77
Are there any games where near-dead enemies do less damage?
One thing that strikes me in games is I can fight tough enemies until they are almost dead but they still fight and deal damage exactly the same as they did at 100% health. Ok that makes some sense with guns, although their accuracy should go down. But it doesn’t make sense for physical attacks.
Does anyone know of any games that reduce physical damage dealt based on health? And more importantly, does it work and is it fun?
Comments
Bit different, but: check out the old PlayStation game ‘Bushido Blade’: it’s a ‘realistic’ samurai game where one slash with a weapon can kill. It has both a one-on-one fighting mode, and a beat-em-up adventure mode.
I’ve also heard of and seen more-modern sword fighting games with the same approach, but don’t remember the titles.
Vanquish has several enemies like that. You can hit them in the legs/arms/guns to progressively cripple them, reducing their HP and making them easier to kill.
I really loved that game, had a unique feeling to it.
Dark Souls 3
The Pontiff Beasts get a damage debuff if you manage to get them down to like a tiny sliver of hp but don’t kill them. They also will cower in fear for a moment and limp pathetically until you finish them off.
The latter is also a staple in the whole Dark Souls series. There is the Red Tear Stone Ring that increases your damage at low health, and the Blue Tear Stone Ring that raises your defense at low health.
Tunic also takes that mechanic from DS and uses it nicely with a ring and some other items to make you into a devestating glass cannon that can one shot almost anything at the cost of only having 1 hit yourself.
To a higher extreme, Dwarf Fortress has so many ways of being hurt that also make you weaker. Losing limbs, having your fat and skin melt off, being weakened by poisons or gasses, etc.
In Kingdom Come: Deliverance (1 and 2) being injured limits your stamina which prevents you from attacking as many times in a row. This applies to both the player and to enemies. These games also only have a limited healing system, only restoring health over time and not being able to use healing items in active combat, which makes it more important to plan ahead and be prepared. I think this works well as making a mistake punishes you by making it easy to get overwhelmed, even once you get to a higher level and have good gear. It also rewards slower play as putting an arrow or three into a group of enemies before they get to you gives you a huge advantage, especially if you are outnumbered.
I mean in many they do more as they lose health. All the same are you fine with the player character having the same mechanic?
In Dark Souls, the Boss Sif (a giant dog with a sword) will start limping and attack less often when he’s near death. This isn’t to make the fight more realistic, but is a mechanic to make the player sad.
And to twist the knife even further, if you do the DLC (which takes place in the past and has you save her life at one point) before fighting Sif, she’ll recognize you and whine and howl mournfully before (regretfully) grabbing her sword to fight you.
(The context behind the fight is that she’s protecting her master Artorias’ grave a la Hachiko, but you need an item that was buried with him to save the world from falling into Darkness.)
I don’t play such difficult games anymore but if I did and got to this, it’d be game over. Especially if I’d done the DLC first.
You’re not wrong about Sif, but there’s actually a lot of Soulsborne enemies that do more damage, get extra attacks, etc, when their health is low. Mostly bosses…
The Banner Saga is a turn based game that has an interesting take on this. You can attack both armor and HP, and armor acts to reduce HP damage. So you want to wear armor down, then take out a big chunk of HP when they’re exposed.
On top of that, health dictates damage, so you sort of have to decide how many turns of taking full damage you can risk stripping their armor before you go for HP damage.
I quite liked the game, and the story was really good too, though I haven’t tried the sequel yet.
Pac Man
First thing that came to mind is Swat 4 (because I’ve been playing it recently).
If you get shot in the leg, you walk slower. If you get shot in the arm, your aim is less accurate.
The “bad guys” are the same. You shoot them in the leg, they will be slow or fall over, shoot them in the arm they drop their gun.
I don’t know if that’s quite what you had in mind, as it doesn’t have big boss fights where the boss gets weaker the more you shoot it, but it’s what came to mind.
fallout 4 has certain enemies become practically useless if they take enough limb damage. feral ghouls could lose both arms and be inneffective at dealing any significant damage, or lose their legs and very slowly crawl around. gotta watch out for assaultrons though, even when they are crawling on the ground they can still get you good, but they are pretty much sitting ducks
But each individual part is again like OP describes: doesn’t matter if a part is at 100 or 1 %, it only changes at 0 to nonfunctional. (At least in New Vegas and Fallout 3 it was like that, never played 4)
New vegas and 3 are also like that.
dart gun vs deathclaw and deathclaw isnt winning 🤣
It might not be the kind of game you’re looking for, but in Civ 6 units attack less effectively when they’re damaged.
Even as far back as Civ 2 units fought at reduced strength if they were tired (had less than one movement point).
I played a LOT of Civ 2 through 5 but I’m not sure I ever realized that.
