53
"The world is open for play, everything and everybody is mockable in a wonderful way." - Robin Williams
Derogatory Irish themes aside, remember that part where Riker straight up murders some incubating clones?
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/556574b9-bbc3-4cfe-8806-e07d75031d75.jpeg
Comments
they were made without thier consent, and subject to the law of diminishing returns of clones would.
I was a kid when I first saw this, so the problematic aspects went over my head back then. I can see them now to but they don’t ruin the episode for me.
One of the reasons is the moment depicted in this meme: it’s one of the first times I remember in the series when we saw some Patrick Stewart shine through. His reaction at the time was totally unexpected. Almost shocking.
The Irish racism I see as a product of its time (though I get why Colm Meaney wasn’t happy.)
Riker’s cold-blooded killing of the clones is also wrong, but I’m of two minds here, and the show missed an opportunity to explore the ethical ramifications. On the one hand, the murder is wrong, but on the other hand, there’s an angle that parallels the Pro-choice point of view. Riker and Pulaski were violated, and these clones are the result. They should have a say, in the same way a woman who is pregnant as the result of a rape should have a say (it’s not exactly the same, il grant you, but there’s enough of a parallel to warrant exploring the ethical ramifications further.)
A lot of people are used to overly sanitized TV shows now. In the past, characters in an a episodic TV show would just do stuff, and it was intended to make the audience think about the morality of that action.
Today people tend to want to lay down judgement on a fictional character. Riker is a murder, Sisko is war criminal or whatever. Quick to judgement to avoid thinking about something because attention spans have been shortened.
What you wrote was the point of the episode. You are meant to think about what this fictional character did in this fictional storyline and whether or not that was ethical. It’s making you think as opposed to telling you how you’re supposed to think. To me, that makes it a good episode. After all, we are discussing it right now. We aren’t discussing the episodes where the obvious good guy does the obviously good thing.
It also gave us one of Riker’s coldest all-time lines:
“And what are you staring at? You never seen a woman before?”
“I thought I had.”
Coldest? He’s complementing her saying she’s the first real woman he’s ever seen. Oh God am I just too old to understand what cold means?
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/88762a61-9862-49ce-a5c8-7be98c725f6c.gif
https://feddit.org/pictrs/image/cc5852c5-f3f0-4b6f-84a8-f7a76c560e97.jpeg
The first two seasons are very reminiscent of TOS, and Riker’s summary execution of those clones is extremely Kirk-coded in its mentality of “nope, don’t like what’s going on here, just gonna change this.”
I missed a lot of episodes back in the day, but am currently in the process of watching… I’m on S2E14, so I guess I’ll see it soon.
To say it’s rough is being generous. O’Brien actor Colm Meaney nearly left the series for its caricatures of Irish culture. Then there’s some muddy ethical issues concerning the Prime Directive and the other society featured in the episode. Still watch it, but with a few grains of salt and a shot or two of tequila, what-have-you.
ooof!
This episode is why my partner wont watch the show
Show them Sub Rosa.
Bummer that’s the case, as it’s an outlier among so much greatness. Butter them up and try “The Inner Light” maybe?
Ah there is so much greatness for sure, I can see past the characiture to te rest of the show but they cant.
Tell your partner about the Irish Reunification of 2024, see if that changes their mind
Absolutely, and enrerprise had a school in Kenmare - their hometown - in episode one.
Well, they would’ve stopped watching anyway when they got to the episode where Beverly’s grandmother is raped by a ghost. TNG is not for the faint of heart sometimes.
Rape gangs are mentioner so frequently in the first season
It was still the 80s. Rape was featured in a lot of TV shows and movies back then.
Sign in to comment. Sign in