Yeah…this is absolutely dystopian and a horrible precedent to set.
I really hope any judge will throw this out in a heartbeat.
There’s some serious chilling effects to this, no matter how much I’d like Brand to just STFU.
What strikes me is the duplicitous nature of these tech companies. They have been very happy to bend over backwards to accommodate Mr Orange Shittypants.
Glad I’m here and not on Reddit. No doubt their paymasters would be unhappy with me.
History shows us that when the state wishes to unjustly convict someone for political reasons there is significant collusion with the judiciary.
There are plenty of obvious well documented examples from the Troubles. More currently, the persecution of protestors that want to pressure the government to stop arming a genocide, or take serious the anthropocene extinction.
I don’t understand. He was convicted of rape. In prison, he can’t rape any girls. He has been removed from that equation entirely. Problem solved.
Why would they need to restrict his freedom of speech in addition to the other freedoms he’s lost? He wasn’t convicted of inciting terrorism or commanding armies of terrorists who follow his orders.
Generally speaking, in most countries in the world that have freedom of speech, someone else’s right to speak freely (no matter how terrible of a person) is more important than anyone elses desire to not be bothered by what they say (no matter how offensive it may be). Shy of someone inciting violence or a handful of other edge cases
The US supreme court had to deal with this exact kind of situation, and they decided that if the offended person has the ability to just turn off the speech then they have no grounds to demand someone else lose their right to speak.
Which IMO makes perfect sense. The guy is in prison. His victims dont need to watch his youtube ramblings. If theyre distressed by them then they can just stop listening to them. No one needs to stifle his right to speak. Everyone just needs to stop giving a shit and let him rot in prison
That’s not a legitimate reason. Anyone stressed out by someone else’s YouTube videos can simply refrain from watching said videos.
We can’t have a government removing people’s freedom of speech just because they think someone might get offended/upset/traumatized.
If someone’s speech is causing actual harm to someone, that’s what restraining orders are for. It should never be an automatic thing that getting convicted means you can never speak about it.
It said his wife broadcast a message from the rapist. Does that mean she read a statement by him or she brought a phone into the prison visiting room and recorded him speaking? Because of it’s the former I don’t know anything you could do about it, but if it’s the latter couldn’t the rules of the prison just say no phones allowed when visiting with this man?
I don’t see that anywhere in the article but okay.
Like I said though there’s no way to stop that. You can’t stop prisoners from being able to write letters that’s insane. You can’t stop a spouse as a prisoners from being able to make public statements, that’s also insane
This is enacted through Rule 34(3) of the Prison Rules 1999 (SI 1999/728):
“A prisoner shall not be permitted to communicate with any person outside the prison, or such person with him, except with the leave of the Secretary of State or as a privilege under rule 8.”
The operational guidance that spells out the media-specific restrictions is PSI 37/2010 – Prisoners’ Access to the Media, which prohibits prisoners from:
Making statements likely to cause unnecessary distress to victims
Making gratuitous reference to victims
Bypassing the rules by having a third party (e.g., a family member) publish their comments
Edit: added second half regarding third party bypassing.
LOLOLOLOLOL. This is what happens when you have sensible government. Try having a lunatic government like my glorious country. Tech companies bend over backwards for them.
A sensible government move is to restrict prisoners rights to advocate for their innocence?
Brand sucks shit, however this is a terrible precedent; One I would fully expect from an island that jails Palestine protestors and strips trans people of rights.
Comments
Yeah…this is absolutely dystopian and a horrible precedent to set.
I really hope any judge will throw this out in a heartbeat.
There’s some serious chilling effects to this, no matter how much I’d like Brand to just STFU.
What strikes me is the duplicitous nature of these tech companies. They have been very happy to bend over backwards to accommodate Mr Orange Shittypants.
Glad I’m here and not on Reddit. No doubt their paymasters would be unhappy with me.
Wait, are they saying that prisoners should be legally prevented from publicly claiming to be wrongly convicted?
Its already an offence for convicts to deliberately distress their victims.
Certain groups are 100% for silencing ppl and punishing resistance.
The removal of certain rights & freedoms is the point of prison.
Appeals against convictions are carried out through legal representation, not through public media.
