The order matters, because if you start with the trans juice and apply the gay juice later, then you have a load of gay people (good), but if you start with the gay juice and then trans, you just end up with straight people again (bad). Thank you.
If the imaginary trans juice actually makes someone the same but trans then they would still be gay (preserves relative preference), but with a different absolute preference.
Thank you (the reader, not necessarily peanuts4life) for coming to the deranged ted talk that is this comment and surely future others.
I’m a little bit confused by how your comment differs from my own. Perhaps I’ll give you examples of what I’m talking about in the critical danger of the misapplication of gay juice:
Scenario A: Trans juice then gay juice (the best outcome).
Imagine, if you will, an ordinary cis man, Alex. He consumes the trans juice and becomes a woman. Alex is now a gay woman, as her sexual preferences did not have any bearing on her gender identity and remain fixed.
Now, we apply the gay juice after the trans juice. Fundamentally, nothing really changes. Gay juice does not turn a gay woman straight.
And, so you left with a desirable outcome. The entire cis population is now Gay and Trans.
Scenario B: gay juice then trans juice (a very bad, bad way of doing it).
Our cis man, Alex, receives the gay juice. He is now interested in men. He is a gay man.
We then follow up with the trans juice. Alex’s sexual orientation remains fixed solely on men, since the change in her gender identity should not have any effect on her sexual orientation.
Alex, and by extension the entire affected population, is straight. Even more harrowing, is that there are no longer any gay people. All sexual orientations in scenario B are set to gay, but then the person is turned trans, meaning that they are now straight. This means everybody, all sexual orientations, now are turned into straight trans people. This is not an acceptable scenario.
If both gay juice and trans juice are to be applied, scenario A should be followed under all reasonable circumstances.
You forgot the 3rd dimension here. The gay juice is in the water and the trans juice is in the milk. Anyone that drinks both will be continously drinking these at different times and different orders.
The population is entirely gender and sexuality fluid. At this stage labels will becoming practically meaningless. Wake up a straight woman, have lunch as a gay man, followed by dinner as a gay woman.
My argument is that the imaginary juices which doesn’t exist and so can be thought of in whatever way is preferred would be entirely independent. If Alex, a cis gay man (post gay juice) takes the trans juice she is now a trans gay women.
Yes, this is mostly because I’m interpreting them based on the change in language used to describe the person, since it’s unclear to me, a not cutting edge not researcher, what the relationship between the biological factors at play in the birth of gay compared to trans people are, and since one is born queer I apply the perspective of “person is now person but with consequences from being born with <cause of thing> change”.
tl;dr the trans juice doesn’t stop you from being gay, nothing can stop you from being gay
A strong and well-reasoned argument, I see you are a fellow philosopher. The Jekyll to my hide. The Moriarty to my sherlock. The Basil of Baker Street to my Professor Ratigan. Uh, The Sonic the Hedgehog to my Doctor Eggman.
That reminded me of a (deleted) comment thread on the dnd community. We were talking about wizard traps, and someone brought up the idea of changing gender every time you step on one. Appearing unchanged after a flash of light, but utterly shattered upon reaching the other end of a very short hallway after your 15th gender swap in a few minutes.
Comments
He’s saying what we’re all thinking!
(The gay juice is cranberry juice. That’s why they put it in everything 😉)
The order matters, because if you start with the trans juice and apply the gay juice later, then you have a load of gay people (good), but if you start with the gay juice and then trans, you just end up with straight people again (bad). Thank you.
chug both at once and ascend
Transfems can take progresterone to become gay again
Im not sure about transmascs though
If the imaginary trans juice actually makes someone the same but trans then they would still be gay (preserves relative preference), but with a different absolute preference.
Thank you (the reader, not necessarily peanuts4life) for coming to the deranged ted talk that is this comment and surely future others.
I’m a little bit confused by how your comment differs from my own. Perhaps I’ll give you examples of what I’m talking about in the critical danger of the misapplication of gay juice:
Scenario A: Trans juice then gay juice (the best outcome).
Imagine, if you will, an ordinary cis man, Alex. He consumes the trans juice and becomes a woman. Alex is now a gay woman, as her sexual preferences did not have any bearing on her gender identity and remain fixed.
Now, we apply the gay juice after the trans juice. Fundamentally, nothing really changes. Gay juice does not turn a gay woman straight.
And, so you left with a desirable outcome. The entire cis population is now Gay and Trans.
Scenario B: gay juice then trans juice (a very bad, bad way of doing it).
Our cis man, Alex, receives the gay juice. He is now interested in men. He is a gay man.
We then follow up with the trans juice. Alex’s sexual orientation remains fixed solely on men, since the change in her gender identity should not have any effect on her sexual orientation.
Alex, and by extension the entire affected population, is straight. Even more harrowing, is that there are no longer any gay people. All sexual orientations in scenario B are set to gay, but then the person is turned trans, meaning that they are now straight. This means everybody, all sexual orientations, now are turned into straight trans people. This is not an acceptable scenario.
If both gay juice and trans juice are to be applied, scenario A should be followed under all reasonable circumstances.
You forgot the 3rd dimension here. The gay juice is in the water and the trans juice is in the milk. Anyone that drinks both will be continously drinking these at different times and different orders.
The population is entirely gender and sexuality fluid. At this stage labels will becoming practically meaningless. Wake up a straight woman, have lunch as a gay man, followed by dinner as a gay woman.
Almost as if gender doesn’t really mean anything and is entirely a social construct.
My argument is that the imaginary juices which doesn’t exist and so can be thought of in whatever way is preferred would be entirely independent. If Alex, a cis gay man (post gay juice) takes the trans juice she is now a trans gay women.
Yes, this is mostly because I’m interpreting them based on the change in language used to describe the person, since it’s unclear to me, a not cutting edge not researcher, what the relationship between the biological factors at play in the birth of gay compared to trans people are, and since one is born queer I apply the perspective of “person is now person but with consequences from being born with <cause of thing> change”.
tl;dr the trans juice doesn’t stop you from being gay, nothing can stop you from being gay
A strong and well-reasoned argument, I see you are a fellow philosopher. The Jekyll to my hide. The Moriarty to my sherlock. The Basil of Baker Street to my Professor Ratigan. Uh, The Sonic the Hedgehog to my Doctor Eggman.
That reminded me of a (deleted) comment thread on the dnd community. We were talking about wizard traps, and someone brought up the idea of changing gender every time you step on one. Appearing unchanged after a flash of light, but utterly shattered upon reaching the other end of a very short hallway after your 15th gender swap in a few minutes.
i guess i have to throw out all my homo milk now
Sign in to comment. Sign in