Skip to content

Comment on Hakeem Jeffries overwhelmingly wins House speaker nomination despite threats from ultra-progressives | CNN Politics

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Youʻve now forced a question onto the American people: What is the point of voting for Democrats as a party?

    Why should they bother?

    0
    • Dems bad

      Republicans are immeasurably worse

      4
      • Voters donʻt care. If “dems bad”, they dont vote. Apologizing for “dems bad” gives bad Dems a pass, and loses elections. This debate was ended November 3rd 2026.

        Your perspective let Trump through in 2024 because guess what? The argument “Dems bad, Republicans worse”, doesnʻt work on voters.

        0
        • @SparroHawc@lemmy.zip· · edited

          This is why there needs to be a two-pronged approach.

          First, push for more progressive candidates who are actually interested in making a difference.

          Second, when votes happen, emphasize harm reduction to anyone who is considering not voting.

          The first by itself means progressive candidates who are in the minority, and majority R legislative bodies stifle progress at every turn.

          The second by itself means moderate and conservative candidates win D seats also stifle progress at every turn, but it happens within the ostensibly progressive party.

          Only with both do we get progress.

          -1
          • Second, when votes happen, emphasize harm reduction to anyone who is considering not voting.

            No. Do not do that, because harm reduction as a strategy isnʻt a good strategy, and was a demonstrated failure in both 2016 and 2024. Its brain rot. It does the opposite of what it purports.

            The only answer is to advocate for better candidates, and to demand they move to more electable positions to get your vote.

            1
    • Oh, that’s easy!

      The Democrats are the people I vote for when third party isn’t available, and I do like heading out to vote. Leaving the boxes blank is quite saddening, you know?

      3
      • Well. Unfortunately, what you do individually is pretty irrelevant. And its funny how whenever this critique of the Democrats is made, its almost instantaneously reduced to what the individuals discussing the point may do or not do: which is entirely irrelevant to the critique. Any anectdotes about what you might do and why: they donʻt have any bearing on this conversation.

        Because the critique isnʻt about how individuals in an obliquely political space behave: its about how voters in aggregate behave. And in-aggregate, American voters are for the large part, almost strictly transactional. Voting, done by actual voters, is treated as a transaction between two parties. Voters do no base their decisions on some NPR promoted view of what Ezra Klein approves of as strategic voting. They look at the situation, and they recognize they ask “What can I get for this?”. If the answer is “Nothing”, they donʻt show up. Its what happened to Democrats in 2024, because Democrats had both failed to deliver anything material from 2024 in the eyes of the voters, and were running on “Weʻre going to keep not delivering for you”. This all changed in 2026; at least apparently, Democrats had learned from their lesson that they actually needed to stand for something; that they needed to put something up for their part in the transaction; and they did, and they found great success.

        Now, we see Democrats regressing. We very quickly see them going back to the leadership who represented the “Do nothing. Play dead.” caucus; the caucus that handed them resounding defeat. Doing so will effectively create headwinds for them in 2028. And nothing you personally think about how voters should vote (because voters donʻt behave like you think they should) changes that.

        2
        • You must have me confused for one of those Blue No Matter Who people. How other people vote is their business. I vote because I legitimately enjoy the act itself.

          You know, there was a time where I voted for people with rare characters in their names. People with a X or a Z, or quotations were great for me. But I have since reformed to doing 3rd party then Democrat when my brother said he favors voting Democrat.

          2
          • Well you went immediately to the virtue signalling “Vote Blue No Matter Who” dialectic. Iʻm not sure what else you expect.

            2

Sign in to comment. Sign in