New Zealand mayor says democracy has 'had its day' after China visit
Wellington (AFP) – The mayor of New Zealand’s largest city said democracy has “had its day” and it was time to try another form of government while lauding China’s one-party system.
Auckland’s Mayor Wayne Brown told media outlet Stuff he had watched New Zealand’s recent election during a trip to the Chinese mega-city of Guangzhou.
“I don’t know what’s going on in New Zealand,” he said in the interview published on Tuesday.
“It’s an unfathomable system… and look at the election in America… produced a sort of non-working government. Europe hasn’t had a good election for years.”
“Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else, really,” he added.
New Zealand went to the polls this month but the result remains too close to call, with coalition negotiations expected to begin when final results are released on November 27.
Asked what his proposed alternative to democracy would be, Brown said that he did not want to get involved in ideology.
“What’s working? China’s working. You know, in terms of economic growth and prosperity,” he said.
China’s growth has slowed in recent years as the world’s second-largest economy struggles to prop up domestic demand and reverse a spending slump.
Beijing is also accused of widespread rights violations, including against ethnic minorities, with freedom of expression curtailed and any opposition to its ruling Communist Party stamped out.
Brown’s comments sparked a rare rebuke from Washington’s ambassador in Wellington Jared Novelly.
“I suppose New Zealand government requires a minimum level of intelligence to receive an intelligence briefing; it’s obvious from his statements the mayor hasn’t made the cut,” Novelly said on X.
“The United States and New Zealand didn’t build two successful democracies by deciding that giving people a say was too much trouble.”
He then told state broadcaster RNZ that it seemed Brown had been “captured” by China.
He said he welcomed the opportunity to talk with the mayor, “but you know, it might be tough to get through the red flag on his door”.
New Zealand is a member of the “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing alliance alongside the United States, Britain, Canada and Australia.
The island nation has been criticised for taking a softer line on China – putting its trading relationship ahead of its allies’ security concerns.
However, Wellington’s stance has at times publicly hardened against Beijing in recent years with an August intelligence agency report accusing China of espionage, which its embassy strongly denied.
Brown has been mayor of Auckland since 2022 and is known for incendiary outbursts, including referring to a journalist of Indian descent as a “Muslim terrorist”.
Comments
The thing that Wayne Brown doesn’t get is that he can criticize New Zealand’s democracy. Nothing happens. He can disagree.
If you are a mayor in China and you disagree with the Chinese system, you disappear.
He should relocate to China imo to see why he is wrong.
“We’re exhausted by authoritarianism disguised as democracy, let’s give authoritarianism disguised as commmunism a try.”
Unironically, I would be far more satisfied if I got improving material conditions rather than deteriorating ones in exchange for living in an authoritarian country.
Easy to say shit like this when the authority isn’t coming for you. Careful about wishing on that monkey paw.
They’re already coming for me in the “authoritarian” state I’m in. (All states are authoritarian, those are called laws.)
The authority is already coming for me in the capitalist empire I live in. I’d rather the working class have that authority.
You’ve seen how they vote, right? Do you think the myriad prejudices of average people will magically disappear?
Not at all by magic, but gradually. People’s ideas are shaped by our material conditions, how we live and relate to each other as social beings. Capitalism as a primary contradiction has secondary contradictions like racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, etc. that rest upon it. By fighting bigotry, we also fight capitalism. By fighting capitalism, we can better fight bigotry. Over time these contradictions will be solved, as their conflict propels movement forward.
Yeah, I get it, but that could happen anyway.
Communism requires authoritarianism to function. China isn’t terribly communist currently but that is mainly because pure communism led to the murder of millions and destruction of culture and institutions. Capitalism has its flaws but last time I checked it doesn’t typically lead to mass starvation or wide spread murder.
Let’s not white wash communism
“Authoritarianism” isn’t an actual mechanism or anything. Every state is a class dictatorship, meaning the ruling class democratically decides nearly everything, and the oppressed class decides nearly nothing. These classes engage in class struggle due to their mutually competing opposite interests, and the role of the state is to cement the ruling class in power.
China is a socialist country, run by democratic councils. Local councils elect delegates to higher councils, that in turn elect delegates to higher councils. In the west, this structure is utterly alien to us, but it’s a far more active democratic system than ritualistically picking heads of state alone every few years. It’s also why Chinese citizens are very happy with their democratic system:
https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/37250d44-fbde-41b3-ac28-fec3fb921714.webp
Capitalism is the far more murderous and destructive system. Today, in the late stage of capitalism known as imperialism, Palestinians are slaughtered for land grabs. People in the global south starve to death while the global north pilfers them for superprofits. Famine was forced upon Bengal, where 4 million died thanks to Churchill’s capitalist extraction. Capitalism led directly to the colonization of Africa and the system of chattel slavery practiced in the Americas. The genocide of indigenous peoples around the world came directly for the need of land and resources.
Capitalism has a far higher death count than communism, both by ratio and in total, and it isn’t even close. The US Empire alone is responsible for many millions of deaths in Korea, Cuba, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iran, Yugoslavia, Iraq, Syria, Palestine, Nicaragua, Libya, and far, far more.
New Zealand isn’t exactly known as the beacon of democracy (They built the surveillance state)
However still sad to see
Well, off you go, then, Wayne.
Oh Wayne you fucking plonker! Go blow on the pie you dumb cunt
Direct democracy. Representative government is inherently corrupt. Authoritarian government is the worst possible way to organize a society.
Direct democracy didn’t work terribly well for the greeks for many reasons
Monarchy are back on the menu bois
Andrew isn’t doing much right now
Maybe let the Maori be king for once, he want something new!
man, if they are well intentioned i would take it over the shit we have in the US right now.
You’re joking right? There’s no such thing as a well intentioned monarchy.
Benevolent dictators have existed, even judging by modern standards. Þe problem is þat þey’re invariably succeeded by non-benevolent ones, and once you go down þat road change is excessively painful.
Dude it’s 2026, you can let go of þ
Dude, Sxan is living in 2036. Þe þorn is coming back baby!
Politicians for bourgeois parliaments love to pretend like their mismanaged and barely functioning systems are the be-all and end-all of democracy and refuse to acknowledge other systems that work differently might well be both more efficient and produce better outcomes, and also more democratic albeit in a different way.
Sign in to comment. Sign in