In Brave New World there was an experimental society of “all alphas”, and within a few years their inability to suppress their egos led to a brutal civil war that killed the vast majority of them.
I encourage the rich to build as many self-governed societies of themselves as they want.
I can’t decide whether Libertarians are most insufferable because of how dumb they are or because of how they only ever try the same damn idea over and over again while ignoring everybody else who already tried the same thing and found that it failed spectacularly… so they thoughtfully wrote down their observations for the next people who came along to build on the shoulders of. The only shoulders that exist to Libertarians are their own which both explains why they are incapable accepting that socialized forms of government are effective and necessary and why the rich ones cannot comprehend the incredible lack of perspective their wealth gives them because they perceive themselves as having obtained all they obtained based upon only their own shoulders…
This is also why Libertarian types so easily become obsessed with AI, it is just the same stupid great man theory of science and innovation but applied to a tool which somehow is even worse than the incorrect, cruel and cynical pseudo-scientific belief that science and progress are dependent upon great men rather than collective shared knowledge.
Every individual Libertarian undergoes a sort of pseudo-learning process where they reinvent basic concepts that everyone else figured out a long time ago and tried hopelessly to explain to them, but overall the effect is a barbershop spinning pole, there is no unified upward movement towards more nuanced forms of intelligence, individual Libertarians that have finally after a lifetime reinvented basic concepts around government and the theory of government after hurting a whole bunch of people unnecessarily eventually die, the knowledge is ignored by all of the other Libertarians and what is left are younger clones traveling along the same exact trajectory.
I can’t decide whether Libertarians are most insufferable because of how dumb they are or because of how they only ever try the same damn idea over and over again while ignoring everybody else who already tried the same thing and found that it failed spectacularly…
I think the lack of knowledge and education plays a bigger part, but that often goes hand in hand with being dumb.
I feel like rich tech people are totally mentally gone. Everything that comes out of their world is made up fantasy bullshit that clearly come from some movie.
An island you say? I wonder where you got the idea to build your own autonomous self governed island. Jeffrey, is that you?
They sound like 4 year olds smashing their action figures together. There is now zero connection between wealth and human value. No connection between wealth and innovation, creativity, or intelligence.
Capitalism created a society of false leaders who are entirely losers through and through. People who would instantly crumble on the field of battle but bellow the loudest of battle cries. I’d rather see them at the end of a rope.
There are no “real leaders”, so people saying “false leaders” as if there were anything else are part of the problem.
Guess who’d also instantly crumble on the field of battle.
Not something strange anyway, seeing people murdered, knowing you’ll see more and perhaps murder some of them and perhaps will be murdered, - that seems a pretty good reason to be in shambles.
Those people all had PTSD to the extent of hallucinations, if you are referring to medieval kings and such as “real leaders”, and some of them were pretty mad and pretty immoral.
While, say, Canute or Charlemagne and other such known “virtuous kings” were pacifists as much as that, eh, existed then.
Well, since you mentioned ropes and battles, I decided you are comparing capitalism to feudalism, care to name the trade of your ancestors? You know why I’m asking? Because you can’t be anyone else, and if the spot is taken, you can only be servant of the person occupying it. That was the deal. If your ancestors are carpenters, then you can only be a carpenter, and if you do anything else, you’ll be a thief by medieval customary laws. Medieval customs differed from place to place, but that was pretty common.
Also people of various families and trades were not equal, so you like a girl from a different family (not commoner versus nobleman, just a better commoner family) and she likes you? Fuck you. Try to approach her or even elope together - chances are you’re both better off accidentally breaking your necks stumbling on some root, than being caught.
Medieval societies were not very nice.
EDIT: And capitalism is the very change that allowed you to not be bound by all those unfortunate rules.
True. We should stop now, and never improve anything, while the plutocrats bring us back to the good ol days of having everything you will ever experience in life, dictated by someone who hates you.
Even today, with Internet and egalitarian laws and common literacy, living in a small village is not a pleasant experience.
And you can experience medieval society right now, in rural India or Afghanistan. At least you might read about it.
I don’t know what view you are talking about, nothing locked and controlled, just the society around you.
Things locked and controlled are sometimes good , for example, when your fate is decided by the collective opinion of your village, they won’t lynch you if there’s control.
And in a medieval village they would lynch you if they wanted.
But again, living in a village in a developed country is still, after all those centuries, living in a village, people write things on how it is to live in a village.
