Anthropic Researcher Says Pretty Much All Humans Will Become “Permanently Unemployable” After Its IPO: "It will be able to defeat you, personally, very soon."
If it works, it’s literally the start of a moneyless utopia, because working will lose all meaning, in all jobs. People won’t be able to earn money and that’s the end of the loop.
If it doesn’t work, they’re trying to scam people.
No problem. If the society keeps up. If not, I wonder who will be able to buy anything which means the monetary value of AI goes to zero. Even most companies who could replace workers with AI only exist because they offer services that an AI can fully do (in that fictional scenario). So less companies, less money circulating, etc. What could go wrong.
The solution is not to play their game. They want their models to be as ubiquitous as the internet. As long as we keep up the pressure that it’s unwanted, the inevitable price hikes and demand for up-front payment by hardware suppliers will take care of the rest.
Let me guess, you have shares/bonds whatever in the company because you are an employee. And if there is enough hype generated before Anthropic goes public, value of your shares will increase substantially. But I am sure this is not at all related to your statement.
“pretty much all humans will become permanently unemployable” in a span of mere months.
They’ve been saying that for a year now. They being the mindless/fanatic believers in AI, that completely lack critical sense.
The truth is that AI adoption rate is declining fast.
I find it very strange that you appear interested enough to ask for source yet you haven’t heard of this??
There has been several news items about declining adoption rate several months now. But OK here you go 1 source all the way back from February!
What always gets me is that, like, even if these machines were exactly as intelligent as advertised, most jobs require some degree of physical action unrelated to interacting with a computer. Even an infinitely intelligent computer can’t so much as lift a box off the floor unless it is given some sort of robot or similar device to control. A fleet of robots tooled to do every job humans do in sufficient numbers to replace them if only the software was up to controlling them, does not currently exist. Building them all would take significant time, and likely would require increasing the supply of certain components given the robotics industry isn’t alreadly manufacturing them at the needed scale, and all those new factories and resource extraction take time to set up too. Therefore, there are blatantly obvious bottlenecks to humans all having their jobs automated within just a few months, which have nothing to do with the present state of AI and therefore aren’t changed by an improvement in that state.
Even an infinitely intelligent computer can’t so much as lift a box off the floor unless it is given some sort of robot or similar device to control.
This is true, neither Clause or ChatGPT or any other of the AI services they claim will disrupt everything can do anything practical.
But of course work is being done in that area too, so they can (sort of), the most famous being Boston Dynamics, but other companies are working on it too.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRwyIiLWT8Q&t=21s
But those are not really threatening any real jobs, at least not yet.
never mind the fact that building a robot that can do everything a human body can do is a stupid waste of time and effort, and currently impossible besides.
Have you seen Boston Dynamics robot dogs? You think an LLM couldn’t be thrown in one and it just makes decisions on its own? Might not be exactly human but could be close enough to accomplish many tasks poorly for a while until one day it does them well and then we’ll really be living in a different world.
What exactly makes you say, LLMs are taking decisions? From what I understand it plays a probability game of predicting next set of words.
From those words chosen there is ReAct(Reason and Act) framework which selects the best possible next executable task from the choices provided to it.
For all I know, decisions are thought out actions using a logical flow and not predicting the next best token based on the previous token. And for every decision we are held accountable brute forcing our way to make decision is not viable IMO. Would like to hear other perspectives or would like to know if I missed something.
This makes me wonder, and I want to see a story of how a more grounded less fantastical AI and robotic uprising story would be like. Like the only impossible science fiction is the omniscient and omnipotent AI that’s trapped in servers or supercomputers, and somehow wants to destroy or enslave humans for whatever reason. Everything else such as the day to day life technology and warfare should be somewhat 5 - 10 years in the future of our current time.
No terminators, no nanobot grey goo situation or anything like that.
Maybe I should try to write this. It’s been 23 years since I last wrote a fictional essay, back in highschool lol. I’m already having some ideas; I should write it down for fun. In a physical notebook, just in case lol
i don’t like this sentiment, because you made it sound like we could just sit and do nothing, and ai will go away by itself. but we need to fight to make sure ai companies are held to account for what they did.
Ai will not go away by itself but it will follow the path of blockchain, which at the beginning was sold as THE solution for every possible problem (much like Ai) and then quitely drop off the radar to be still used only where it make sense to use it.
