Skip to content

Comment on Sorry, Humble. You lived long enough to see yourself become the villain.

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Why? The registration form has to tell you this anyway, right? That’s not avoidable. So no big deal if the login page does too.

    0
    • It makes it super easy for attackers to know if an email address has an account. Say your email is in a data breach, they’ll just go to services like this to see if you have an account, so they know if it’s even worth bruteforcing.

      All you have to do is ask for username/email and password at once, and only say “these credentials are incorrect” when the email is incorrect, and when a user requests a password reset link, you just say “an email has been sent if this address is known to us” or something. You don’t give away information about the existence of user accounts.

      @hereiam@lemmy.world already explained why the registration form shouldn’t tell you this either. If it does, it’s exactly the same issue as this.

      8
    • For the regristation form you just say “thanks for signing up, we sent you a link to the provided email”. And for the login screen you just say “email or password was wrong” to avoid email harvesting.

      5

Sign in to comment. Sign in