important for BYOD devices use approved software as it’s the only way to control company data.
If you use Thunderbird on a managed company device we can wipe the whole device if there’s a security issue. We can’t do that with the employee’s own device so we need to insist on approved software to allow the targeted deletion of company data in the event of a security issue.
Some even recommend that the best way to do that is to provide remote desktop access to a managed VM so that the company data never gets onto an unmanaged device.
One of my previous clients did the remote access thing, which was pretty cool. The network was segmented strictly into Office and Lab networks. All communications, emails, documents etc strictly in Office network. People in management, sales, marketing, customer support get strictly managed Windows laptops and connect to the Office network.
Engineers and developers were on the Lab network, with less strict rules and whatever device/OS they choose. They get RDP access to a Windows server in the office network.
Yet another one had a more advanced setup, with the same separation, but developer PCs were configured to receive VLAN trunk, and Office VLAN was routed into a Windows VM.
BYOD is one thing, but often the law says the employer has to provide equipment.
So you can choose to BYOD, but can’t be forced to.
Whatever they say, byod is voluntary.
They gave me an iphone 8 (with the MDM complaining daily that the os is unsupported), but how I’m supposed to read emails with that
1: Lightning to HDMI connector --> external screen.
2: Bluetooth keyboard
Turn that shitty iphone into a desktop PC!
Damn, sounds like a great employer…
Do they block web access too? https://outlook.cloud.microsoft/
Sorry mom
LOL I just received an additional email saying that “for security” they will block any login email from WeTransfer and Dropbox, “use the included onedrive to share files”
The catch is that the cheapskates are paying a Microsoft 365 F3 subscription meaning I only have 2gb shared between onedrive and outlook and it’s already 98% full
let the mail fill it up… right before some vacation days
Can’t you use the web interfaces for these things, if the clients don’t run on your OS?
Can use but I hate it
Used to be able to do this at my place but they’ve recently blocked it.
F3 has very specific usage requirements. If you are regularly sending emails or sharing files, there’s a good chance they are misusing the Frontline license. That said, I’ve seen people using shared mailboxes as regular mailboxes because they are free and technically they can be enabled and given a password.
what kind of company do you work for?
Can you run virtual machines on your work computer?
Time to spin up a little Linux VM inside your work computer with all the things you want.
Any place that allows that is asking to be pwned
No edr or oversight on shadow IT
I think far too many companies have made themselves dependent on Microsoft for stuff they could implement themselves if they cared enough…
But at the end of the day, it’s your company’s data, and their say over where that data is stored and how it is accessed.
You can still access Outlook and OneDrive via the web, so it’s not as though they’re forcing you to install the Microsoft suite. Just that you can’t use another email client they don’t deem to meet their security standards.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-ca/answers/questions/5901453/why-outlook-considers-the-latest-epiphany-release
Can you? Because they pick and choose what browsers can access outlook web.
IT can set or revoke that setting as they please
It requires them to care enough, though. Also, at a certain scale, the requirements for security and access become significant and Microsoft does a decent enough job to make running their service less painful than others.
There is also a lot more risk for executives who choose their own system rather than pick an industry standard.
Funnily enough, Outlook addresses refuse to properly authenticate on Thunderbird for me even on a private device with a private account…
Edit: Gmail on Android (the app) can’t authenticate either.
[deleted]
Oh really? Huh, it’s not like it doesn’t work at all, just very intermittently. This is the first time I’ve heard about it requiring an extension, but I’ll look into it.
Edit: It’s not a work address, btw.
I’ve experienced this one. I get it; they don’t know what they are doing and don’t want any responsibility. But whatever is on the iphone was on the whitelist. I just set up email forwarding to circumvent their stupid policies.
Be careful. This could get you fired if it’s against your company’s policy and an admin could easily verify if they think you are doing it
Definitely
And what’s doubly dumb is the admin could also block automatic forwarding like that, it’s pretty straight forward in Exhange.
This is because they have to take the time to allow Thunderbird graph access inside entra. It’s got nothing to do with security,. I have created a group for anyone who wants to use Thunderbird in our organisation. People just have to know to ask.
not surprising since no exchange out of the box, no domain policies, and the ability to fetch imap/pop3. any sysadmin would do that if they had any sense of devops.
IIRC, the exentsion for Outlook with the Owl, not sure what was the name, logs in using the web login so it does not requires alternative clients to be allowed for login.
It does cost a few $ per year, but it might work for you in this case? I know I couldn’t login normally to Thubderbird, but the extension let me, but it has been a few years ago.
Try Davmail…
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
Sign in to comment. Sign in