Age of Wonders does something similar. Units you buy are often entire squads. As health decreases, members die, reducing damage. It can give a mechanical difference between a single-creature unit and a squad with similar base stats since the single unit doesn’t weaken.
A lot of strategy games similarly clump units to reduce controlled elements. The real-time ones such as Total War and Dawn of War seem to track the squad members health individually though. Heroes of Might and Magic, a turn-based game, does a weird hybrid where it calls them out as individual units but it treats them as a large health pool and kills them percentile-wise.
In all of these examples, the creatures aren’t weakening, the group is weakening as sub-units die.
In Kenshi there isn’t really a normal health bar, you have a bunch of limb health bars and those going down has different effects. So you could fight a really strong enemy and if you’re able to take off an arm or cripple it or something, they’ll be significantly weaker
+1 for Kenshi. That’s a game that’ll grab you by the balls and not let go for a good hundred hours or so. Or you might just bounce off hard.
Also if you have a multi attack mod on, mad cat lon can dismember several members of your team at once!
Pretty much any Fallout from 3 on
Kenshi
The Flood in the first Halo trilogy’s arms can be shot off so they can’t really deal damage; at least in the first two games.
The Surge games have directional/limb targeting, so you could theoretically take off limbs before you kill them.
Works really well in Wargroove.
I play a lot of XCOM (I still haven’t beaten the original Long War 😅) and I always enable the ‘Red Fog’ option (units perform worse while injured).
It’s brutal but that’s what makes it fun
Is that also active for the enemy troops?
Doesn’t Red Dead Redemption 2 let you cripple people by shooting them in the leg?
Probably not what you had in mind, but destruction derby, since that’s just part of the formula. BeamNG especially perfects this sort of beat-up, limping car struggling to survive experience.
Wreckfest and old games Big Red Racing and 1NSANE did a good job of that too IIRC.
You can even make damage affect your car in Forza Horizon. I tried it, but that game is more fun just tearing down the roads without worrying about damage.
Only cases where the strength goes justifiably down I can remember are Final Fantasy VII (OG), Naruto Storm 4, and Evening Starter.
About FFVII...
The “final” fight is a scripted fight against an 1 HP Sephiroth, I’d imagine Sephiroth being as weak on this last fight for maybe being the remnants of his consciousness given form after the fight where he dies.
About Storm 4...
Same with the manga and anime, after the villain defeated, Naruto and Sasuke still have some unresolved disputes, and keep fighting until way past they can use any powers, the final stretch being a sloppy brawl where both of them can barely move anymore.
About Evening Starter...
First, don’t look it up, at least publicly. It’s a horror and eroge game.
Second, the final fight is also scripted, like with FFVII, though in it both the protagonist and the villain barely alive after surviving a falling building. The villain too weak to be able to properly shoot at the protagonist, and the protagonist with several bones broken and having to slowly drag her hand that still somewhat works throughout the turns to a loaded gun she keeps with her.
And considering how the game’s lore is rather fucked up, pun not intended, it’s very hard to know what’s going to happen.
In all cases, I think it works pretty well.
However, for a more open battle, only case I can remember, but barely fitting, is…
a boss from Persona 5.
Shido’s Shadow iirc is one of the bosses with the most health in the game, and with the most unique stages since iirc Persona 3’s original final boss. However, he barely fits because in the stage he gets “weaker”, the final stage, he’s about as strong as the previous stage, but his animation loop showing him getting so exhausted he can barely keep his arms in a lifted stance, implying his doing an effort to keep up while being at his limit.
In a lore perspective, it also works well imo, though not actually fitting a weakened enemy into gameplay.
Oh, right, there’s another one if I remember it right…
A boss from the OG DMC.
It’s been way too long since I finished that game, but iirc, after Dante defeats Mundus in Hell, he escapes back to the cursed castle, but is followed by Mundus that dragged himself all the way.
While in the fight in Hell Mundus was at his full strength, making the battle somewhat of a puzzle, in his second and final encounter with Dante, he’s weakened enough that the fight becomes rather straight forward, no puzzles, just punch the boss until his life is at 0.
First one that comes to mind is that monsters in Monster Hunter games get tired and eventually start limping. But that’s more about showing the damage and fatigue in games that used to not have health bars for fights that could take half an hour.
There is more to it than just showing damage and fatigue. The moves they perform also change. I recall fighting a Lagombi and as the fight progressed more of his moves were full-body, until he was near death and he was too tired to swipe at me and instead just tried body slams… unable to stand back up when he missed.
This is somewhat inaccurate.
Monsters who are low on health tend to enrage more frequently, making them deal more damage and be more aggessive. My general understanding of the game might be skewed toward G/Master rank, but my gauge for when a monster is near death is when it starts enraging almost constantly.
