Comment on Democrat Hakeem Jeffries is nominated to become House speaker, a historic first
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Remember what moderates (and even some “progressives”) did when some people tried to take a stand against the lesser evil for literally committing genocide? Those people still think they were in the right.
I still want to know what you people thought was going to happen when Kamala lost but harder. Something different than what we got?
For clarity, fuck Joe Biden and fuck Kamala. I want to know what would have been different, aside from personal pride that you really stuck it to the man.
You lot seem to be under the impression we thought anything else was going to happen. We’ve stated over and over that the outcome would be the same cause both parties are owned by the same people, but you think we weren’t expecting Trump to win? I didn’t cast my vote for PSL thinking they or Dems would win cause my state was gonna go conservative no matter what. I didn’t care who won.
Well seemingly the plan was to force her to capitulate before she lost; Uncommitted for example kept saying this over and over again but were only subjected to cannibalism by their supposed allies. A united progressive front might’ve gotten it into her thick Zionist head that maybe full-on Zionism was a bad idea (or hell, with enough disruption even forced immediate action; there’s more to resistance than elections). Besides, even if we accept the premise that Harris would’ve lost even harder rather than change course, a principled progressive stance against genocide would’ve sent a signal that Democrats can’t win while backing genocide. Instead we got the worst of both worlds, where the genocide continues unabated, Harris just barely loses and the lesson learned is that progressives can’t take a stand for shit. And even setting aside all that, the cannibalism that happened over the course of 2024 was a net negative to the world all on its own. I remember the vote blue no matter who crowd complaining that the people who might well have been watching their friends and family die for over a year wouldn’t vote for the murderers. We should all remember the people who were—who are—denying that a genocide was even happening because the right party was in charge. Ugh, this disgusts me to even think about. A world where so-called progressives didn’t engage in genocide apologia and victim blaming would’ve been a better one all on its own.
It seems to me that they lack deductive reasoning. They don’t seem to understand that the situation was if not A than B. They wanted not Kamala Harris. Apparently not understanding that not Kamala Harris meant Donald Trump. Maybe they thought Harris losing would somehow result in no president.
I’m incredibility confused by the warning here.
The answer is always to choose the lesser of two evils if you’re faced with a binary choice (and the reality is that often things are binary choices).
But like, the choices never stop?
The decision to put dems in control of congress was the lesser of two evils. The NEXT choice was the choice of speaker. It doesn’t concede the earlier choice.
But like, this is an entirely new choice.
Before I explain myself: I strongly disagree; it’s almost never the case that a choice is truly binary. That requires that, from the nearly infinite potential choices available, only two are viable enough to be considered. Not three, not one, two. Statistically that doesn’t make sense; binary choices are usually the result of imposing either very broad categories or very narrow assumptions. In the case of electoral politics, the assumptions are that:
1- It’s impossible to coerce candidates to change before they’re elected (it’s impossible to choose between multiple potential Harrises).
2- The only result of an election worth thinking about is who wins (it’s impossible to make an electoral choice whose desired results are unrelated to the next guy).
3- Politics can or should prioritize elections over other avenues for progress (it’s impossible to work outside the electoral cycle).
There’s a reason almost no successful protest/resistance movement worked that way. The total rejection of long-term strategy (edit:) would be fatal to any serious movement for social change, which is how you know this isn’t a serious movement for social change.
My point is that the mental framework that the vote blue no matter who crowd were working with is going to (try to) prevent effective resistance to a Democratic but centrist-dominated Congress. The same rhetoric seen in 2024 is going to be mobilized against, say, anti-Jeffries or pro-impeachment protests. Pro-Palestinian protests are the latest attempt at not taking a nap when the lesser evil is in charge and they were smothered to death by not only moderates but also self-proclaimed progressives.
Well I strongly disagree right back.
Which isn’t to say that there is no merit to what you said, only that it casually brushes away the fundamental nature of the universe: The universe is a machine that compresses near infinite futures towards an instantaneous actionable present and leaves in its wake a single immutable past.
We have the luxury of our actions (and especially collective actions) pushing potential futures towards or away from the statistical reality of becoming the present.
But as time marches on, you might be pushing for something that just isn’t realistically viable ANY MORE, while simultaneously driving worse outcomes to being more likely, and alternativly better-and-still-viable futures to being less likely.
The binary choice of a forced dichotomy happening in the present, sure, that’s the naïve and obvious one.
“Is my target future still viable at all?” Is the generalized decision, it is binary, and it is hard.
I admit, once the answer resolves to “no” the implication is follow up questions, like “well what is left? Of those which is best? How can I action towards that one?” But, generally, THAT set of decisions which has increasing variance based on how far you’re looking don’t even get made because people have already made the wrong choice of the earlier binary decision.
So your three assumptions don’t relate to this model at all. It makes no claim about the immutability of politicians. There is no carve out for elections. There is no general prescription for what a politician should prioritize.
The vote blue no matter who crowd? How do I feel about them? Any crowd, really? Function of time. When? A month ago? Wise. Now? Not.
Not really, it’s a continuum from “not at all” to “undeniably yes.” The number of meaningfully different potential answers is literally infinite. It’s only binary if you round up or down, and then you immediately have to decide your threshold for rounding. Which is to say: Even your hyper-generalized model still requires implicit assumptions to produce anything resembling a binary choice, because the world is more complicated than that.
But your model also can’t on its own produce a “vote blue no matter who and don’t protest genocide” conclusion, or for that matter any concrete conclusion about what do actually do; you need more assumptions to tie it into politics in a more concrete way.
I think I did a bad job of explaining, let me try again.
You know if you spin a quarter, sometimes it will lean over and start just start doing that thing where its wobbling mostly on one side, faster and faster and faster until it finally stops (“precession”)?
Just because the coin is still moving, and might continue moving for a really long time, it doesn’t mean that all settled outcomes are equally likely anymore. In reality, they’ve for all practical purposes already collapsed.
That’s all.
Terminal optimists tend to overestimate the likelihood of how realistic the outcomes are. Fatalists underestimate.
My point is about the vast majority of people are neither. They don’t ask the question. They don’t re-evaluate. They set a course at a target a year in the future.
If you guessed heads, and as the coin was wobbling, and tails is showing and you’re offered a chance to change your guess before it settled, you would. For most people, they can see that far into the future when something is staring them in the face.
They just get bad at doing it when things are less tangible.
The coin could phase through the table. Or get hit by a meteor. Or a cosmic magnetic field could push it straight up and down and resolves neither heads nor tails. The possibilities are endless.
But, with a coin, we’re still pretty comfortable restricting our expectations to less than infinity.
But they “took a stand” by making sure the worse of two evils won. The democrats are evil for not protecting people from the fascists…so the answer is to have fascists instead
Nice twist. The people who rejected evil are responsible for one of the two evils, while the liberals who refused to reject evil are the good ones.
If you want to contest my point, you can go to my reply to ContactClosure where I lay out my arguments and respond to them. Otherwise there’s nothing for me to say here. It’d also be nice if you could prove that progressives were especially relevant to Harris’s loss (instead of Harris’s stubbornness alienating less committed voters because progressive policy is popular).
Sign in to comment. Sign in