88
Can Syncthing-Fork be trusted now?
Last time I checked there were quite a few shenanigans going on with ownership and transfers, seeming very shifty. But since the original Syncthing for Android is abandoned I feel like i have no choice… Has anybody spotted major red flags or was it just a messy maintainer transfer?
Comments
You can use Syncthing in Termux.
pkg install syncthingIt’s the official Debian package, so it’s pretty much as official as it gets, not even a fork or anything. I assume most people in this community either already use Termux or are comfortable with getting started: https://termux.dev/en/
Set it to automatically run at boot using these instructions: https://www.stephenjianu.com/syncthing-android/
I have been doing this for months, and it’s a very hands-off method to use Syncthing on Android without feeling any different than when I used Syncthing-Fork or any related app. It just runs in the background and does its job.
How’s the battery usage of this method for you? Continuously syncing drains my battery super quickly.
I didn’t notice any difference in battery usage compared to using Syncthing-Fork. But I didn’t really meter it or check a historical usage chart or anything.
Thought about this too, but I have fat fingers so I don’t want to type in a terminal as much as possible on a phone
At least it’s just a one-time setup, and you hypothetically never have to touch it again. If you really want, you can connect a keyboard to your phone to set this up.
But if an app like BasicSync seems more appealing to you, go for it.
FYI there is also BasicSync, it’s working well for me
The design of BasicSync has some performance advantages I think: an embedded syncthing library and it does not shutdown when paused:
https://forum.syncthing.net/t/does-anyone-know-why-syncthing-fork-is-no-longer-available-on-github/25661/256
The dev comes with a decent reputation:
https://forum.syncthing.net/t/does-anyone-know-why-syncthing-fork-is-no-longer-available-on-github/25661/253
Finally it’s GPL3 if you prefer copyleft.
Credit to @darcmage@lemmy.dbzer0.com for posting links above in this topic.
Yeah, I actually prefer basicsync to syncthing-fork.
This is what I have been using ever since. Minimalist code base, works great. But: The project essentially rests on the shoulders of one single dev.
Very true (with most f-droid apps too), but hopefully thanks to the minimalist code base it’ll be easier (even for others) to review and mantain. I even prefer using the web UI since it’s the standard interface on desktop/server as well
I won’t say I followed the drama closely but I think it ended up being nothing more than a messy transfer.
I followed it up until a few months ago. That’s all it was, and like clockwork, the vocal idiots got all up in arms over it.
Yeah, I think it was just messy transfer and that led to more spotlight being put on it which is a good thing, so if something malicious gets attempted there’s a better chance of it getting caught with more eyes on the project.
I’ve been using it still but lagging behind updates by about a couple months.
Just FYI, the original Syncthing Android project has been abandoned for a few years now. Syncthing-Fork has been the defacto go-to for pretty much the whole time after that, until the big nothingburger of ownership transfer happened.
You say nothingburger, but AFAIK the mysterious circumstances have never been fully explained.
It has worked very well for me, and there hasn’t been any weird shenanigans as of right now. It was a bit messy but it’s all good! If you are very paranoid, I think you can use Termux with the Linux version of Syncthing (or hey, go all the way and experiment with a Linux phone if you’re daring!)
I’ve been using the fork without even being aware of any drama. A search came up with this so I guess I’ll just keep using it.
I considered using syncthing a while back but didn’t because syncthing-android was abandoned/archived.
I’m still not sure I understand the point of syncthing if it doesn’t work on android. Is it just used for syncing between PCs now? I feel like that is a pretty narrow use case with other more robust options available.
Before you say “but the cloud”, not everyone wants to store their personal things in a cloud service. For example, I can download a document of some sort on my PC, sign it and save it, and then access that signed form directly on my phone within seconds. No cloud needed. And it works across the internet.
In my original comment I said “if it didn’t work on android”. Seems like, from the responses, it still does.
Without it working on Android, I don’t understand the point of it, was my point.
I find it weird that they stopped dev work on android, given it is the main use case - sync between PC and phone.
You’re missing out unless your other software is superior. What are the other syncing options you use that are multiplatform?
Syncthing has never not worked on Android for me, it’s just different versions and maintainers. Nothing too crazy.
Gotcha. I guess I just find it weird that one of the main use cases, syncing between a PC and phone, they just stopped development on.
I don’t trust anything that hasn’t been around for a while at this point.
Sign in to comment. Sign in