Skip to content

Comment on US now admits Austin man deported to Mexico was a U.S. citizen

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @meco03211@lemmy.world· · edited

    I’d say it should be no one deserves qualified immunity. Other immunities can provide a benefit.

    0
    • Do you have an example where legal immunity is beneficial?

      1
      • One aspect of grooming victims for sex trafficking is coercing them into committing crimes that can then be held against them in the future. Offering them immunity can be used to elicit testimony and evidence against their traffickers.

        Generally it can be used as the carrot on a stick for lower level criminals to flip on higher ups.

        8
        • Yeah, if you don’t give immunity to people giving you information on the people causing real/more severe harm, they’re going to be disincentivized to cooperate with you. And most people aren’t monsters and still have lines they won’t cross, like that story about the thief that turned himself in so that he could tell the cops he found a ton of CSAM in the house he broke into. I don’t think it’d be morally correct to punish him, or trafficking victims, etc.

          9
        • Thats not a good example for using lawful immunity. Its a great opportunity to use prosecutorial discretion. Extraordinary circumstances is a widely accepted legal defense and already established precedent. We can acknowledge and forgive crimes committed in pursuit of a greater good, but thats no reason to throw around immunity from the law.

          There is genuinely no good reason for any entity to have any kind of legal immunity whatsoever.

          1
          • That goes out the window the first time some new DA overrides the previous DAs prosecutorial discretion and charges someone that previously revealed damming evidence against themselves.

            0
            • And with prosecutorial immunity, you cant sue that prosecutor for going back on the word of their predecessor.

              Without immunity, the prosecutor (or DA) that “overrides” the previous arrangement can be dragged into court and forced to justify their decision.

              You are so conditioned to legal immunity you dont even realize how much of a problem it is.

              0
        • Oh, I agree in cases like that. I was more thinking about immunity prior to investigation/arrest. Like qualified immunity or presidential immunity.

          I view cases like yours as not really immunity. That is still paying society for committed crimes, just not by rotting in jail (which I think is a stupid way to handle crime anyway).

          2
      • I think Parliamentary Privilege, a type of immunity given to politicians in Westminster-based systems, is mostly a good thing. It can be abused (see Barilaro v Shanks) and really should be amended to remove that potential for abuse. But at its core, it allows politicians to bring to light things which would put them at risk of being sued for defamation or charged with a variety of offences, if done outside Parliament.

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in