Skip to content

Comment on Grand Theft Auto VI Reviews - 98/100 OpenCritic Rating, 100% Critics Recommended

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Ok AAA games are generally over hyped, but this isn’t some Microsoft owned studio. This is Rockstar. Their worst game is at worst, pretty good. GTA 5 and RDR2 are generational titles. They didn’t pump one of these out every year in order to make billions annually. They worked on this game for over a decade. Worst case, GTA6 has real artistry and intention of in its design.

    Only problem is they are forcing us PC gamers to wait for an undetermined amount of time, but Rockstar has enough pedigree that I’m confident that this game will be at least close to these review scores.

    23
    • Those aren’t generational titles, and they wouldnt have taken so long to make another game if not for their live service bringing in billions. They are using all that money to refine and ensure they can make even more money.

      Rockstar has gone the way of Call of Duty. Over-hyped games that overstay their welcome.

      I’m sure in about a year I’ll have a decent weekend playing through a pirated copy of GTA 6 on my PC, and then I’ll forget about it.

      A giant social event doesnt make a game good. There isnt even any multiplayer yet ffs.

      6
      • Did you even Play those Games you mentioned? GTA is not at all Like cod. Sure your point about Live Service is prolly valid but saying they are the Same is disingenuous

        -2
        • The comparison is a franchise that started out focused on making good games and ended up being a vehicle to make obscene amounts of money.

          5
          • Sure. That Sounds more reasonable but id still argue that every gta is more memorable than any COD Which is more comparable to fifa

            -1
            • @Rekorse@sh.itjust.works· · edited

              Sort of, its maybe a better comparison due to the fact they both have separate online and offline game modes. COD 1-3 had fantastic campaigns for the time, the multiplayer didnt become more widespread until it hit consoles. I’d argue theres a similar trend there to GTA 1-3 and vice city.

              I think once a piece of art becomes worth a certain amount of money, the money kills the art. For some reason, art made with the intent to make money doesnt seem to work as well.

              I think GTA6 is only the “biggest game in the world” right now because a lot of people with a lot of money, and those that stand to make a lot of money or already have, are pumping it up on social media and mainstream news. Theres otherwise no justification for it.

              2
    • They should have been dismantled when they fired people for unionizing. This game only exists because no one has a fucking spine anymore.

      2
    • @1984@lemmy.today· · edited

      The problem is that they expected peoples computers to be top notch when we just had impossible upgrade prices for five years, and still do.

      And also that their game can’t run properly even on consoles. But the normies will buy it anyway.

      2
      • Even my fairly crap PC is better than a PS5. So it’s not a totally unreasonable expectation but yeah you’re right it’s nowhere near as advances it would be if NVIDIA didn’t decide to crash the market. But you never know maybe AI can solve the problem that it created and it can just vibe us a PC port. In fact I actually think the threat of that happening will probably prompt rockstar to release a PC version sooner rather than later.

        3
    • They rake in billions annually through the live service ecosystem they have created. That has little to do with quality and everything to do with monetization.

      17
      • I think they have actually realized though that they would probably make even more money if GTA Online was designed with a bit of intentionality.

        Everyone got so sick of constantly getting blown up by random flying motorcycles with infinite rockets that they nerfed the darn thing, I think they probably should have deleted it but that would of course some problems for them. They have said that they want grand theft auto online 2 (or whatever it ends up being called) to be considerably more grounded. People are much more likely to pay for things if they can actually play the damn game in peace. I never got into Grand Theft Auto Online for precisely that reason, and I’m not alone.

        0
      • But to monetize it in the first place they do need a good enough game that people play though.

        6
        • By that standard Roblox is the best game in the world so why would you want to play GTA6?

          2
    • Their worst game is… Pretty good? What are you smoking?

      Most rockstar games feel and play so janky I have no idea why people like them.

      They have managed to make a lot of mediocre games that are in a genre people are willing to slog through.

      So I am sure it will sell well, as people like mindless jank. But I wouldn’t call it good.

      0
      • If Rockstar games are janky, mediocre, and mindless, then what games aren’t? It would have to be an extremely short list of games.

        0
        • No they aren’t in other games.

          I meant literally, it is a common criticism in most rockstar games. The movement doesnt seem right, its floaty. Or the animation sequences in the middle of it seem crammed in (like in RD2).

          Like this post "it feels too floaty. Like your character has their own idea of what controls do. The realistic steps, and turning are not intuitive. I feel like I’m telling them what to do, and they do their best .5 seconds later. "

          That is rockstar in a nutshell.

          1
      • What are you smoking?

        The same old stuff.

        Most rockstar games feel and play so janky I have no idea why people like them.

        Maybe because they invented/popularized the open world genre?

        They have managed to make a lot of mediocre games that are in a genre people are willing to slog through.

        You mean a genre they invented?

        -2
        • What the hell? Are you really smoking something? I’m not the OP, but I gotta chime in at this ludicrous claim. Open-world games existed well over a decade before Rockstar did:

          Ultima (1981) and Elite (1984): free roaming across a whole map or galaxy. Mercenary (1985): a 3D open world you could explore freely. The Legend of Zelda (1986): the classic “go anywhere from the start” example. Turbo Esprit (1986): driving around an open city. Hunter (1991) and Daggerfall (1996): big 3D open worlds.

          That didn’t even popularize it, all they managed was to popularize was the “sandbox city” formula and with zero innovation in game mechanics.

          7
          • Ok maybe popularized was a better word. But gta3 accomplished creating a seamless 3d open world which was legitimately innovative at the time. Just because you’re indifferent to the game doesn’t make it less historically important.

            -1
          • @1984@lemmy.today· · edited

            Young kids today are not concerned with gaming in the 1980s and those games are not comparable to modern open world games at all.

            What an open world game is today and what it was in 1980 is very different, even though the same word is used for both.

            For me, I would say Eve Online may be one of the oldest open world games that is still popular and has modern graphics.

            -4
            • Depends what you mean by comparable? I mean, graphically no. In pure size daggerfall wins over modern games still. Of course, there’s fuck all to do, and it’s terribly generic, never mind the graphics.

              So, yes, it’s “not comparable” in the sense that experiencing it now would be… Uh, not the same. But he was claiming “invented”. Which isn’t true. Driver, Shenmue, etc did much of the same thing in different way. I think (IIRC) the biggest achievement is the seamless loading on PS2 and the formula.

              1
        • You mean Shenmue? Zelda? Driver?

          They did popularize it though, because they rely on exploiting the subject matter over any decent game play. Nothing ever feels solid or in control, its always sloppy. Kind of works for San Andreas I suppose.

          Kind of amusing that Grand Theft Auto one was an accident.

          4

Sign in to comment. Sign in