Your comment is completely untrue. You’re watching brave heart and playing chivalry thinking that’s how it was. It wasn’t.
People were not locked into a profession, if they had a good one they worked to keep it. People did all sorts of work and the need for a job which paid was actually not as important as working to secure food for you and your people. Community mattered more.
On top of that, because the community mattered, there wasn’t mindless slaughtering, hangings and such violence you’re asserting. That’s literally ridiculous. Crime was both higher in some ways than today and actually much lower. They wouldn’t lynch you if they wanted, such a dramatic belief of history you carry.
And you can experience medieval society right now, in rural India or Afghanistan
That’s actually not medieval society it’s modern society. Medieval society was very isolated and community oriented. The problems in Afghanistan and India you’re talking to have a lot more to do with racism, inequality that evolves into anger, loss of community, and access to extremely dangerous weapons like guns. Those aren’t things the medieval era struggled with. People were more homogeneous, they didn’t travel much and didn’t fully understand the inequality they faced especially since it wasn’t the same level of predatory as the modern age. They didn’t need to maintain an office job, car payments, mortgage, money for food. All of those were just daily chores.
And then battles? They were not gut spilling brutal massacres of gore and hate and violence. They were actually kind of slow. Troops were rotated out often, you didn’t field the whole force at once that’s stupid people gotta shit and eat and rest up for the fight later on. Soldiers would retreat once formations broke. If you wanna see what a battle looked like go watch a group of teenagers yelling at each other on the street before a fight and scale that up, then watch HEMA or Buhurt and recognize most fighters weren’t professionally trained, you had guys with spears told to stand there and a couple really good fighters in walking tank suits. Both groups will get exhausted after 30 minutes of fighting.
Your comment is completely untrue. You’re watching brave heart and playing chivalry thinking that’s how it was. It wasn’t.
Very fucking strange, it seemed you do that and I’m trying to explain that people are not very nice when not checked.
People were not locked into a profession, if they had a good one they worked to keep it. People did all sorts of work and the need for a job which paid was actually not as important as working to secure food for you and your people. Community mattered more.
… And competing in trade was an act of aggression, judged by how justified it was, and if it wasn’t you were considered a thief. That’s a specific fact about those medieval community values. That made sense in small isolated settlements and no market to speak of to alleviate supply and demand changes.
And there were not locked specifically , but they were not expected to just pick another way of life, that wasn’t normal. I don’t know where even specifically to send you, there’s plenty of good historical fiction, but there’s also plenty of literature from the times we are discussing, like Chaucer might help, or some of the Norse sagas for a different, but still quite similar society.
I don’t even know why you are arguing this, if you think there was some better society that was “ruined by capitalism”, that ain’t it. Too stupid an idea anyway.
That’s actually not medieval society it’s modern society. Medieval society was very isolated and community oriented.
That’s exactly what they are, isolated and community oriented places where a village mulla can say to the people that you insulted Quran and you get lynched within an hour. Plenty of real cases in our times. Plenty of such real cases described by travelers hundred years ago and two hundred years ago. And that’s how it was in European villages.
Those aren’t things the medieval era struggled with. People were more homogeneous, they didn’t travel much and didn’t fully understand the inequality they faced especially since it wasn’t the same level of predatory as the modern age.
Yes, damn right, literally being owned is not the same level of predatory. You are amazing.
Yes, of course they didn’t understand the inequality, they were more equal than now, except in a medieval society it’s not considered that two equal people can do the same things. In a medieval society you have your place, your family, your ancestors, your trade and can’t just change to any other equal place. Even in cities, and of course you couldn’t in villages. Nobody forces you, you’ll just die from hunger because it’ll be very hard to be accepted into some other “equal” place, accepting strangers was uncommon, and a stranger competing in some trade with a known local wouldn’t have any clients. Even if theft accusation wouldn’t happen and it could.
They didn’t need to maintain an office job, car payments, mortgage, money for food. All of those were just daily chores.
They did have jobs (just couldn’t realistically change them), they did have debts, and due to less productive technologies owned less and owed more, and of course they did need to have money to buy food if they failed to grow food, they didn’t live in communism, that’s for sure.
They could submit into serfdom if they were freemen that couldn’t feed themselves on their own. That didn’t mean they wouldn’t need money and work to live and care for themselves and pay debts, they just could submit into serfdom in exchange for something, like payout of their existent debt by their new master. One time.
