Skip to content

Comment on Largest US egg producer to cull 1.8 million birds after bird flu outbreak

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • “Cull” is a strange way to say that they are going to kill a bunch of animals that are sick due to their mistreatment.

    15
    • Why? It’s what cull means. I can’t think of a better use. Killing livestock because they are ill, to prevent the disease from spreading, is the best example I can think of for the word “cull”.

      17
      • Because nobody wants to use the word “slaughter” since it has moral implications and everyone wants to eat dead animals without guilt.

        -5
        • No, words have meaning.

          Hate to be the one that breaks that to you.

          Cull is fine, your own lack of knowledge isn’t.

          5
          • It’s most notable that you made a neutral conversation into a personal attack. It was unnecessary.

            -2
            • Lacking in knowledge is not a personal attack, everyone lacks knowledge.

              Coming on to a platform and espousing such misinformation opens you up to criticism.

              Hope this helps!

              1
              Continue this thread 19 more replies
        • There are places literally called slaughterhouses. If you work or live on or around a farm you’d probably hear the word slaughter at least monthly

          -1
        • “Slaughter” means killed for meat (and/or other products).

          “Cull” means killed but not otherwise used.

          Cull is worse than slaughter because the lives are just wasted without any benefit other than hopefully containing the spread of disease. They were all going to be slaughtered in the normal case. I think that’s pretty well understood.

          -1
    • Chickens get culled by millions every month.

      1
      • Doesn’t make it right.

        7
      • They get “processed”

        “Culled” implies straight slaughter.

        1
      • Yes but normally they become food. This is waste.

        1
        • I mean technically its a waste in the most literal sense of it being disposed of without use, but its trying to contain an outbreak so it doesnt spread further. and 1.8 million chickens is hardly a lot of chickens.

          America alone consumes something around 20-30 million chickens a day.

          Theres almost 400 million egg laying chickens at any given time (not counting private backyyard chickens)

          Culling 1.8 million (0.5% of all egg layers) to contain a dangerous virus and keep it from infecting the other 99.5% of chickens is just common sense.

          0
          • I understand what you are saying and that ratio makes it seem like a smaller problem. My point is that the waste was caused by mismanagement. Chickens put into unhealthy situations created this problem.

            0
            • Its a waste, but I wouldnt be so quick to blame mismanagement. even the best of practices can still have failures, afterall.

              and bird flu hasnt just been a US issue afterall, several European nations have had to do culls as well.

              0

Sign in to comment. Sign in