Comment on Largest US egg producer to cull 1.8 million birds after bird flu outbreak
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
You’ve completely missed the rhetoric here. We are not talking about definition, we are talking about word choice. I’ll admit that I did not understand why implication and analogy were such a big part of the GRE when I took it, but now I can see why it is there.
Culling and slaughter are two different things.
You want to have a real conversation about a real issue, however you cannot even use terms correctly.
Language is important, and people like you love to espouse their hatred for unethical farming which is great but then you have no idea what you’re talking about, which is not.
lol i have two bachelors in linguistics and a masters in discourse analysis. Please don’t tell me about language.
I’ve met many people who memorize but never understand.
Adding one more.
look up prescriptivism vs descriptivism to see why you and many others here are wrong
Your assumption that people are against disgusting factory farm practices is wild.
Your absolute refusal to acknowledge that words have meaning is the single most stubborn thing I’ve ever witnessed.
Bravo you’ve convinced me once again that even college educated people can be idiots.
For the record, that was a personal attack.
What rhetoric? Culling almost 2 million chickens because it’s cheaper to do that than improve conditions so they don’t get sick in the first place is how the word is meant to be used. If you want to use the word “slaughter” because it feels more weighty that’s a you problem. Cull is literally the word that describes what they did. The only rhetoric involved is from you, somebody who thinks you should change what words you use on an emotional basis, description of reality be damned
So you did catch the rhetoric and chose to act that way because you simply disagree. Then you made it personal. It’s a good example of how the way someone treats you is more a reflection of them than of you.
Sign in to comment. Sign in