I thought Oculus Rift was originally a product with good intentions behind it and Meta enshittified it, but after reading more about this douchbag and things he’s said like it being ok for military AI to make decisions to kill people, I no longer hold such delusions.
So it’s an immensely large floating city project and… he’s spending <$2 billion to build it. I know these guys are idiots but fucking hell, large cruise ships are a tiny fraction of the proposed size of this thing, and they cost around $1 billion each.
They’re doing this because they tried the cruise ship angle and it didn’t work. So they think the issue is not enough money was being spent to solve the problem. Smart people 👌
What I assume this means is that they want to be pedophiles, rapists and slave owners without some government they only partially own telling them what to do.
Much like the salmon swimming upstream to spawn and die, the tech lolbertarian will take to the sea with some half-baked idea about how to mine bitcoin and rebroadcast MLB with implied consent away from governance.
This sort of plan would be pretty worrying coming from any billionaire, but given that Luckey runs Anduril and plans to genetically engineer dogs for the military, the idea of him controlling a giant lab that operates outside conventional laws gives off strong Umbrella Corporation vibes.
Oh, there would be plenty of laws. His laws. We’re supposed to learn from history, not ignore it. This place would be hell to live and work on, and there would be a revolt, and perhaps a massacre. Come to think of it, I really hope he builds it. Maybe the world needs to see this happen.
Not that this thing will ever be more than AI renderings.
Comments
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/9b71f3f6-3653-4a4d-8655-91a0904651c7.png
Oooh boy I can’t WAIT for the YouTube mockery when it crashes and burns.
Sealand 2: Aquatic Boogaloo
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/4a940cac-b315-4cf4-a625-7ab90eda1dcd.png
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/70aaeb9d-f77f-49ec-b2d0-ccc423254de6.png
Guy has been robbing the us government blind and now plans to hide it all away in the ocean
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/2942ecff-02df-4109-9b57-7b32b38dc399.png
Yes do it bro great idea spend all your money on this please please please
Let them, then seize their bank accounts and assets on the way out.
They won’t because then they’d have to do that to everyone leaving for a private island.
Which I’m in favor of, but they won’t do it.
In Brave New World there was an experimental society of “all alphas”, and within a few years their inability to suppress their egos led to a brutal civil war that killed the vast majority of them.
I encourage the rich to build as many self-governed societies of themselves as they want.
Not good enough, “vast majority” means that the worst offenders survived.
I can’t decide whether Libertarians are most insufferable because of how dumb they are or because of how they only ever try the same damn idea over and over again while ignoring everybody else who already tried the same thing and found that it failed spectacularly… so they thoughtfully wrote down their observations for the next people who came along to build on the shoulders of. The only shoulders that exist to Libertarians are their own which both explains why they are incapable accepting that socialized forms of government are effective and necessary and why the rich ones cannot comprehend the incredible lack of perspective their wealth gives them because they perceive themselves as having obtained all they obtained based upon only their own shoulders…
This is also why Libertarian types so easily become obsessed with AI, it is just the same stupid great man theory of science and innovation but applied to a tool which somehow is even worse than the incorrect, cruel and cynical pseudo-scientific belief that science and progress are dependent upon great men rather than collective shared knowledge.
Every individual Libertarian undergoes a sort of pseudo-learning process where they reinvent basic concepts that everyone else figured out a long time ago and tried hopelessly to explain to them, but overall the effect is a barbershop spinning pole, there is no unified upward movement towards more nuanced forms of intelligence, individual Libertarians that have finally after a lifetime reinvented basic concepts around government and the theory of government after hurting a whole bunch of people unnecessarily eventually die, the knowledge is ignored by all of the other Libertarians and what is left are younger clones traveling along the same exact trajectory.
Rinse & Repeat
I think the lack of knowledge and education plays a bigger part, but that often goes hand in hand with being dumb.
It’s Epstein Island but cyberpunk.
The things people do to avoid age of consent and csam laws
That too, but first and foremost it’s always a financial grift. The child slaves come later.
So if there are no laws at sea, then if something shot a missile at it, that isn’t a crime?
If they wanted to ship in food and supplies, pirates could happily snatch them.
When a big storm hits and fucks everything up, nobody has to go save them.
I don’t see any issues here. Proceed.
The high seas aren’t lawless. International maritime law still applies.
Would be practically hard to enforce, sure, but still.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Convention_on_the_Law_of_the_Sea
Collect all the billionaires there and launch a bunch of Tomahawks at it.
Naw a GBU-43/b, gotta really make sure none of them have a chance to escape.