I mean, who does he think he is ffs, Bob Marley?
History shows us that when the state wishes to unjustly convict someone for political reasons there is significant collusion with the judiciary.
There are plenty of obvious well documented examples from the Troubles. More currently, the persecution of protestors that want to pressure the government to stop arming a genocide, or take serious the anthropocene extinction.
I don’t understand. He was convicted of rape. In prison, he can’t rape any girls. He has been removed from that equation entirely. Problem solved.
Why would they need to restrict his freedom of speech in addition to the other freedoms he’s lost? He wasn’t convicted of inciting terrorism or commanding armies of terrorists who follow his orders.
Because it causes distress to his victims to continually see him calling them liars.
Generally speaking, in most countries in the world that have freedom of speech, someone else’s right to speak freely (no matter how terrible of a person) is more important than anyone elses desire to not be bothered by what they say (no matter how offensive it may be). Shy of someone inciting violence or a handful of other edge cases
The US supreme court had to deal with this exact kind of situation, and they decided that if the offended person has the ability to just turn off the speech then they have no grounds to demand someone else lose their right to speak.
Which IMO makes perfect sense. The guy is in prison. His victims dont need to watch his youtube ramblings. If theyre distressed by them then they can just stop listening to them. No one needs to stifle his right to speak. Everyone just needs to stop giving a shit and let him rot in prison
That’s not a legitimate reason. Anyone stressed out by someone else’s YouTube videos can simply refrain from watching said videos.
We can’t have a government removing people’s freedom of speech just because they think someone might get offended/upset/traumatized.
If someone’s speech is causing actual harm to someone, that’s what restraining orders are for. It should never be an automatic thing that getting convicted means you can never speak about it.
I assume you’re an American? Government do have that right in every other country on the planet.
well they are obviously in the wrong
And it causes distress to me to see him at all.
And he’s profiting off of what he did to them
YT demonetized his channel. NORTA.
It said his wife broadcast a message from the rapist. Does that mean she read a statement by him or she brought a phone into the prison visiting room and recorded him speaking? Because of it’s the former I don’t know anything you could do about it, but if it’s the latter couldn’t the rules of the prison just say no phones allowed when visiting with this man?
I don’t see that anywhere in the article but okay.
Like I said though there’s no way to stop that. You can’t stop prisoners from being able to write letters that’s insane. You can’t stop a spouse as a prisoners from being able to make public statements, that’s also insane
Wasn’t meant to be sarcastic sorry, literally just providing the info you wanted.
Edit: Really? Downvoting me for apologising? Fine, be a dick.
https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/79ed57df-0b67-4dfc-8789-a81e756a1936.png
Oh no wonder, my reader blocks photos.
Apparently in the UK it’s literally illegal and yes they literally can (and do) do all of those things.
Show me the law that says people married to prisoners aren’t allowed to speak in public.
The law is the Prison Act 1952 which gives the secretary of state powers to restrict prisoner communications. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1952/52
This is enacted through Rule 34(3) of the Prison Rules 1999 (SI 1999/728):
The operational guidance that spells out the media-specific restrictions is PSI 37/2010 – Prisoners’ Access to the Media, which prohibits prisoners from:
Making statements likely to cause unnecessary distress to victims
Making gratuitous reference to victims
Bypassing the rules by having a third party (e.g., a family member) publish their comments
Edit: added second half regarding third party bypassing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_S-qEODlbg
Incoherent religious stuff
LOLOLOLOLOL. This is what happens when you have sensible government. Try having a lunatic government like my glorious country. Tech companies bend over backwards for them.
https://www.reuters.com/world/india/india-blocks-22-youtube-news-channels-citing-national-security-2022-04-05/
https://www.thenewsminute.com/news/govt-orders-takedown-of-138-youtube-videos-83-instagram-posts-on-adani-using-court-order
A sensible government move is to restrict prisoners rights to advocate for their innocence?
Brand sucks shit, however this is a terrible precedent; One I would fully expect from an island that jails Palestine protestors and strips trans people of rights.
I don’t think the person leading with “LOLOLOLOOL” is a serious person worth engaging with myself
Sign in to comment. Sign in