Skip to content

Comment on Epstein death "result of a homicide", claims forensic medicine expert | BBC News

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • I think it was probably suicide… i mean he literally already attempted suicide and was on the watch list. Killing him and not killing Maxwell never really made sense to me. I think most of the stuff like dead cameras and lack of guards is more easily explained by incompetence and laziness than malice.

    0
    • I work in a hospital with a suicide watch area, and a patient got ahold of their pills to OD again one more time while there… It was a crazy confluence of like 10 things that should never happen all happening at once (ER was overflowing and we had so many people on hold she was outside the regular known area with that patient popularion, we didnt have enough sitters on that night for everyone to be 1:1 watched so the sitter she had was also watching someone else, the person watching her was taking their other patient to the bathroom, she was newly arrived so she wasnt changed out to the special clothes they have to wear to signal to everyone they are on a suicide watch, her belongings hadnt been moved to the safety locker yet, and then she asked a passerby to hand her her backpack…)

      Crazy shit happens, sometimes all at once, so while I dont particular know in this case in particular, the whole “theres no way all that coincidental stuff happened all at once” can absolutely all happen at once.

      4
      • In your case though there is one particular source that likely caused all those weird shit to happen which was that ER was overflowing and understaffed. And also this particular person was looking for opportunities to get those pills. So it wasn’t like a string of unrelated chance events really. Here the claim is that all of these just happened randomly by chance without any particular reason and on a very high profile case.

        0
        • Oh for sure the two cases are different… and our patient wasnt THE most high profile suicide watch in the entire world at that point in time… but I just mean to point out a complete system collapse of checks can happen without a conspiracy to make it so. The guards really could have just stepped away for a minute right as the camera failed (or whatever they claim happened, I cant quite remember)

          0
    • attempted suicide

      Wasn’t all these during his time in the prison? I wouldn’t count these as very strict evidence that he was suicidal especially because he himself said he did not attempt suicide and said that his cellmate wanted to kill him.

      Maxwell

      Both of them getting killed at the same time? That is more or less admitting to the crime. My guess is they killed the one that was less compliant and more knowledgeable.

      more easily explained

      Yeah incompetence happens. But incompetence happening in a very high profile case like this makes it even less likely. I wouldn’t therefore say it more easily explains the situation. I wouldn’t even say it is more likely than some powerful figures wanting to kill him, especially if he tried to blackmail them.

      1
      • Idk. Im not 100% convinced it was a suicide, I just think people underestimate how hard it would be to pull off a fake suicide inside a prison. A lot of people would have to be on the take. Meanwhile Nixon couldn’t wiretap a hotel without getting caught.

        Some other things pointing to suicide: -he signed his last will and testament just 2 days before he died.

        -Also days before he wrote that “It is a treat to be able to choose one’s time to say goodbye”

        1
        • The first of the last two could easily have been him being afraid of being killed in the prison. Last one, hearing for the first time so I wouldn’t comment on that without knowing the context.

          Agreed that it is a hard job, probably harder on a high profile case. And also to remove one weak link, you have to create multiple other weak links that might break any other time. But these all depend on what the real cost of him talking is to these people. If he started hurling threats saying he will speak unless they get him out, that might have tipped the balance.

          0

Sign in to comment. Sign in