300
Nuclear Explosion in Low Earth Orbit Would Disable 98% of Satellites
Apparently, the initial explosion might be the least of our concerns.
shialeboufdoit.gif
Apparently, the initial explosion might be the least of our concerns.
shialeboufdoit.gif
Comments
“Bad thing would make bad things happen.” More news at 11!
Just to be clear, the set of countries that have the ability to nuke LEO is also the set of countries that would destroy all their own satellites by doing so. It would not be a particularly good move for anyone unless a conflict was basically at the stage of general nuclear exchange in which case the satellites are the least of your worries.
You can maybe make an argument for NK but even they aren’t that stupid. China currently provides them all of their political cover and would absolutely hop across the border and paddle them bloody if they did that.
To be fair, all it takes is a narcissistic goon and enough cronies to ruin everyone’s day, even if it’s not in the interest of the general population.
Hmm, which nuclear armed country has a narcisstic goon running it with cronies in all positions of power.
Oh wait, there’s two of them, out of what, 9 countries ? That’s not great odds
I wonder which of USA, North Korea, Russia, and Israel is not in your set of two.
Israel wouldn’t nuke space. They wouldn’t gain anything from it. They fit the other criteria through.
There aren’t any women or children in space.
They have the samson option which is basically nuke entire world, if anybody try to stop them. Nuking the satelites would be one of the way for them to show the world that they are serious about their samson option.
Literally, they are the only ones crazy enough to do it, and they have a reason to do it too
It’s not about
the moneygaining, it’s about sending a message.NK is not making it to LEO. Also, Israel and USA is the same entry.
… URINs
Point well made. 4 it is
*4
Um, 4 if you want to get technical, NK, USA, RUS, and India.
LEO nuke is also a viable strategy to create an EMP. It’s one of the reasons the internet was invented.
Can you please elaborate on that?
ARPANET on Wikipedia.
Interesting, thanks
I hate that kind of bullshit, using unjustifiably heavily loaded language to start and then backpedaling to the point where it pretends it’s clarifying subtle details but finally admits it’s pretty much just splitting hairs with definitions and vaguely nitpicking. It’s so disgustingly disingenuous and I’m not even sure it’s intentional, it’s just the subtly misleading way stuff like this often gets written but it really bothers me.
That’s a quote from The Internet Society. Here’s another quote from the same source:
ARPANET, like the modern internet, were and are pretty resilient on the network level and one of the major components why it’s still working today is that it can route around problems. However, it absolutely needs to have a pretty thick forest for the routing to work and thus it’s not really viable for military as they generally don’t have the time nor resources to build such networks on the battlefield.
Switching network theory does come from RAND, but that’s more or less it. ARPANET founders didn’t have nuclear threat in mind when designing their network.
Obviously today we’ve drifted away from such resilience as half a dozen companies manage majority of everyday things on the net, but the underlying network is still pretty good and centralization of services is a story for another day.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARPANET
Could NK even reach that far up with their missiles?
It’s really not that far up. The hard part of putting something in orbit isn’t getting up, it’s staying there. The hard part isn’t needed in this case 😅
They’ve done a few icbm tests that have give higher than LEO
If they stack enough of them on top of each other, yes
article is poorly written, does not explain what would actually happen. just accepts one scientist’s interpretation as “the truth”.
…and half of them are Musk’s.
Worth it.
peam
Yeah yeah, I played Modern Warfare 2 back in the day
How did they manage to bring that first scene, doing a terrorist attack on an airport in russia. And all we got was a “this scene can get someone offended, lol”. Meanwhile, not many years later, MOH released part of a game where you could play as taliban and everybody went nuts because you were suppose to kill american soldiers.
I mean, people did get really upset at the MW2 mission where you play a CIA agent who shoots up an airport. There was a whole entire moral panic about it in 2009
Aren’t most of them blocked by the earth?
It would Keffler syndrome
Kessler syndrome is the correct term.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
Wow, mocking someone with a lisp is just unnecessarily mean…
If lisp is the problem then I’m happy for them they mastered the s in syndrome so well. Yay!
