Skip to content

Comment on 76% of Canadians believe transgender people should be able to live without fear of harassment

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @MBM@lemmy.world· · edited

    Sports organisations have been handling it pretty well before it became a political talking point. Just leave it to the experts (and research shows that, if anything, trans women have a disadvantage (edit: after hormones)).

    2
    • That research is by no means settled. There is also research saying the opposite, as recently as this year. Which, respectfully, is part of the problem.

      0
      • If you’re only going after my afterthought I don’t see a point in having this conversation. Also, why are insisting on AGAB terminology here, I don’t see how someone’s birth certificate is more relevant than e.g. which puberty they (first) went through (if we’re talking trans people, those are meaningful distinctions)

        1
        • Because their AGAB is usually established by their biology at birth, and arguing with biology is a losing fight most of the time. But, you’re right in that their birth certificate has no relevance, which is why I transitioned to referring to them as XX and XY instead.

          But to your further point, it’s been solved in recreational sports since before we as a society were ready to admit trans people existed. Coed rec sports leagues have existed for 30 years. One of the ways in which they solve that is going completely non-contact. If the league folks are wanting to join isn’t non-contact, though, there will, on average, be a disadvantage. And the only way you’re going to establish there absolutely isn’t a disadvantage is by violating their medical privacy.

          1

Sign in to comment. Sign in