If push comes to shove, I’ll carry a dumbphone and small tablet / old flagship for the inevitable QR code bullshit.
I know Sailfish, PostmarketOS are a thing. They’re not reliable enough yet for me to daily drive here as the only solution - weird volTE whitelists in Oz.
I only recently got an android phone again (FF4 running calyx) after using a pinephone and dumbphone for years. Could consider some kind of pocket or tablet sized Linux PC along with a dumb phone just to get SMS.
You’re less secure and private in your communications using a dumb phone. Mms and cell calling are subject to the lawful intercept backdoor (which was famously found to be exploited at the hardware level a few years ago).
You’re better off with some ott encrypted messaging and voice over data.
Most likely if they go back to a dumb phone their usage will be radically different, probably the bare minimum for which they might not care about encryption or hacking… as there will close to no interesting data.
My flip dumbphone has Android 8.1 on it - VoIP, Signal, XMPP etc are all possible. I suppose that makes it a dumb smartphone instead of a Nokia 3310. Though if the 3G shutdown had gone ahead, I’d be rocking my N95
Anyhow, I use my phone for calls, and SMS for trivial things.
For important stuff, there are other channels. Hell, I host my own non-fed 24/7 XMPP server with failover that can only be reached via Wireguard whitelist. It has OMEMO, Fail2Ban and Anubis on it.
Digital convergence was great…until it wasn’t.
Btw, worth noting there are now encrypted SMS and MMS apps. Yes, you have to convince the other person to install the app…at which point you’re better off using Signal or something else.
After all that’s happened in the last year or two (closing android, kneecapping attemps on add filters, no unapproved software running on mainstream OSs, taking more hostile stance towards open source, adding unbelivable shit in EULAs) kinda made me suspect this was coming. Big Tech starting to reap fields of all that “free to use” software that people got hooked on and preventing people from dodging to alternatives.
For that reason I picked Ubuntu Touch.
I really can’t recommend it to “average joe” at the present. Only if you are exited to be a part of new OS and it’s early steps. OS is stable and runs well, even the weekly release client that I’m on, but apps available are few and most are alpha to early beta level.
I got everything I need working, although some solutions are running on android (waydroid) that’s running on top of Ubuntu Touch.
It took too much fiddling, investigating and stuff running on cli on the side. Not for everyone.
Yes, agreed. The issue here (Australia) is around approved devices / whitelisted. Carriers literally refuse to provide service to otherwise perfectly fine phones. A nice 1-2 with the 3G shut down.
Would you be able to carry a small whitelisted mobile network modem that’s meant to be used with security tech and use it’s wifi?
Edit; Like the discussion behind the link said, It’s not really about the software, mostly about the hardware. In same cases phone might have a feature that UT doesn’t support and service provider requires.
Possibly? I’ve not looked in it. My current 2019 era debloated Samsung is still white listed, and so is my Opel Smart touch flip. In theory, I could get a whatever, install PostmarketOS and use the flip as a mobile hotspot.
Though it only has 1750mAh battery.
I haven’t looked into VoIP for a while here but I do recall it being impractical to bridge VoIP to normie telecoms.
EDIT to your EDIT: It’s mostly around approved VoLTE standards, though they do literally block TACs not whitelisted. So a phone that actually works for VoLTE calls can still be blocked because the model was never whitelisted. How my cheap 2019 Samsung scraped by I don’t know. My mates Xperia bit the dust.
Incidentally, that means if you visit Oz from overseas and bring your phone assuming it will work with a cheap local SIM…it might not. Do your homework.
I’ve been in the Apple ecosystem since 2007. I am already about to switch to Home Assistant on a Linux mini computer given how consistently shite Apple Home has always been; and it has somehow gotten even worse. iOS has gotten so bad, I’m considering moving everything to Linux. There are viable phones now, although I don’t know if there’s a tablet solution yet.
FYI: iOS is much more aggressive in restricting apps to run in background, not my cup of tea.
Android is still better at playing youtube in background despite being controlled by Google.
Android allows torrent apps inside the official Google Play store, there are zero torrent apps in apple’s store.
iPhone apps cost more. Some free Android apps coat money on iOS, because Apple charges a yearly $99 fee while Google only charges a one time $25 fee. You could put an app that last basically forever on Google Play (unless you piss off Sundar Pichai or something)
(Also, apk installs is not exactly dead, you can still do the developer options thing, and adb installs also work.)
Comments
If they are gonna lockdown android, i might as well just use iOS.
Nah. Linux WiFi tablet tethered to a burner or MiFi router.
Frying pan into fire, huh?
If push comes to shove, I’ll carry a dumbphone and small tablet / old flagship for the inevitable QR code bullshit.
I know Sailfish, PostmarketOS are a thing. They’re not reliable enough yet for me to daily drive here as the only solution - weird volTE whitelists in Oz.
