Skip to content

Comment on KOTOR Fan Project Rebuilds the Original RPG in Godot

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • So the license text is void because it’s actually not copyrightable. Cool.

    5
    • It’s actually quite complicated and not that straightforward. However, most of the things that would be copyrightable about it, aren’t, because it’s obviously not their IP. There may still be some aspects of it that are. Architectural decisions. Handwritten code and prose. Etc.

      Related post I made yesterday

      2
      • It’s actually quite complicated

        Actually, it’s not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality is a thing, LLM output is not creative work.

        However, most of the things that would be copyrightable about it, aren’t, because it’s obviously not their IP.

        If you mean the assets: Not part of the project.

        Architectural decisions.

        Not copyrightable.

        prose

        Yeah, show me the court decision that any LLM prompt is classified as a lyrical creation worthy of copyright protection. Tedium to prompt an LLM is not creativity.

        2
        • Architecture is absolutely copyrightable. That’s a creative form of expression. And IP extends beyond mere digital assets.

          As explained in the quote in my link: raw LLM output isn’t copyrightable, as verbatim text, but other aspects of the project may be.

          Also, you’re confusing LLM prompts with generated output; (human-authored) prompts are copyrightable.

          Edit: Also, this project isn’t source-available (I don’t think?). So the license is actually applying to the distributed bundle. But I was speaking in generalities anyways.

          2
          • Architecture is absolutely copyrightable.

            So that’s why Linux isn’t a microkernel. Minix already copyrighted being a microkernel. Sure, sure.

            (human-authored) prompts are copyrightable.

            Maybe, maybe not. Court decision please.

            Also, there must be proof of the prompts themselves being authored by humans. “Make me a copycat engine based on Godot” hardly qualifies as a poem.

            -1
            • Nothing of what I said is controversial in the legal world, and it’s all pretty well understood. Yes, your example of a one sentence prompt is likely to not be defensible; but more elaborate prompts likely are, depending on specificity and the merit of individual claims. This is a case by case thing. No court decision will be or even can be universal on something as broad as LLM prompts.

              But regardless, all of this is irrelevant to the original post.

              0
              Continue this thread 2 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in