Skip to content

Comment on Google is finally mask-off trying to kill GrapheneOS

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Fuck everything about Google and Alphabet and that entire shit-ass ecosystem. (Also fuck Apple x100)

    For the Graphene peeps: lie down with the dogs, get up with the fleas. No shit. Please tell me you saw this coming. Because if you did not, you are idiot-savants: really good with computers, but can’t understand capitalism and the interhuman power dynamics.

    And the above is a big problem. You make good tech decisions, but very poor political positioning decisions, and everyone in the GOS echosystem pays for it. Don’t even try to tell me how you aren’t political. Everything has always been and will be political.

    What are the Google/Alphabet priorities? What are the GrapheneOS priorities? You have never been aligned, fools.

    Google does not currently benefit from granting their users digital sovereignty. Google and Alphabet make their money from privacy and user sovereignty invasions. Wake the fuck up.

    -2
    • What exactly did the GrapheneOS developers do wrong? You write a lot of vague stuff to blame the victims.

      10
      • They chose Pixel and overrelied on Android.

        They should have given up on Titan for political reasons, done their best to get as secure as possible w/o Titan, even if not as secure, a worthy sacrifice.

        Release on many devices, and don’t release on Pixel at all. Diversify.

        And get ready to fork Androiod and take over its development. Make plans, talk to people. Determine who’s interested. Organize. OpenOffice was forked. I am sure there is even more interest in a liberated mobile OS than in an office suite. And if not an Android fork, then a proper Linux phone.

        Of course not everything must happen on day 1, but on day 1 you DO know what side your bread is buttered on, you know where your spiritual North is, and move accordingly, gradually. On day 1 you KNOW you aren’t aligned with Google/Alphabet (unless somethig drastically chages over there in way we could trust), so no illusions, don’t get comphy with Pixel, or stock Android for that matter, and steer toward your own organizational sovereignty and that of your users.

        A decision can never be 100% technical. If Titan has the best specs, that alone isn’t good enough to choose it.

        Of course in a fight between GOS and Google/Alphabet, I want GOS to win. But GOS could have and should have done better as well.

        1
        • That seems like oversimplifying things. Pixels were chosen over other phones, because the bootloader is not locked. If that was the case for more other phones, I doubt the GOS team would have chosen the company they were trying to circumvebt/improve upon. Also Pixels offer stock android which offers simpler adoption options.

          Titan was a burden, but they had already put lots of effort into Pixels and the Titan port was just a logical next step.

          Do not get me wrong… yes, android was a long time getting more locked down instead of tending to open up more, but alternative options were limited at best.

          I agree they were relying on Android and Google, but given the alternatives, I wouldnt say they were relying too much, because what else was there to do (genuine question, I don’t see what)?

          2
          • Now that we’re here, I hope GOS cleans the shit out of Google/Alphabet in court.

            Both things can be true at once: GOS is a victim of Google, and, GOS has not used all the cards they had to play up to here.

            It’s not too late for GOS either. Things are only getting started, there is all kinds of future potentials. No need to panic or doom. But we do need to take stock of what’s happening and how to do better.

            Unfortunately, we’re dealing with ruthless assholes in the industry, and short of government action doing to Google/Alphabet what was done to Ma Bell, people imo should plan accordingly.

            If you are dealing with sharks, you have to be well prepared. Either you are a shark yourself, or you have other strong adaptations which effectively counter shark behaviors.

            Essentially, as I see it, GOS is a digital sovereignty organization. They want to decentralize or in other words splinter control in the computing sphere. Google/Alphabet is moving toward consolidation of control, in the opposite direction. Google is moving toward tech feudalism, inspired by Apple, no doubt.

            Basically, in the big picture, Google is the worst possible partner politically in 2020-26, possibly earlier. (Very very EARLY “do no evil” Google did legit look like an attractive and good faith FOSS partner! But those days are long gone.) So the dependency on Google hardware, or software, or services, has to be continually minimized. For practical reasons we might want to maintain some interop with Google/Alphabet, but we want at all times to make it as painless and as easy as possible to dump them, continually, for the entire life of the project, unless something very drastically and substantially changes at Google, like Google moves wholly to an entirely new business model which changes radically this entire calculus.

            Phones with open and openable boot loaders:

            https://android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/list-phones-with-unlockable-bootloaders-0179751/

            Another thing, I think a huge amount of weight was given to Titan on technical merit forgetting WHO controlls Titan and what their priorities are.

            Even if not enough phones come with open bootloaders, then LOBBY the phone manufacturers continuously to open them. And, seek new ventures, an entirely new breed of a phone company that will stake its future on widespread digital sovereignty. Educate. Evangelize. Etc. This is political activity.

            In other words, digital sovereignty is both a tech project AND a political one.

            Fascists like big vertical hierarchies, and quasi-feudal social norms. This works best with big power/wealth consolidations and concentrations.

            If you want distributed everything, you align with democracy and socialism. You align with people power. Economic populism. Just realize which side your bread is buttered on.

            0

Sign in to comment. Sign in