Not enough ()
emacs user shaming is indeed very mean
it’s not because of kessler syndrome
I didn’t say that. I simply corrected a miss spelling.
*misspelling
go read article and you’ll figure out why it’s not a problem
But they will all come down eventually, if not by radiation damage, then by decommissioning. How are we still allowing this without knowing what it will do to the planet.
Because Elon is going to wring out earth like a rag and throw it in the trash. No worries though, the beautiful ecosystem of Mars is our nut to crack! What a great man we’ve got leading the pack.
yes… Elon the genius who gave the world “full self driving” thats doesnt even work. “elmo” is more like it.
It’s going to bring value to shareholders, stupid. What are you? A communist?
apparently there was a random study saying that metallic nano partciles high up in the atmosphere could impact climate change negatively but i dont remember the name of the papwr
Maybe if there’s enough of them it will reflect sun rays back to space, negating the warming effects of climate change… and make like a giant disco ball in the sky.
Suck it, Aurora Borealis.
Oooh or maybe it’d be just right for us to just get a ring. Maybe not something that’ll make Saturn jealous (the whore…you see how many moons she has following her around?)…something modest. Like the ring around Uranus.
No that’s not true. Most of them will be put in a burn off path at their eol
Yes, they will burn in our atmosphere. That is what the article is talking about.
Well crashing implies lot breaking, which is kinda different to aerobraking
https://feddit.org/pictrs/image/af05d22b-819b-4cf4-b674-34de2be89d23.jpeg
Not what I need to be reading on this week of all weeks, this month of all months, this collapse of all collapses
Meh most of the worlds digital traffic actually goes through cables. Satellites are slow and expensive and usually only last 10-20 years max (less than 5 years for stuff like Starlink). Cables are cheap, direct, can handle huge amounts of traffic and can easily last 50 years.
Losing satellites would be an inconvenience, but actual collapse? Not really.
Everybody would need to learn how to read maps again. Also a lot of time critical production and infrastructure depends on the precise GPS time signal.
GPS satellites would probably be fine. They’re ~50-100x higher in a very different orbit. If you were a giant standing on the surface of earth and the GPS satellites were just over your head, Low Earth Orbit would be skimming the tops of your toes.
Don’t get me wrong, you can absolutely nuke GEO but it would be somewhat harder, take a lot longer (someone may notice you trying to put a fucking nuke through a hohmann transfer) and take out far fewer satellites of military importance.
Also, the military is currently adopting systems that provide GNSS through various terrestrial means (APNT) and your phone already has a the ability to navigate without GNSS by using a database of wifi access points.
gps sats are not in geostationary orbit
dsmac and tercom have been around for decades, some systems can also use star position for navigation
GPS satellites are in MEO, about 20,000 km up. That’s still a lot higher than LEO.
Again is not accurate for bigger parts of humankind. They’d have to learn it at all.
Communication instantly would increase heavily. So many people asking about directions, so many people… Maybe even love stories would come of that, and an increase in the population numbers? A girl once asked me about the time when I was walking home, and then one thing led to the other.
Tell us your love story, ladicius
Some of us can already read a map
the problem would be the Kessler syndrome, more than the loss of satellites immediately
Oh yea that’s the plot of Terror in Resonance
Including your own.
Who told you about my satellites?
dew itttt
I wonder how much difference that would make in my day to day life. Both immediately and longer term assuming nuclear war isn’t started.
Potentially no more GPS
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
Geosynchronous orbit (where GPS satellites are) is not low Earth orbit. They are quite far apart.
FYI, GPS satellites are at an elevation around 20,000 km, which is above low Earth orbit (<2000 km), but not as high as geosynchronous orbit (over 35,000 km).
I last used GPS about 6 months ago to track how long and what speed I cycle home at as I was curious how fast I could go.
Also GPS satellites aren’t low earth orbit.
North Korea taking notes…
Sign in to comment. Sign in