AI will be part of business just like computers did, there is no way around that.
Also you can’t really fight if a company wants to implement AI, it is not the decision of workers. It can only be fought politically.
So be careful what you vote for.
A lot of houses are owned by people who might no longer be employable (in that pictured scenario). Which then means they can’t afford to have their house fixed. Which in turn means those who live off of fixing houses get less contracts or have to massively reduce prices (and therefore dock their own income). So the potential changes are still a big issue, even if robotics aren’t as far yet.
Obviously, this nonsense is meant to try to prop up their stock price until they have an opportunity to cash out.
However, even if it was true it would mean their company is over valued.
They don’t have any sort of “moat”, so if AI models were truly that good then we could use them to replace Anthropic and render their entire company worthless.
That’s why they want to get local / open source models banned. Because they keep getting better and better and they don’t really have a moat. Gimmie all your RAM Altman kinda shit.
Edit: The only real moat is going to be when one of them solves actual real AI (unlikely any time soon or ever with LLMs) or some dramatic reduction in cost to run them that others can’t replicate.
Funny how the people building AI keep warning that it will make humanity unemployable, then immediately explain why investors should value their company at astronomical levels. Apparently the apocalypse has a cap table, and the people selling tickets insist it’s inevitable.
We still don’t have fully autonomous sela driving cars. That is a much smaller and more manageable problem space than every job that every human on earth can do.
Yet, even within that difficult but constrained problem space, over a decade of effort by multiple companies and hundreds of billions of dollars, we’ve landed on a bunch of disbanded programs and shuttered companies, a few players that can run cars in a handful of specific areas in specific cities that are constantly and carefully mapped with a ton of human management of map data, cities where there is little rain (or where they shut down during heavy rain) and no snow, and where there needs to be 24-7 live human support in case the cars get stuck or confused. And even still there are incidents requiring pulling cars from the roads or pulling operating licenses from companies.
Don’t get me wrong, what they have managed to accomplish is amazing. The 1st time you ride in a Waymo it feels like the sci-fi future we were promised. But it’s far from perfect and there are quite a lot of smoke and mirrors.
How are the robots gonna take over the world next quarter if they can’t even drive past the city limits?
Apparently replacing every human job is easier than teaching a car what to do when a traffic cone falls over. The AI industry has mastered one genuinely autonomous task, though: moving the goalposts whenever reality misses the quarterly earnings call.
There were 3 recent Waymo things: 1) the record rainfall, which yeah, it’s a lot, but people could still drive 2) The day before they had their license to drive on the highway pulled because of some incidents and then 3) this week they blocked a street car for hours (this is from memory so forgive me if I’m off slightly here)
Anthropic loves this doomsday narrative so much. They’ve run the concept through their LLM over and over and it hits big with predicting investments. Who wouldn’t want to invest in the beast that takes over the world. Yeah it sounds bad on the surface, but when it comes to investments don’t you want to be winning? Don’t you want to at least be rich when the doomsday machine you supported takes you down? They aren’t trying to warn you, they’re trying to get you excited.
Comments
Remember when that CEO got shot and all those little Pissbabies shivered in their britches? Good times.
If it works, it’s literally the start of a moneyless utopia, because working will lose all meaning, in all jobs. People won’t be able to earn money and that’s the end of the loop.
If it doesn’t work, they’re trying to scam people.
I wonder which it is.
laughs stone masonly
“This thing will be make unlimited amounts of money, I promise. If you have money, I would like to trade my ownership in it for your money.”
Absolute pisstake from that guy
No problem. If the society keeps up. If not, I wonder who will be able to buy anything which means the monetary value of AI goes to zero. Even most companies who could replace workers with AI only exist because they offer services that an AI can fully do (in that fictional scenario). So less companies, less money circulating, etc. What could go wrong.
I’m already unemployable. 🤷🏻♂️
Former employee, some researcher, study finds… Fear implemented, what’s the solution?
Pay for ai, get your own agent to work for you before it’s too late?
The solution is not to play their game. They want their models to be as ubiquitous as the internet. As long as we keep up the pressure that it’s unwanted, the inevitable price hikes and demand for up-front payment by hardware suppliers will take care of the rest.
I hate their ultra aggressive marketing blah.
All humans.
Including CEOs, board members, and other parasites.
Especially those.
