Vague questions like “do you support discrimination” are useless, as no one wants to consider themselves a bigot. Many of these people will happily tell you, “no, I don’t want trans people to be oppressed, but I’m still uncomfortable with trans women in women’s restrooms” and other such crap.
Jim Crow was built citing the comfort and safety of white women.
The real tests of an ally are the hard questions.
Do you support trans people using the bathrooms that match their gender?
Do you support housing trans prisoners with their gender?
Do you view it as child abuse for a parent to deny trans healthcare to their trans kids?
If you answer “no” to any of these, at best your are a performative “ally” who only vaguely supports trans people for woke street cred. If you answer no to any of them, you fundamentally do not respect trans lives and identities. If you’re not willing to respect the gender of a serial killer, you don’t really support trans identities. You don’t really believe “trans women are women” if you want even the most fucked up criminal that happens to be a trans woman housed with men. You believe that trans people who behave should have their genders respected out of courtesy, but you don’t really believe that trans women are women. We don’t throw cis female serial killers into jail cells with men. We don’t even throw the rare chronic cis lesbian rapist in cells with men. But even most “allies” reveal their true colors when they eagerly support denying the gender of trans people that have done something wrong. By doing so, they tell every trans person they know, “do something I don’t like, and your gender is no longer valid.”
And if you don’t support trans kids getting HRT for vague bullshit concerns about people making a mistake, you fundamentally believe the life of every cis person is worth the lives of thirty trans people.
Then what the hell does that have to do with trans people? It’s not our job to tear down society’s gender roles. If you want to push for gender neutral toilets, go for it. Yet people never actually push for that, they just bring up the idea to dismiss the needs of trans people.
Let’s say you believe taxation is unjust. Suppose someone proposes a law where only non-whites pay taxes, and you support it. In that situation I will call you a racist. It doesn’t matter that you believe tax is generally unjust. Supporting the whites-only tax relief is an act of racism.
Analogously, if you believe trans people should be forced to go the toilet of the wrong gender, you are a transphobe. It doesn’t matter if you believe gendered toilets are dumb or whatever. The act of forcing trans people to use the wrong toilet is transphobic.
In “Rising out of hatred,” Eli Saslow describes himself, and the whole white supremacy movement, as avoiding to say “We hate [group]” in favor of things like “We love our [minority] fam, but we all thrive best in our own community.” Essentially, they’re trading ‘kill all the [minorities]’ for ‘go be a [minority] somewhere I don’t have to see it.’ The mainstream can be more comfortable with it.
Even Abraham Lincoln started with that as the solution to slavery. He was able to learn that such isolation is hateful, oppressive, and not good for the long term, but I think it’s a hard lesson to communicate. Most of us gravitate to similar-minded, similar-culture people, and welcoming people with different social patterns or expectations can be uncomfortable.
We gotta do it, though: it’s the very definition of pluralism.
Mate, we’re in a liberal country (as in Montesquieu’s liberalism). Personal freedoms trone over anything here because it’s what liberalism literally is as a doctrine. Trans people have the final say, no matter the general opinions in this discourse.
Also do not use adverbs such as “fundamentally”, they work against clarity since it’s what they’re for.
Comments
Vague questions like “do you support discrimination” are useless, as no one wants to consider themselves a bigot. Many of these people will happily tell you, “no, I don’t want trans people to be oppressed, but I’m still uncomfortable with trans women in women’s restrooms” and other such crap.
Jim Crow was built citing the comfort and safety of white women.
The real tests of an ally are the hard questions.
Do you support trans people using the bathrooms that match their gender?
Do you support housing trans prisoners with their gender?
Do you view it as child abuse for a parent to deny trans healthcare to their trans kids?
If you answer “no” to any of these, at best your are a performative “ally” who only vaguely supports trans people for woke street cred. If you answer no to any of them, you fundamentally do not respect trans lives and identities. If you’re not willing to respect the gender of a serial killer, you don’t really support trans identities. You don’t really believe “trans women are women” if you want even the most fucked up criminal that happens to be a trans woman housed with men. You believe that trans people who behave should have their genders respected out of courtesy, but you don’t really believe that trans women are women. We don’t throw cis female serial killers into jail cells with men. We don’t even throw the rare chronic cis lesbian rapist in cells with men. But even most “allies” reveal their true colors when they eagerly support denying the gender of trans people that have done something wrong. By doing so, they tell every trans person they know, “do something I don’t like, and your gender is no longer valid.”
And if you don’t support trans kids getting HRT for vague bullshit concerns about people making a mistake, you fundamentally believe the life of every cis person is worth the lives of thirty trans people.
What if I say no because I think gendered toilets are a stupid concept?
Then what the hell does that have to do with trans people? It’s not our job to tear down society’s gender roles. If you want to push for gender neutral toilets, go for it. Yet people never actually push for that, they just bring up the idea to dismiss the needs of trans people.
Let’s say you believe taxation is unjust. Suppose someone proposes a law where only non-whites pay taxes, and you support it. In that situation I will call you a racist. It doesn’t matter that you believe tax is generally unjust. Supporting the whites-only tax relief is an act of racism.
Analogously, if you believe trans people should be forced to go the toilet of the wrong gender, you are a transphobe. It doesn’t matter if you believe gendered toilets are dumb or whatever. The act of forcing trans people to use the wrong toilet is transphobic.
You’re missing their implied point.
They don’t think any person should be forced to go to the toilet of any gender.
But I wouldn’t support any restrictions on where anyone can take a shit.
In “Rising out of hatred,” Eli Saslow describes himself, and the whole white supremacy movement, as avoiding to say “We hate [group]” in favor of things like “We love our [minority] fam, but we all thrive best in our own community.” Essentially, they’re trading ‘kill all the [minorities]’ for ‘go be a [minority] somewhere I don’t have to see it.’ The mainstream can be more comfortable with it.
Even Abraham Lincoln started with that as the solution to slavery. He was able to learn that such isolation is hateful, oppressive, and not good for the long term, but I think it’s a hard lesson to communicate. Most of us gravitate to similar-minded, similar-culture people, and welcoming people with different social patterns or expectations can be uncomfortable.
We gotta do it, though: it’s the very definition of pluralism.
Mate, we’re in a liberal country (as in Montesquieu’s liberalism). Personal freedoms trone over anything here because it’s what liberalism literally is as a doctrine. Trans people have the final say, no matter the general opinions in this discourse.
Also do not use adverbs such as “fundamentally”, they work against clarity since it’s what they’re for.
Sign in to comment. Sign in