Skip to content

Comment on Every Single Game Reviewer That Gave GTA6 a Perfect 10/10 Is Fraudulent And Corrupt

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • @KC_Royalz@lemmy.world· · edited

    I thought red dead was a 10/10. This is even better. Like I don’t get why gamers are so butthurt that rockstar gave us another GTA. I think there’s only one game ive ever shit on and that was bulletstorm.

    Whys it worth whining if you don’t like something? it’s not going to change anyone’s opinion on it. Gaming is a hobby. Let people enjoy their hobby how they like.

    Personally I think this GTA 6 is going to keep me entertained for years to come

    28
    • @sp3ctr4l@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP· · edited

      Like I don’t. Get why gamers are so butthurt that rockstar gave us another GTA.

      That isn’t the complaint.

      The complaint is that this game is being widely reviewed with perfect scores, when the game is very obviously not perfect.

      The complaint is about how game reviewing ‘standards’ work, or rather, seem to be entirely arbitrary and thus meaningless.

      If you enjoy GTA6, more power to you! Genuienly, if you love this game, and I don’t, that is a-ok, and I am happy that you enjoy this game! If this game brings you joy for a decade, then I will be glad for you that it does.

      I am not saying you are not allowed to enjoy this game.

      I am saying it does not deserve a perfect score. Many of these perfect score reviews even literally state ‘this is not a perfect game’, yet give it a perfect score… when for scoring other games, the same problems that they say GTA6 has … caused those other games to have lower scores.

      The complaint is about consistency and standards in game reviewing. It is about obvious favoritism and double standards.

      The complaint is not … that GTA 6 exists.

      1
      • If you like a game 96%, then it’s not a perfect game, but that rounds to 10/10.

        8
      • @thingsiplay@lemmy.ml· · edited

        The complaint is that this game is being widely reviewed with perfect scores, when the game is very obviously not perfect.

        That’s not how 10/10 scores work. Between a perfect score and one point less is a huge gap, so that 10/10 isn’t that extraordinary like 100% scores. A game doesn’t have to be perfect, because no game is perfect, to get a perfect score. It just means its one of the best games of its generation, compared to what games are out there and what the system can deliver. And then there is a personal opinion involved too.

        If you enjoy GTA6, more power to you! Genuienly, if you love this game, and I don’t

        Did you play the game or is your opinion baseless?

        8
      • @KC_Royalz@lemmy.world· · edited

        Reviews are opinions. Siskel and Ebert shit on a lot of great movies and loved some awful ones.

        What your asking is for the people who play the game and love it to give it a bad review and that’s not going to happen.

        I’m only about 6 hours in and when I find something I don’t like about it I’ll say so but that hasn’t happened yet but is it going to drop my rating of the game overall. Most likely not

        4
        • Ebert has gone on record saying The Core is his favorite guilty pleasure bad movie.

          And I will stand by that Stanley Tucci saying “but what if we could” is basically the entire idea behind science condensed into one sentence.

          0
    • Ah, Bulletstorm, the game most of us got to play the Gears 3 Beta a week early. I did still enjoy it, but never touched it after finishing it once.

      0
    • I think its fair to say its close to just a reskin, and that business model has had a negative impact on the gaming community.

      Its OK for anyone to like a new version of the same game, look at COD and fallout London, but just like COD its important to differentiate the dev/artist team from the board of directors.

      This game will be used to extract money from gambling addicts, and will be incredibly profitable. It probably also only released now due to the market cooling on GTA V online, and paid their devs the absolute minimum they could without bad PR.

      (also try gaten of banban if you want to shit on a game lol, but at least there we know the moneys not just going upstream)

      -1
      • Even if it’s a reskinn which it’s not just borrowing some old assets . It’s a completely new story, and exploring is most of the fun of these games

        3
        • @klankin@piefed.ca· · edited

          For sure yeah, and like COD a lot of people still like the latest releases.

          I just wanted to highlight not liking the ethics of it is a valid reason to try to spread awareness (like shadowbanning news companies for negative reviews is usually agreed to be shitty, but profitable)

          0

Sign in to comment. Sign in