Skip to content

Comment on Judge halts Army’s plan to detonate 5 tons of bomb-making material as Iowa residents worry about lead exposure

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Hot take: the Lead II Azide needs to be disposed of. Its extremely hazardous stuff left in that form.

    The containment they built for it seems better than nothing.

    It has a detonation energy of 9mJ. You could touch it slightly too hard and it explodes.

    You can chemically nuetralize it, but it creates MORE hazards that way. Blowing it up is the correct way to go about it. They can barely safely transport the stuff.

    Its a “choose the least harmful method of disposal.” If the containment can be improved to reduce the spread even more, great. If it can’t, then the military owes exposed Iowans compensation.

    51
    • My problem is that it was allowed to get to this point.

      At some point it wasn’t too volatile to move. Inspections should have been more thorough, or more frequent, or both. Somebody fucked up to get us into this situation, and that somebody should be held accountable.

      11
      • Lead II Azide is always this volatile. The problem was that it was left unused and undisposed of. It doesn’t decay, but will react with other elements that become even more volatile. And if those more volatile compounds denotate in an uncontrolled fashion, the whole thing goes up in an uncontrolled fashion.

        It’s meant for detonaters.

        0
        • @nulluser@lemmy.world· · edited

          You’re missing my point.

          Blowing it up in place was not always the only option. Somebody fucked up to get us to the point that blowing it up in place is the only option.

          5
    • You could touch it slightly too hard and it explodes.

      But enough about puberty

      25
    • If they can put a sarcophagus over melted down nuclear reactors, surely they could figure out a way to cover this up under enough concrete and steel without disturbing it. There is no world where dispersing lead in the US corn belt is the best option.

      11
      • Except you can’t. The volatility of it is so crazy that the best containment we could engineer would still allow for the transfer of energy INTO the material. It’s literally impossible to prevent all sources of energy transfer.

        The way they have it set up reduces the lead dispersion, but they want the army to review to see if it can be reduced further.

        You have two options with Lead II Azide.

        You can detonate it. Or you can chemically render it inert with expensive chemistey which creates new hazards to despose of.

        Thats it. The question isn’t “what can we do about it” the question is “how do we prevent this situation in the future.”

        3
        • But nuclear meltdown isn’t volatile? Come on. Bury the lead azide under enough concrete and steel and I don’t care how big the explosion is, it will be contained.

          I assume they did a cost-benefit analysis and decided it’s just too expensive to construct a sarcophagus for one explosion.

          1
          • So the crane guy drops a pack of cigarettes and explodes the whole area. That’s the whole point, going near enough to the thing to do anything about it is dangerous as fuck.

            1
            • Tbh Im surprised they were ballsy enough to do the sandbag and water containment. But I guess with the army, they don’t typically smoke around explosives. I think. Idk i was never in the military

              0
          • No, radioactive material ISN’T volatile.

            Volatile means it can change state due to a wide variety of factors. Radioative means that it is sending off ionizing particles at a constant rate. Radioactive material does not explode.

            You seen to be ignoring a lot of what I thought would be basic science. E = .5mv^2. The process of burying it under ANYTHING you will set it off. If you build a big ass dome around it, you’re going to need a LOT of construction machinery to lift and place heavy stuff. And someone or something will fuck up. Then, instead of spreading that would be a small amount over a large area , you got people killed immediately.

            Pretty much every scenario results in the stuff detonating. 9 milijoules. Thats an object of 0.72 grams moving at 5 m/s. Which is like less than a meter and a half of something dropped.

            2
            • you got people killed immediately.

              Vs killing arguably more people slowly over time due to lead exposure.

              0
            • You argue a whole lot about this and there are certainly correct things, but also some nonsense. You can pile a shit ton of stuff in top and nothing will happen. All you need is to take the load off of the container, like with a bit of concrete you pour first or whatever else you want to do. This is really a non-issue and you can easily contain this detonation.

              For chemically decomposing it, what is supposed to be even worse there?

              -1
      • Those are to contain radiation, not a huge explosion. Totally different situations!

        10
    • @zoloftt@lemmy.world· · edited

      That’s understandable, but they need to do as much as possible to mitigate in that case.

      25
      • Unfortunately this is the mitigation. The force of the explosion has to go somewhere. You could blow it up in a bigger container, but the container needs to be a certain size otherwise it just becomes more shrapnel

        1
        • Yeah, I read the article. It seems like they have handled this poorly though.

          Hope they compensate people for this

          1
    • This makes perfect sense. I wonder if they could just blow it up in small amounts in a semi enclosed space to prevent wide dispersal, then clean up the area?

      0
      • Sure, you could. But remember, moving the material transfers energy. You have 9 milijoules that you cannot transfer. Every time you move it, you present a risk of static electricity detonating it, a change in temperature detonating it, dropping it detonating it, looking at it wrong detonating it.

        The more times you have to move it, the more chances you have of it becoming a really bad day.

        3
    • This and the article Zak posted in this thread really changed my mind. Without context blowing it up send as silly as the time they tried blowing up that whale carcass

      But it seems in every way the best course of action knowing the volatility of the stuff.

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in