Skip to content

Comment on ‘I admire you’: Transcript of Biden’s final call with Netanyahu clashes with his memoir - exclusive

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @Nola@piefed.zip· · edited

    I love that in this little hypothetical you made up you basically managed to not just do apologetics for Biden’s genocidal culpability but drag in dual loyalty tropes about Jews too. Then blame them for everything.

    Spoiler: Abdul El Sayed just won a race on calling Israel a genocidal apartheid state and defunding them entiriely…He still won a majority of Jewish voters and only performed 1 point less than how rabid Zionist Elissa Slotkin performed in the 72 largest Jewish precincts in Michigan. If anything, Abdul El Sayed shows that had Biden/Harris run on a more economically populist, anti genocide campaign, and taken actions against Israel earlier, they would have won Michigan and there would be no Trump. And also, which seems relevent for you, Jews aren’t a monolith and they aren’t all taking marching orders from Israel.

    So sorry, your fantasy doesn’t hold up to the reality we have in front of us right now.

    Biden was a willing accomplice to genocide and no amount of mental gymnastics is removing his culpability for it.

    Maybe try developing a politics that is built around policies, morals, and outcomes, not tribal loyalties and lesser evil rationalizations. If you can’t draw a red line at genocide, you aren’t someone that can be trusted to draw a redline at anything as long as a D is by their name. And that is how you repeat the same cycle we are seeing in Gaza.

    1
    • @dou9m@lemmy.ca· · edited

      Idk if you’ve noticed but most Americans STILL didn’t give a shit about Israel’s nearly century long genocide until recently lmao. And continue to do the Israeli bot job of pretending like mentioning jews == antisemitism.

      Yap city mayor over here

      -3
      • So your new argument is that Joe Biden helped with Israel’s genocide for love of the game, not some elaborate 11D chess move about Jewish voters.

        …Ok, guess we are now in agreement.

        Enjoy the rest of your evening, friend

        2
        • Yep somewhat, although you missed the part where Biden’s love for genocide pales in comparison to Trump’s in just about every aspect, otherwise Biden would’ve been happy to bomb the fuck out of Iran when Bibi asked him multiple times.

          -3
          • @Nola@piefed.zip· · edited

            It doesn’t fucking matter

            Being a lesser genocidaire when you had the power to stop the genocide but refused is like trying to argue Pol Pot wasn’t as bad as Hitler. Or that LBJ’s crimes against humanity should be ignored cause Nixon’s were worse. Or that we shouldn’t prosecute the nazi generals that felt bad about the gas chambers, just the ones that were least remorseful.

            Sure, it is technically true, but maybe lets set our redlines at no genocide, k? And support bringing war criminals to justice instead of making it a fucking rationalization competition.

            3
            • To say Biden could’ve stopped the genocide is just factually incorrect. He could’ve only paused it, at best. Trump has both literally and metaphorically been the main person who has paved the way for this genocide the current century.

              -2
              Continue this thread 10 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in