Skip to content

Comment on Grand Theft Auto VI Reviews - 98/100 OpenCritic Rating, 100% Critics Recommended

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • What are you smoking?

    The same old stuff.

    Most rockstar games feel and play so janky I have no idea why people like them.

    Maybe because they invented/popularized the open world genre?

    They have managed to make a lot of mediocre games that are in a genre people are willing to slog through.

    You mean a genre they invented?

    -2
    • What the hell? Are you really smoking something? I’m not the OP, but I gotta chime in at this ludicrous claim. Open-world games existed well over a decade before Rockstar did:

      Ultima (1981) and Elite (1984): free roaming across a whole map or galaxy. Mercenary (1985): a 3D open world you could explore freely. The Legend of Zelda (1986): the classic “go anywhere from the start” example. Turbo Esprit (1986): driving around an open city. Hunter (1991) and Daggerfall (1996): big 3D open worlds.

      That didn’t even popularize it, all they managed was to popularize was the “sandbox city” formula and with zero innovation in game mechanics.

      7
      • Ok maybe popularized was a better word. But gta3 accomplished creating a seamless 3d open world which was legitimately innovative at the time. Just because you’re indifferent to the game doesn’t make it less historically important.

        -1
      • @1984@lemmy.today· · edited

        Young kids today are not concerned with gaming in the 1980s and those games are not comparable to modern open world games at all.

        What an open world game is today and what it was in 1980 is very different, even though the same word is used for both.

        For me, I would say Eve Online may be one of the oldest open world games that is still popular and has modern graphics.

        -4
        • Depends what you mean by comparable? I mean, graphically no. In pure size daggerfall wins over modern games still. Of course, there’s fuck all to do, and it’s terribly generic, never mind the graphics.

          So, yes, it’s “not comparable” in the sense that experiencing it now would be… Uh, not the same. But he was claiming “invented”. Which isn’t true. Driver, Shenmue, etc did much of the same thing in different way. I think (IIRC) the biggest achievement is the seamless loading on PS2 and the formula.

          1
    • You mean Shenmue? Zelda? Driver?

      They did popularize it though, because they rely on exploiting the subject matter over any decent game play. Nothing ever feels solid or in control, its always sloppy. Kind of works for San Andreas I suppose.

      Kind of amusing that Grand Theft Auto one was an accident.

      4

Sign in to comment. Sign in