I mean, I’m sure the game is fine, but acting like “videogame critics” are a good measurement for the overall quality of the product would be naive.
They’re the first to dissect indie games with surgical precision, yet the tune often seem to change drastically when highly anticipated triple-A games come into play. Not exactly calling them sell-outs… yet I truly wonder how a game that struggles to mantain 30fps on any platform it launches on, is considered a 100/100 for a magazine. Like, at this point what does it even mean to have many reviewers give a game a full 100, if we’ve been proven many times that it can be assigned to games with various problems, both in technical and design departments?
You’re right in saying that my last paragraph sounds like an exaggeration, I mistakenly repeated metacritic when I meant reviewers in general. Fixed :)
I still think there’s something odd with the system as a whole if one hundred and fifty critics mostly agree on a “100/100” score. Like, this means that 99% of them never got bored, never didn’t like a mission, never felt the story dragged for a bit more, never found flaws in any of the characters.
How much of the game they played, I wonder? Because look at GTA V: roughly a 97 on Metacritic. A game that, by all accounts, surprised us all with a strong introduction… only to be met by weak character stories and awful narrative pacing. It feels like they’re voting on the technical feat, more than anything.
In a story-driven game without much else going on, such problems would really drag the overall package down. The thing about these GTA games is that there’s so much to do and see that most people can be satisfied fully by just a subset of it. Heck I know some people who still, to this day, have never even tried GTAV’s story mode despite putting hundreds upon hundreds of hours into the game, and those flaws aren’t of concern to them at all.
I guess I’ve never been enough of a fan of rockstar’s sandboxes to see it that way. Still, you make a good point :) I’ve recently realized there seems to be a lot of pure hatred for GTAVI as a concept more than anything else on lemmy/piefed, which isn’t my type of thing - I wanted to merely provide a different point of view from the fomo and hype which can be a little extra when it comes to this company’s games. I’m sure the game is good and fun at the end of the day. I hope they don’t start doing mass layoffs once again, though.
Comments
I mean, I’m sure the game is fine, but acting like “videogame critics” are a good measurement for the overall quality of the product would be naive.
They’re the first to dissect indie games with surgical precision, yet the tune often seem to change drastically when highly anticipated triple-A games come into play. Not exactly calling them sell-outs… yet I truly wonder how a game that struggles to mantain 30fps on any platform it launches on, is considered a 100/100 for a magazine. Like, at this point what does it even mean to have many reviewers give a game a full 100, if we’ve been proven many times that it can be assigned to games with various problems, both in technical and design departments?
What are the last three games with over 95 on MC or OC that didn’t deserve it at all?
You’re right in saying that my last paragraph sounds like an exaggeration, I mistakenly repeated metacritic when I meant reviewers in general. Fixed :)
I still think there’s something odd with the system as a whole if one hundred and fifty critics mostly agree on a “100/100” score. Like, this means that 99% of them never got bored, never didn’t like a mission, never felt the story dragged for a bit more, never found flaws in any of the characters.
How much of the game they played, I wonder? Because look at GTA V: roughly a 97 on Metacritic. A game that, by all accounts, surprised us all with a strong introduction… only to be met by weak character stories and awful narrative pacing. It feels like they’re voting on the technical feat, more than anything.
In a story-driven game without much else going on, such problems would really drag the overall package down. The thing about these GTA games is that there’s so much to do and see that most people can be satisfied fully by just a subset of it. Heck I know some people who still, to this day, have never even tried GTAV’s story mode despite putting hundreds upon hundreds of hours into the game, and those flaws aren’t of concern to them at all.
I guess I’ve never been enough of a fan of rockstar’s sandboxes to see it that way. Still, you make a good point :) I’ve recently realized there seems to be a lot of pure hatred for GTAVI as a concept more than anything else on lemmy/piefed, which isn’t my type of thing - I wanted to merely provide a different point of view from the fomo and hype which can be a little extra when it comes to this company’s games. I’m sure the game is good and fun at the end of the day. I hope they don’t start doing mass layoffs once again, though.
[deleted]
Ocarina of time remake got 95 on metacritic.
It doesn’t deserve it at all?
It’s a remake of a 30 year old kids game. I think the score is biased
Sign in to comment. Sign in