“AI research says…” has become the new Trump says…
Every word out of their mouths is a lie designed to make them more money. We’d done well to ignore them.
cult vibes.
if you read tec forums, they are full of beliebers that arn’t going to make bank…
when the free money runs out, these are the guys (and it is 99.9% guys) that are expected to fill the multi-trillion dollar hole.
Yeah bitch show me how you fix an complicated espresso machine. Please buy another one
“AI” propaganda. Homie gets paid in stock
soon to be worthless
All I hear is "Tax AI businesses at 99.99% of revenue to pay for society or make it illegal
AI can’t vote, we still have options.
Nationalize it if it can’t be profitable
AI can’t vote yet.
Edit: or Ai might already change the votes. As long as the voting system is connected to the internet.
https://statecourtreport.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/delaware-considers-if-corporations-should-be-allowed-vote
Just have the AI run inside one.
Obvious lies as to capability. Absolute true statement of intent and purpose.
Let me guess, you have shares/bonds whatever in the company because you are an employee. And if there is enough hype generated before Anthropic goes public, value of your shares will increase substantially. But I am sure this is not at all related to your statement.
https://feddit.org/pictrs/image/70928803-2b62-47a1-83ad-3a98793bacd4.gif
They’ve been saying that for a year now. They being the mindless/fanatic believers in AI, that completely lack critical sense.
The truth is that AI adoption rate is declining fast.
Source?
I find it very strange that you appear interested enough to ask for source yet you haven’t heard of this??
There has been several news items about declining adoption rate several months now. But OK here you go 1 source all the way back from February!
https://hbr.org/2026/02/why-ai-adoption-stalls-according-to-industry-data
This one is from a year ago:
https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1nebta7/ai_use_at_large_companies_is_in_decline_census/
This one is from only a month ago:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8YsC8oVpek
I think the only area where it may still be pretty strong is programming. Everything else it is either plateauing or declining.
That’s probably where my doubt comes from. I’m a programmer so it seems like AI hype and adoption are still very alive.
What always gets me is that, like, even if these machines were exactly as intelligent as advertised, most jobs require some degree of physical action unrelated to interacting with a computer. Even an infinitely intelligent computer can’t so much as lift a box off the floor unless it is given some sort of robot or similar device to control. A fleet of robots tooled to do every job humans do in sufficient numbers to replace them if only the software was up to controlling them, does not currently exist. Building them all would take significant time, and likely would require increasing the supply of certain components given the robotics industry isn’t alreadly manufacturing them at the needed scale, and all those new factories and resource extraction take time to set up too. Therefore, there are blatantly obvious bottlenecks to humans all having their jobs automated within just a few months, which have nothing to do with the present state of AI and therefore aren’t changed by an improvement in that state.
This is true, neither Clause or ChatGPT or any other of the AI services they claim will disrupt everything can do anything practical.
But of course work is being done in that area too, so they can (sort of), the most famous being Boston Dynamics, but other companies are working on it too. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRwyIiLWT8Q&t=21s
But those are not really threatening any real jobs, at least not yet.
never mind the fact that building a robot that can do everything a human body can do is a stupid waste of time and effort, and currently impossible besides.
Have you seen Boston Dynamics robot dogs? You think an LLM couldn’t be thrown in one and it just makes decisions on its own? Might not be exactly human but could be close enough to accomplish many tasks poorly for a while until one day it does them well and then we’ll really be living in a different world.
What exactly makes you say, LLMs are taking decisions? From what I understand it plays a probability game of predicting next set of words.
From those words chosen there is ReAct(Reason and Act) framework which selects the best possible next executable task from the choices provided to it.
For all I know, decisions are thought out actions using a logical flow and not predicting the next best token based on the previous token. And for every decision we are held accountable brute forcing our way to make decision is not viable IMO. Would like to hear other perspectives or would like to know if I missed something.
https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/react-agent
This makes me wonder, and I want to see a story of how a more grounded less fantastical AI and robotic uprising story would be like. Like the only impossible science fiction is the omniscient and omnipotent AI that’s trapped in servers or supercomputers, and somehow wants to destroy or enslave humans for whatever reason. Everything else such as the day to day life technology and warfare should be somewhat 5 - 10 years in the future of our current time.
No terminators, no nanobot grey goo situation or anything like that.