The mechanic you are citing is a thing, but it isnt strictly related to health. There is basically a stamina or energy system which causes them to go on a form of cooldown, the polar opposite of enraging. This state is completely negated if they enrage and they cannot enter this state while enraged.
I would believe there is a relationship with this mechanic to health, as it feels as if when enemies that dont enrage very easily at low health seem to enter this state more easily, but it could also be an esoteric system where they can only regain partially while they are engaged in a fight. Monster Hunter has long been opaque about such things, and you would need to seek this info out to even know it exists.
There is also a mechanic with blunt weapons (and special cases like Punishing Draw skill. Generally anything that can apply KO to the head) that can either force this state similarly to applying status, i believe, referred to as Fatigue, though it may vary by game and in some cases deal damage to their stamina.
I mostly played older games, and at least in those, most monsters start limping when they’ve received a bit more damage than needed to capture them. There are some that rage a lot and basically don’t have time for limping around, and some that have their own special behavior instead like playing dead. But as a general rule I’d beat up the monster until it starts limping out of the zone and then try to capture it. So there it’s definitely health based.
Punishing Draw is called Punish Draw before World so we’re probably thinking of fundamentally different gameplay. Exhausting monster stamina is a thing in either though as far as I know. The mechanic I remember is building up exhaust status (not just through skills, any blunt attacks do), and once a threshold is hit the monster flinches and loses a bunch of stamina. When it’s out of stamina it becomes slower and many start to look for food to recover stamina. So that kind of also fits the original question if we consider damaging stamina to be similar to damaging health. Although they can recover stamina much more easily than health, by eating or going into rage.
I should have mentioned the whole thing with cutting off parts too since some monsters do lose attacks when you cut off specific parts. And they don’t recover those at all. Like tail slams go away when the tail is gone and some others. But they never took that very far IMHO, can’t cut off the legs for example.
It’s partially that and partially the limb break system. Every subpart of a monster has its own health bar (there are modded overlays to show these), and when you deplete it that part will “break” with various effects such as limping, losing moves, or dropping extra monster parts. Or pissing the monster off, because Capcom are sadistic that way.
The weird thing is that limbs quickly recover and you can break them multiple times. I think it gets easier each time they break so it’s still worth focusing on a single spot, but you can’t permanently cripple most targets outside of maybe cutting off a tail.
Kingdom Death is a ridiculous board game where the monster’s health is represented by a deck of cards that determine its moveset. When you inflict an injury on a monster, you remove a card from its deck until it has none left, so the more injured it is, the less moves it has available to it
Players in Frosthaven kind of work similarly too. As you get hurt you can burn a card to heal.
In Helldivers 2 many enimies can have limbs shot off which reduces the damage they can do as a whole, sometimes eliminating damage completely if they don’t have a basic melee attack. Not quite the same as low health since the locations have their own hit points, but it is reduced damage output because they took damage.
There are other games where damaging locations reduces damage from that location, but I can’t think of their names off the top of my head.
In the Zero Dawn games the robots usually loose attacks as you strip their weapons off. There are also attacks you can do that degrade their armour.
I suppose that the reason they don’t implement this is because it’s more fun for the player to have a crescendo, with the heat gradually ramping up and the difficulty curve increasing as the battle protracts, as opposed to having a difficulty barrier upfront and then the fight becoming gradually easier. It’s got nothing to with realism and more with the way we consume media and expect a certain kind of narrative tension.
Monster Hunter is often like this, but they will still get bursts of energy
My first thought oddly enough was Overgrowth. It’s been a while since playing, so I can’t say if the damage was just cosmetic or limiting in any way. Could a hurt rabbit holding their bloodied arm still use a two handed weapon? I think so.
The issue is, if they get affected, so should you, right? But is that fun being on that decline? I’m pretty sure lots of games have that for the player, with stamina and vision and such, and if done wrong it becomes frustrating being on that curve, unable to get back up (without a magic health, and suddenly you’re okay lol). Then again, that dopamine rush when you’re beaten down and do a hail mary and it works…
Overgrowth is a great example, which reminds me after watching it for years I never played it.
It takes a bit to get used to the controls, but once you do, it’s fun. The ending was… not a let down, it just seems the story ran out and they couldn’t figure out what to do, so they went quick and dark. The arena though, I came up with some wild things when I was playing it. And the editor, so much potential, but it never caught on at the level of Doom wads and the like.
The dev team ran low on money, found an infinite money glitch, and then weren’t super focused on or pressured to complete Overgrowth.
For those who don’t know, they made Humble Bundle.
That doesn’t help the distraction, but they put together HB early into the alpha for Overgrowth. I don’t know what the real (lack of) motivation was, I just followed the blogs back then.
Sign in to comment. Sign in