They own the tomahawks
The non-billionaires are the ones who design and build them
Company Towns, famously with no problems at all /jk
I feel like rich tech people are totally mentally gone. Everything that comes out of their world is made up fantasy bullshit that clearly come from some movie.
An island you say? I wonder where you got the idea to build your own autonomous self governed island. Jeffrey, is that you?
They sound like 4 year olds smashing their action figures together. There is now zero connection between wealth and human value. No connection between wealth and innovation, creativity, or intelligence.
Capitalism created a society of false leaders who are entirely losers through and through. People who would instantly crumble on the field of battle but bellow the loudest of battle cries. I’d rather see them at the end of a rope.
There are no “real leaders”, so people saying “false leaders” as if there were anything else are part of the problem.
Guess who’d also instantly crumble on the field of battle.
Not something strange anyway, seeing people murdered, knowing you’ll see more and perhaps murder some of them and perhaps will be murdered, - that seems a pretty good reason to be in shambles.
Those people all had PTSD to the extent of hallucinations, if you are referring to medieval kings and such as “real leaders”, and some of them were pretty mad and pretty immoral.
While, say, Canute or Charlemagne and other such known “virtuous kings” were pacifists as much as that, eh, existed then.
Well, since you mentioned ropes and battles, I decided you are comparing capitalism to feudalism, care to name the trade of your ancestors? You know why I’m asking? Because you can’t be anyone else, and if the spot is taken, you can only be servant of the person occupying it. That was the deal. If your ancestors are carpenters, then you can only be a carpenter, and if you do anything else, you’ll be a thief by medieval customary laws. Medieval customs differed from place to place, but that was pretty common.
Also people of various families and trades were not equal, so you like a girl from a different family (not commoner versus nobleman, just a better commoner family) and she likes you? Fuck you. Try to approach her or even elope together - chances are you’re both better off accidentally breaking your necks stumbling on some root, than being caught.
Medieval societies were not very nice.
EDIT: And capitalism is the very change that allowed you to not be bound by all those unfortunate rules.
True. We should stop now, and never improve anything, while the plutocrats bring us back to the good ol days of having everything you will ever experience in life, dictated by someone who hates you.
You might think you are being ironic, but in fact you are just picking strawmen not being capable of saying something of value.
Do you unironically want Monarchy? Or to stop at Capitalism?
Just because we aren’t slaves, does not mean we are well-off.
Bro they can’t even stop kids smoking weed in school.
The view of medieval society being locked and heavily controlled just ain’t true. Reality was not like that at all.
Your comment is not reasonable.
Even today, with Internet and egalitarian laws and common literacy, living in a small village is not a pleasant experience.
And you can experience medieval society right now, in rural India or Afghanistan. At least you might read about it.
I don’t know what view you are talking about, nothing locked and controlled, just the society around you.
Things locked and controlled are sometimes good , for example, when your fate is decided by the collective opinion of your village, they won’t lynch you if there’s control.
And in a medieval village they would lynch you if they wanted.
But again, living in a village in a developed country is still, after all those centuries, living in a village, people write things on how it is to live in a village.
Your comment is completely untrue. You’re watching brave heart and playing chivalry thinking that’s how it was. It wasn’t.
People were not locked into a profession, if they had a good one they worked to keep it. People did all sorts of work and the need for a job which paid was actually not as important as working to secure food for you and your people. Community mattered more.
On top of that, because the community mattered, there wasn’t mindless slaughtering, hangings and such violence you’re asserting. That’s literally ridiculous. Crime was both higher in some ways than today and actually much lower. They wouldn’t lynch you if they wanted, such a dramatic belief of history you carry.
That’s actually not medieval society it’s modern society. Medieval society was very isolated and community oriented. The problems in Afghanistan and India you’re talking to have a lot more to do with racism, inequality that evolves into anger, loss of community, and access to extremely dangerous weapons like guns. Those aren’t things the medieval era struggled with. People were more homogeneous, they didn’t travel much and didn’t fully understand the inequality they faced especially since it wasn’t the same level of predatory as the modern age. They didn’t need to maintain an office job, car payments, mortgage, money for food. All of those were just daily chores.