Maybe I should try to write this. It’s been 23 years since I last wrote a fictional essay, back in highschool lol. I’m already having some ideas; I should write it down for fun. In a physical notebook, just in case lol
Relevant almost-xkcd
https://what-if.xkcd.com/imgs/a/5/robot_apocalypse_comparison.png
i don’t like this sentiment, because you made it sound like we could just sit and do nothing, and ai will go away by itself. but we need to fight to make sure ai companies are held to account for what they did.
Ai will not go away by itself but it will follow the path of blockchain, which at the beginning was sold as THE solution for every possible problem (much like Ai) and then quitely drop off the radar to be still used only where it make sense to use it.
AI will be part of business just like computers did, there is no way around that.
Also you can’t really fight if a company wants to implement AI, it is not the decision of workers. It can only be fought politically.
So be careful what you vote for.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/9e5c5dbd-3ab7-497e-bb14-f5de33ac3928.jpeg
https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/pictrs/image/4fe37867-0e2c-4e9b-9451-e80b2f1000de.webp
Wake me up when AI can fix a house. There are plenty of ways for me to go out of business but AI aint one of em
A lot of houses are owned by people who might no longer be employable (in that pictured scenario). Which then means they can’t afford to have their house fixed. Which in turn means those who live off of fixing houses get less contracts or have to massively reduce prices (and therefore dock their own income). So the potential changes are still a big issue, even if robotics aren’t as far yet.
I say weird stuff when I jack off too. They don’t write articles about me over it.
“And when none of you have jobs, nobody will pay Anthropic and it’ll all crash,” he didn’t add.
Obviously, this nonsense is meant to try to prop up their stock price until they have an opportunity to cash out.
However, even if it was true it would mean their company is over valued.
They don’t have any sort of “moat”, so if AI models were truly that good then we could use them to replace Anthropic and render their entire company worthless.
That’s why they want to get local / open source models banned. Because they keep getting better and better and they don’t really have a moat. Gimmie all your RAM Altman kinda shit.
Edit: The only real moat is going to be when one of them solves actual real AI (unlikely any time soon or ever with LLMs) or some dramatic reduction in cost to run them that others can’t replicate.
Funny how the people building AI keep warning that it will make humanity unemployable, then immediately explain why investors should value their company at astronomical levels. Apparently the apocalypse has a cap table, and the people selling tickets insist it’s inevitable.
It’s a trick to lure investors, they want people to invest in fear that AI is the ONLY future, that will take over the global economy.
We still don’t have fully autonomous sela driving cars. That is a much smaller and more manageable problem space than every job that every human on earth can do.
Yet, even within that difficult but constrained problem space, over a decade of effort by multiple companies and hundreds of billions of dollars, we’ve landed on a bunch of disbanded programs and shuttered companies, a few players that can run cars in a handful of specific areas in specific cities that are constantly and carefully mapped with a ton of human management of map data, cities where there is little rain (or where they shut down during heavy rain) and no snow, and where there needs to be 24-7 live human support in case the cars get stuck or confused. And even still there are incidents requiring pulling cars from the roads or pulling operating licenses from companies.
Don’t get me wrong, what they have managed to accomplish is amazing. The 1st time you ride in a Waymo it feels like the sci-fi future we were promised. But it’s far from perfect and there are quite a lot of smoke and mirrors.
How are the robots gonna take over the world next quarter if they can’t even drive past the city limits?
Apparently replacing every human job is easier than teaching a car what to do when a traffic cone falls over. The AI industry has mastered one genuinely autonomous task, though: moving the goalposts whenever reality misses the quarterly earnings call.
If you’re talking about the recent Waymo story, they shut down in San Francisco over an all-time record rainfall.
There were 3 recent Waymo things: 1) the record rainfall, which yeah, it’s a lot, but people could still drive 2) The day before they had their license to drive on the highway pulled because of some incidents and then 3) this week they blocked a street car for hours (this is from memory so forgive me if I’m off slightly here)
Slopvangelical LLM thumpers are the worst.
Anthropic loves this doomsday narrative so much. They’ve run the concept through their LLM over and over and it hits big with predicting investments. Who wouldn’t want to invest in the beast that takes over the world. Yeah it sounds bad on the surface, but when it comes to investments don’t you want to be winning? Don’t you want to at least be rich when the doomsday machine you supported takes you down? They aren’t trying to warn you, they’re trying to get you excited.
Sign in to comment. Sign in