On Friday Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claimed to have used the company’s Claude AI model to solve the Riemann problem, perhaps the most important open quandary in mathematics.
“We have full confidence that Alpöge’s proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement,” mathematicians wrote in a joint statement by the Lean and Mathlib communities
Are we calling it “Alpöge’s proof” despite the fact that he didn’t come up with it?
I think it’s unclear how the LLM was involved, I doubt the LLM came up with it itself. It’s a tool and assisted him but he ultimately is responsible for it. If it were garbage he’s the one who will take the reputations hit.
In math, these things are attributed to those who can actually complete the proof. Maybe this could be called Alpöge’s hypothesis of the Riemann problem’s proof or something if he did come up with the idea.
I don’t think ownership is determined by whose reputation would take a hit. I mean, at this point, the Lean and Mathlib communities would also take a reputation hit if it was proved wrong, but it doesn’t make sense to name it after them.
Maybe all mathematicians that ever published anything should be credited? After all, the plagiarism machine can only predict characters based on what it’s been trained on.
Is that so weird, though? I’m drinking soda from a can that nobody made. My desk is covered with things that nobody made. Bots make tons of stuff and we don’t name those things after the bots or their operators.
You don’t HAVE to name mathematical objects after a person. We could just call it Riemann’s Theorem (a proved hypothesis is a theorem) and include the date and by-line if we need to reference a specific one in (e.g.) a bibliography.
There’s no reason to think that a “body” has to make something just because it exists and is complicated. That’s the same mistake that creationists make instead of understanding evolution.
But that’s all off-topic. The question isn’t where it came from, but who it is named after.
Comments
Are we calling it “Alpöge’s proof” despite the fact that he didn’t come up with it?
I think it’s unclear how the LLM was involved, I doubt the LLM came up with it itself. It’s a tool and assisted him but he ultimately is responsible for it. If it were garbage he’s the one who will take the reputations hit.
In math, these things are attributed to those who can actually complete the proof. Maybe this could be called Alpöge’s hypothesis of the Riemann problem’s proof or something if he did come up with the idea.
I don’t think ownership is determined by whose reputation would take a hit. I mean, at this point, the Lean and Mathlib communities would also take a reputation hit if it was proved wrong, but it doesn’t make sense to name it after them.
Yep, Alpöge should take the responsibility, and should not be allowed to have authorship on the result (as previously ruled so).
Maybe we should just call any proof that uses calculus Newton’s proof.
He has a writeup describing some of the process: https://alpo.ge/remark.pdf
if the human drives you from A to B, do we give credit to the driver or to the car?
You think Claude should be credited instead?
Maybe all mathematicians that ever published anything should be credited? After all, the plagiarism machine can only predict characters based on what it’s been trained on.
Claude isn’t a person, so no. I think if Claude did the important work, then it shouldn’t be named after anybody.
The proof just… showed up, then? Nobody made it?
Is that so weird, though? I’m drinking soda from a can that nobody made. My desk is covered with things that nobody made. Bots make tons of stuff and we don’t name those things after the bots or their operators.
You don’t HAVE to name mathematical objects after a person. We could just call it Riemann’s Theorem (a proved hypothesis is a theorem) and include the date and by-line if we need to reference a specific one in (e.g.) a bibliography.
Decolonize maths!
There’s no reason to think that a “body” has to make something just because it exists and is complicated. That’s the same mistake that creationists make instead of understanding evolution.
But that’s all off-topic. The question isn’t where it came from, but who it is named after.
That’s already long established. It’s the Riemann hypothesis, it’s right in the title.
I’m not sure what you’re suggesting at this point. When it’s published in a journal are you suggesting the byline should be left entirely blank?
Related reading: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/06/monkey-selfie-case-animal-photo-copyright
Sign in to comment. Sign in