And then battles? They were not gut spilling brutal massacres of gore and hate and violence. They were actually kind of slow. Troops were rotated out often, you didn’t field the whole force at once that’s stupid people gotta shit and eat and rest up for the fight later on. Soldiers would retreat once formations broke. If you wanna see what a battle looked like go watch a group of teenagers yelling at each other on the street before a fight and scale that up, then watch HEMA or Buhurt and recognize most fighters weren’t professionally trained, you had guys with spears told to stand there and a couple really good fighters in walking tank suits. Both groups will get exhausted after 30 minutes of fighting.
You have a ludicrous view of history.
Very fucking strange, it seemed you do that and I’m trying to explain that people are not very nice when not checked.
… And competing in trade was an act of aggression, judged by how justified it was, and if it wasn’t you were considered a thief. That’s a specific fact about those medieval community values. That made sense in small isolated settlements and no market to speak of to alleviate supply and demand changes.
And there were not locked specifically , but they were not expected to just pick another way of life, that wasn’t normal. I don’t know where even specifically to send you, there’s plenty of good historical fiction, but there’s also plenty of literature from the times we are discussing, like Chaucer might help, or some of the Norse sagas for a different, but still quite similar society.
I don’t even know why you are arguing this, if you think there was some better society that was “ruined by capitalism”, that ain’t it. Too stupid an idea anyway.
That’s exactly what they are, isolated and community oriented places where a village mulla can say to the people that you insulted Quran and you get lynched within an hour. Plenty of real cases in our times. Plenty of such real cases described by travelers hundred years ago and two hundred years ago. And that’s how it was in European villages.
Yes, damn right, literally being owned is not the same level of predatory. You are amazing.
Yes, of course they didn’t understand the inequality, they were more equal than now, except in a medieval society it’s not considered that two equal people can do the same things. In a medieval society you have your place, your family, your ancestors, your trade and can’t just change to any other equal place. Even in cities, and of course you couldn’t in villages. Nobody forces you, you’ll just die from hunger because it’ll be very hard to be accepted into some other “equal” place, accepting strangers was uncommon, and a stranger competing in some trade with a known local wouldn’t have any clients. Even if theft accusation wouldn’t happen and it could.
They did have jobs (just couldn’t realistically change them), they did have debts, and due to less productive technologies owned less and owed more, and of course they did need to have money to buy food if they failed to grow food, they didn’t live in communism, that’s for sure.
They could submit into serfdom if they were freemen that couldn’t feed themselves on their own. That didn’t mean they wouldn’t need money and work to live and care for themselves and pay debts, they just could submit into serfdom in exchange for something, like payout of their existent debt by their new master. One time.
I thought Oculus Rift was originally a product with good intentions behind it and Meta enshittified it, but after reading more about this douchbag and things he’s said like it being ok for military AI to make decisions to kill people, I no longer hold such delusions.
So it’s an immensely large floating city project and… he’s spending <$2 billion to build it. I know these guys are idiots but fucking hell, large cruise ships are a tiny fraction of the proposed size of this thing, and they cost around $1 billion each.
Let’s let him cook.
Best case scenario is he gets the Titan Submersible treatment.
Most likely case is he’ll run out of money building the thing and will no longer plague our politics with his moneyspeech.
Worst case is he succeeds and… leaves the United States forever?
I see only upsides.
Literally willing to pay billions to avoid paying millions in tax. Genius move
They’re doing this because they tried the cruise ship angle and it didn’t work. So they think the issue is not enough money was being spent to solve the problem. Smart people 👌
What I assume this means is that they want to be pedophiles, rapists and slave owners without some government they only partially own telling them what to do.
If history is any indication, this usually means that they are about to be arrested and want to GTFO before they go to prison.
Yeah, pretty much.
Time to add him to the growing list of rich white dudes who have tried this and failed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasteading
Venice?
Much like the salmon swimming upstream to spawn and die, the tech lolbertarian will take to the sea with some half-baked idea about how to mine bitcoin and rebroadcast MLB with implied consent away from governance.
Remember that giant cruise ship they were talking about once a time? Not the one that ran out of money in Vietnam, the dumber one that never happened.
Riiight… “dogs”…
Just give them Rabbies
Yet another wildly impossible project that looks good on a PowerPoint presentation. Though it’s usually the Saudis falling for it.
Oh, there would be plenty of laws. His laws. We’re supposed to learn from history, not ignore it. This place would be hell to live and work on, and there would be a revolt, and perhaps a massacre. Come to think of it, I really hope he builds it. Maybe the world needs to see this happen.
Not that this thing will ever be more than AI renderings.
Never a shortage of techbros trying to become James Bond villains.
Sign in to comment. Sign in