Skip to content

Comment on Aptera Completes Its First Solar Electric Vehicle for Customer Delivery | Aptera Solar EVs

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Neat! The concept is fatally flawed from inception, but this is still very neat to see!

    2
    • Optimized aerodynamics and independence from energy infrastructure are flaws only to someone who sells energy. 😆

      19
    • What’s wrong with the concept? Seems like a nice vehicle if you don’t have access to an outlet much of the time and don’t want to deal with charging stations outside roadtrips. Seems quite reasonable for a commuter car in a multi-vehicle family.

      13
      • The flaw is the amount of energy collection from the solar panels on a car sized object will always be significantly lower than the energy needed for street legal weight making it a novelty. It can’t really scale up to a useful vehicle that primarily relies on solar panels.

        This would also be true if the solar panels were 100% efficient, which makes it a flawed design.

        5
        • the energy needed for street legal weight

          What is this?

          3
          • @snooggums@piefed.world· · edited

            I’m referring to the existence of things like signals, airbags, and other safety features ends up being required weight to be street legal. Not a set ‘street legal’ weight, just weight required to meet legal requirements.

            On an ultralight vehicle that could take up a significant proportion of the weight.

            0
            • Does weight really matter that much at speed? At least for biking, I got the impression that it was aerodynamics that dominate resistance after like 20mph. Weight should mostly just affect acceleration speeds, not energy (although if you end up going slower on average you’d have less air drag, so more weight I guess could incidentally save you energy in some cases?)

              1
              Continue this thread 2 more replies
          • Smells like a load of bullshit.

            -2
        • Definitely read about it before you come to an opinion on it.

          -1
          • I did…

            I also understand the basics of solar power and how much energy it takes to move objects.

            -1
            • Gotcha, so you know that the primary mode of charging is the NACS port under the license plate cover, and the solar is supplemental to add to driving range, around 40 miles per day in optimal conditions?

              0
      • They did a charging study by a third party…in southern CA near the Mexico border, at noon, on summer solstice.

        No, you will not charge your car for free.

        3
        • Of course its not free; you need panels to do it.

          Seems like reasonable test conditions to me given where I live. Even if it only got like 4miles/day in range instead of 40+ in the third party study, that would still cover my typical commute.

          0
      • @dan1101@lemmy.world· · edited

        The range, performance, and/or charging time will be very bad. There is no way to get enough solar onto a car to charge that car in a reasonable amount of time. I’m talking days, probably more.

        2

Sign in to comment. Sign in