I only recently got an android phone again (FF4 running calyx) after using a pinephone and dumbphone for years. Could consider some kind of pocket or tablet sized Linux PC along with a dumb phone just to get SMS.
How is your experience like with calyx?
Yep - exactly that.
You’re less secure and private in your communications using a dumb phone. Mms and cell calling are subject to the lawful intercept backdoor (which was famously found to be exploited at the hardware level a few years ago).
You’re better off with some ott encrypted messaging and voice over data.
Yeah. This is the only reason I haven’t switched to a dumb phone. Privacy/security is a necessity for anyone engaged in community organizing ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Most likely if they go back to a dumb phone their usage will be radically different, probably the bare minimum for which they might not care about encryption or hacking… as there will close to no interesting data.
That has not been my experience when friends and family have gotten dumb phones.
^ this.
My flip dumbphone has Android 8.1 on it - VoIP, Signal, XMPP etc are all possible. I suppose that makes it a dumb smartphone instead of a Nokia 3310. Though if the 3G shutdown had gone ahead, I’d be rocking my N95
Anyhow, I use my phone for calls, and SMS for trivial things.
For important stuff, there are other channels. Hell, I host my own non-fed 24/7 XMPP server with failover that can only be reached via Wireguard whitelist. It has OMEMO, Fail2Ban and Anubis on it.
Digital convergence was great…until it wasn’t.
Btw, worth noting there are now encrypted SMS and MMS apps. Yes, you have to convince the other person to install the app…at which point you’re better off using Signal or something else.
Be aware that there isn’t an Android 8.1 device that can’t be physically bypassed with off the shelf cop tools like cellebrite.
After all that’s happened in the last year or two (closing android, kneecapping attemps on add filters, no unapproved software running on mainstream OSs, taking more hostile stance towards open source, adding unbelivable shit in EULAs) kinda made me suspect this was coming. Big Tech starting to reap fields of all that “free to use” software that people got hooked on and preventing people from dodging to alternatives.
For that reason I picked Ubuntu Touch.
I really can’t recommend it to “average joe” at the present. Only if you are exited to be a part of new OS and it’s early steps. OS is stable and runs well, even the weekly release client that I’m on, but apps available are few and most are alpha to early beta level.
I got everything I need working, although some solutions are running on android (waydroid) that’s running on top of Ubuntu Touch.
It took too much fiddling, investigating and stuff running on cli on the side. Not for everyone.
Potential is still huge.
Yes, agreed. The issue here (Australia) is around approved devices / whitelisted. Carriers literally refuse to provide service to otherwise perfectly fine phones. A nice 1-2 with the 3G shut down.
https://forums.ubports.com/topic/3695/australian-mobile-service-providers-dont-accept-ubuntu/
Thread is from 2020/21; gotten even worse since then
Shit that’s cold.
Would you be able to carry a small whitelisted mobile network modem that’s meant to be used with security tech and use it’s wifi?
Edit; Like the discussion behind the link said, It’s not really about the software, mostly about the hardware. In same cases phone might have a feature that UT doesn’t support and service provider requires.
Possibly? I’ve not looked in it. My current 2019 era debloated Samsung is still white listed, and so is my Opel Smart touch flip. In theory, I could get a whatever, install PostmarketOS and use the flip as a mobile hotspot.
Though it only has 1750mAh battery.
I haven’t looked into VoIP for a while here but I do recall it being impractical to bridge VoIP to normie telecoms.
EDIT to your EDIT: It’s mostly around approved VoLTE standards, though they do literally block TACs not whitelisted. So a phone that actually works for VoLTE calls can still be blocked because the model was never whitelisted. How my cheap 2019 Samsung scraped by I don’t know. My mates Xperia bit the dust.
Incidentally, that means if you visit Oz from overseas and bring your phone assuming it will work with a cheap local SIM…it might not. Do your homework.
I’ve been in the Apple ecosystem since 2007. I am already about to switch to Home Assistant on a Linux mini computer given how consistently shite Apple Home has always been; and it has somehow gotten even worse. iOS has gotten so bad, I’m considering moving everything to Linux. There are viable phones now, although I don’t know if there’s a tablet solution yet.
Im thinking rotary dial
FYI: iOS is much more aggressive in restricting apps to run in background, not my cup of tea.
Android is still better at playing youtube in background despite being controlled by Google.
Android allows torrent apps inside the official Google Play store, there are zero torrent apps in apple’s store.
iPhone apps cost more. Some free Android apps coat money on iOS, because Apple charges a yearly $99 fee while Google only charges a one time $25 fee. You could put an app that last basically forever on Google Play (unless you piss off Sundar Pichai or something)
(Also, apk installs is not exactly dead, you can still do the developer options thing, and adb installs also work.)
So move to a more locked down device out of spite?
Now that Linux is doing so well on the desktop, maybe a Linux phone grapheneos would be a way forward.
Sign in to comment. Sign in