Skip to content

Comment on T-Mobile illegally imposed 50GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says: Law requires 25Mbps home Internet. T-Mobile lowers speed to 600Kbps after 50GB cap.

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • I mean, wasn’t this discussion started by whether bits per second or bytes per second is deceptive or misleading in order to make people think “woah, bigger number means better internet” ?

    Also, how is a division or multiplication by a factor of 8 the difference between what most people do or don’t understand? It’s a primary school mathematical operation. If people cannot understand that, how are they going to understand that different downloads or uploads inside different applications provide them with different (byte-based) values depending on protocol and server performance of whatever service they are using?

    It really is the truest and simplest unit to use that the ISP can reasonably guarantee to you, because on the lowest level, whether using fibre or copper, we send bits and not bytes across the wire.

    1
    • No one who was not specifically taught this will notice the difference between Mbps and MBps since it’s the same fucking letters. Let alone know the difference is division by 8. Not everyone has formal IT education and bits never come out in daily life of most people except for internet speeds. You are expert in this field. You massively overestimate how much average people know if you think they recognize the difference and know how to convert it.

      If people cannot understand that, how are they going to understand that different downloads or uploads inside different applications provide them with different (byte-based) values depending on protocol and server performance of whatever service they are using?

      Why do you keep insisting they need to? An average person will not care much about the difference between a download taking 6 minutes or 7 minutes. They will care about the difference between 6 minutes and an hour, which is about the difference if they misinterpret bits as bytes.

      -1
      • We should NOT accommodate for the stupid if that means lying about the facts. My two cents.

        1
        • Stupid and not an expert in a specific field are two very different things. Also, it is not lying. It is the exact same facts (same number) presented differently.

          -2
          • Mm and mm are very different. Mg and mg are very different. Mbps and MB/s are very different. People lacking basic education to be able to read units properly have to deal with that themselves.

            They are not the exact same. Somebody else already talked a whole thread about the reason as to why.

            What I would argue for is every company at least all advertising the same unit, so that when comparing it becomes easier to do so.

            0
            • A whole thread and still no explanation how taking an accurate number and multiplying it by a constant to get a different representation can magically make it less accurate.

              It’s like saying a distance has to be in miles because converting it to km makes it less accurate.

              -1
              Continue this thread 4 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in