Comment on Grand Theft Auto VI Reviews - 98/100 OpenCritic Rating, 100% Critics Recommended
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
There’s a difference between not being naive and being aggressively cynical.
All evidence so far points to it being a great game. It’s bizarre for people who haven’t played it to be this dismissive, in the face of an overwhelmingly positive reception by those who have.
Lots of precedent of games getting a bunch of perfect scores from professionals because it’s Bioware or Nintendo or Bethesda or whatever. The big players get soft gloves, it’s true. Some stuff really is that good. Other games get 10’s across the board initially and then turn out to be kinda shit like Veilguard.
I’m still playing GTA 6 tomorrow on a base model PS5 which reportedly cannot maintain 30FPS while data streaming as you drive around. I don’t care that it’s not flawless, I just chuckle at game journalism.
It has an 82 on MC and an 80 on OC. It clearly was not getting 10s across the board.
Yeah I don’t disagree. On the other hand, it would have been absolutely wild if Rockstar, given their history, and the time and resources pumped into this, didn’t deliver.
Can you point to any AAA game that was panned by critics before release as evidence they aren’t acting as little more than free advertisements for the big studios?
The whole concept is flawed considering these companies have hundreds of millions or billions of dollars riding on these games selling quickly and they chose who is allowed to get early release copies in order to do these reviews. This means the reviewers are entirely dependent on staying in the good graces of these companies in order to retain the ability to keep reviewing their games in the future. If they piss a studio off, that studio is likely to withhold games from them in the future while giving copies to all the competing reviewers. Reviewers don’t want you reading their competitor’s websites since they have little else to offer their customers, so they treat these big games with kid gloves to keep the whole system going.
None of this is new or exclusive to Lemmy.
Look, I’m not here to convince anyone of the merits of the game, and I couldn’t if I wanted to, because I haven’t played it yet. I’m just pointing out that there is a significant percentage of negative attitude towards it here that is entirely at odds with reviews and the response from the general public in the regions that it’s available.
As I say, I don’t care about the reason why, I just find it funny. It comes across as (and I’m not saying that it’s the case - it just comes across as) a real edgelord/superiority complex vibe from some areas. Some people clearly want it to be shit, or have already decided it is purely on frame rates, and really want people to know. If they were so not-arsed about the game, why waste their time telling us it’s not worth playing.
I do see what youre saying and personally have no opinion on the game either way. My comment was just pointing out how flawed and essentially worthless professional game reviews are. I feel the same about movie and product reviews too. There’s too great of an incentive to lie in favor of the product and very little downside to doing so.
Yeah a few people have said the same about not trusting the critics. It’s just interesting that these kind of comments only appear en-masse for a (currently console exclusive) game like this, and not something like Silksong that was also universally praised by reviewers.
It’s clearly a selective distrust, that has manifested here by people who want us to know how much they aren’t interested in GTAVI by telling us repeatedly.
I dont think that distrust is misplaced. We’ve gone through a decade of major corporate studios with bloated budgets releasing buggy, half finished games that are designed around draining your wallet through gimmicks all while being praised about how great they are. GTA VI and Rockstar epitomizes all of that at a whole new level which is why you’re seeing such a response. People think this major corporation is trying to pull one over on them to protect their investment yet again.
If you saw years of talk about McDonalds releasing a new burger followed by a bunch of influencers talking about how amazing and perfect this new McDonalds burger is, wouldn’t you be pretty skeptical about it? McDonalds isn’t exactly known for quality.
What you think is cynicism is just Lemmy having higher standards. I don’t care how good the game would be at 60+ fps… If it’s running at 30 fps (or lower) it will actively ruin the experience and is not worth my time.
Considering the other guy thinks 30 fps is an unplayable stuttery mess and that it’s not a matter of tolerance, combined with wilful ignorance that a smooth 30 fps is more than possible, cynicism is definitely at play here.
My Guy the game runs at 30fps. That is simply not acceptable. Correctly pointing that out is not being aggressively cynical, it is the bare minimum of criticism.
I mean, if you say so my guy.
I haven’t played it yet, so it’s not for me to say.
Yes it’s 30fps. That’s established, and has not been neglected by reviewers. And the reviews so far indicate that it’s a great game despite being 30fps. Writing it off because of that fact, without actually playing it, and in the face of all the evidence pointing to it being well worth your time, is an interesting choice.
Waaaaaaaaaaaaaah
Are you defending the game running at 30fps?
I’ve never noticed a difference between 30 and 60 unless they’re presented side-by-side. I couldn’t care less
Then you’re really not paying attention. The difference is immediate and obvious.
Sign in to comment. Sign in